Share this @internewscast.com

SAN FRANCISCO — A federal judge on Monday threw out a lawsuit filed last year by Elon Musk’s X platform against the nonprofit organization Center for Countering Digital Hate. 

U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer dismissed the lawsuit and wrote that it was an attempt to silence the center for its reports about rising hate speech and conspiracy theories on X. 

“This case is about punishing the Defendants for their speech,” the judge wrote. 

In a statement Monday, X said that it disagreed with Breyer’s decision and planned to appeal. 

Musk, who has called himself a free speech absolutist, targeted the Center for Countering Digital Hate after it released a report called “Toxic Twitter” last year, when X was known as Twitter. That report said that Twitter under Musk’s ownership had reinstated the accounts of previously suspended “neo-Nazis, white supremacists, misogynists and spreaders of dangerous conspiracy theories,” and that Twitter stood to profit from additional advertising as a result. 

X sued the center and a separate nonprofit, the European Climate Foundation, which X’s lawyers said conspired with the center to illegally obtain data about the platform’s advertising. The lawsuit said that the organizations had “cherry-picked” information and that they were unlawfully interfering with X’s relationship with advertisers. 

But Breyer wrote in his ruling that X was simply trying to silence its critics, saying that X’s suit violated a California law barring litigation that is designed to punish free speech, cases that are also known as “strategic lawsuits against public participation” or SLAPP. 

“X Corp.’s motivation in bringing this case is evident. X Corp. has brought this case in order to punish CCDH for CCDH publications that criticized X Corp. — and perhaps in order to dissuade others who might wish to engage in such criticism,” Breyer wrote. 

“Although X Corp. accuses CCDH of trying ‘to censor viewpoints that CCDH disagrees with,’ it is X Corp. that demands ‘at least tens of millions of dollars’ in damages — presumably enough to torpedo the operations of a small nonprofit — because of the views expressed in the nonprofit’s publications,” he added. 

“If CCDH’s publications were defamatory, that would be one thing, but X Corp. has carefully avoided saying that they are.” 

The Center for Countering Digital Hate celebrated the dismissal and said that Musk had tried to “weaponize the courts to censor good-faith research and reporting.” 

“A huge win for everyone working to hold social media giants to account,” the center said on X. 

“We’ll continue to expose hate & lies wherever we see them and to stand for independent research,” it said. 

Breyer in a separate ruling also dismissed the claims against the European Climate Foundation. The foundation did not immediately respond to a request for comment. 

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
JSO: Man found dead with 'multiple' blunt-force injuries at Jacksonville apartment complex

JSO: Man Discovered Deceased with Severe Blunt-Force Injuries at Jacksonville Apartment Community

The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office says multiple people were detained when officers responded…
Rob McElhenney shortens name to Rob Mac: 'Purely practical'

Rob McElhenney Shortens Name to Rob Mac for Practical Reasons

“The amount of time that I have wasted trying to get people…
Two hikers on the summit of Mount Whitney holding a sign.

14-Year-Old Overcomes Altitude-Induced Hallucinations During Descent from America’s Tallest Mountain as Father Observes

THE father of a teen who fell off a 120-foot cliff gave…
Bryan Kohberger could escape death penalty because of leaked evidence aired during TV episode: fmr prosecutor

Bryan Kohberger anticipated to enter guilty plea: what happens next

Bryan Kohberger, the suspect in the Idaho murders case, is anticipated to…
Honolulu water board sues Navy for $1.2B over fuel leak that contaminated drinking water

Honolulu Water Authority Files $1.2 Billion Lawsuit Against Navy Over Fuel Leak Contaminating Drinking Water

On Tuesday, the Honolulu Board of Water Supply (BWS) initiated a federal…
Kate Middleton admits she's 'not able to function normally' after cancer treatment

Kate Middleton Reveals Struggles with Functioning Normally Post-Cancer Treatment

Kate Middleton made an emotional admission about her life post-cancer treatment. While…
Inside Taylor Swift, Travis Kelce's 'wonderful' lunch date near his hometown

Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce Enjoy a Delightful Lunch Date Near His Hometown

Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift going out near his Ohio hometown hits…
Immigration news: Judge blocks order barring asylum access at border, gives President Trump's administration 2 weeks to appeal

Judge Halts Order Restricting Asylum Access, Allows Two-Week Appeal Window for Trump Administration

WASHINGTON — On Wednesday, a federal judge ruled that President Donald Trump’s…
Mugshot of Travis Caleb Decker, wanted for murder.

DNA Discovery on Handprints Intensifies Travis Decker Murder Investigation Amid Exhaustive Five-Week Search

POLICE have new evidence that links a father to the murder scene…
Woman holding a photo of a younger woman with a bird.

Virginia Giuffre’s Family Shares Heartbreaking Note to Her Children Amidst Custody Battle With ‘Abusive’ Husband Robert

VIRGINIA Giuffre left her three children a heartbreaking final letter before her…
Diddy trial: Jury in Sean Combs' sex trafficking trial to resume deliberations after reaching partial verdict

Diddy Court Case: Jury to Continue Deliberations After Partial Verdict in Sean Combs’ Sex Trafficking Trial

NEW YORK — The jury in Sean “Diddy” Combs’ sex trafficking trial…
Federal judge orders Mexican migrant seeking asylum to be released by ICE

U.S. Judge Mandates ICE to Release Mexican Asylum Seeker

A federal judge in Oregon has mandated the immediate release of a…