Dr. Anthony Fauci’s involvement in one of the COVID-19 pandemic’s most influential scientific papers is facing renewed scrutiny after federal health officials called for an independent review of whether he helped shape the study without receiving formal credit.
The National Institutes of Health has asked Nature Medicine to examine allegations that Fauci, former NIH Director Francis Collins and British scientist Jeremy Farrar made substantial contributions to the 2020 paper The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2 without those roles being properly disclosed.
Published in March 2020, the study concluded that the available evidence did not indicate the virus had been deliberately engineered or manipulated in a laboratory.
NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya is now seeking a formal review of whether the three men helped influence the manuscript behind the scenes and whether their involvement should have been acknowledged under scientific authorship rules.
There is no current indication that Fauci violated the law. The inquiry instead focuses on potential ethical issues, including whether undisclosed contributions breached standards for authorship, attribution and transparency in scientific publishing.
The letter, obtained by German outlet WELT5, also asks Nature Medicine to determine whether the paper should be corrected or retracted.
Kristian Andersen, Andrew Rambaut, Ian Lipkin, Edward Holmes and Robert Garry were listed as the paper’s five authors.
The NIH has asked Nature Medicine to investigate claims that Fauci and others made major contributions to the 2020 paper The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2 without those contributions being properly disclosed
The dispute reaches back to the first weeks of the pandemic, when scientists were racing to determine how the virus emerged and whether it might have escaped from a laboratory in Wuhan, China
NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya has requested a formal review of whether the three men influenced the manuscript and whether their roles should have been disclosed
According to a letter described in the October 1 HHS advisory opinion on authorship and attribution, NIH correspondence indicates that Farrar organized the February 1, 2020 call involving Fauci, Collins and several of the paper’s authors. He also remained involved as the study progressed.
The advisory opinion states that Fauci and Collins reviewed early drafts and discussed scientific questions, while Farrar helped coordinate the drafting and distribution of the manuscript and made at least one direct edit.
DISCOVER MORE: Family of Los Angeles Teen Who Died After School Jump Challenges Official Findings
The dispute began during the earliest stage of the pandemic, as researchers sought to determine how COVID-19 emerged and whether the virus could have escaped from a laboratory in Wuhan, China.
The Proximal Origin paper was cited extensively by public health officials, journalists and politicians who rejected the idea that the virus had been intentionally engineered in a laboratory.
Fauci, who at the time led the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, referred to the study during a White House briefing in April 2020 while discussing the origins of COVID-19.
Since then, the publication has become a major flashpoint in the politically charged debate over whether government officials and scientists dismissed the lab-leak theory too quickly.
Republican investigators have previously claimed that Fauci and Collins influenced the paper’s drafting and release in an effort to weaken the lab-leak explanation.
The scientists involved, along with Democratic investigators, have disputed those allegations.
During testimony before the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic, co-author Kristian Andersen rejected the claim that Fauci had directed the team to produce a paper disproving a laboratory leak. Andersen said the early discussions were aimed at evaluating competing scientific explanations.
Democratic investigators have also cited interviews with the authors in which they said Fauci and Collins did not lead, supervise or direct the paper’s drafting.
The NIH request does not conclude that Fauci ghostwrote the study or that its scientific findings were knowingly inaccurate.
Rather, it renews attention on whether the contributions of outside participants were fully disclosed in accordance with accepted publishing standards.
Nature Medicine has been asked to conduct an independent review and decide whether the scientific record requires any correction or other action.
The paper remains in publication as debate continues over COVID-19’s origins, the influence of government scientists and the treatment of scientific dissent years after the pandemic began.