Share this @internewscast.com
Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer

Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer. (Image via Jeff Kowalsky/AFP/Getty Images)

The men accused of plotting to kidnap Michigan’s Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer lost a motion to dismiss their indictment on Tuesday, as a federal judge found they did not meet their “heavy burden” to show entrapment.

“Domestic Terrorism”

Made public amid national turmoil in late 2020, the case of the men accused of conspiring to abduct Whitmer appeared to symbolize militant anti-government sentiment and anger over COVID-19 restrictions boiling over among far-right groups across the country.

The FBI claimed that the men surveilled Whitmer’s vacation home earlier that year, casing possible locations to detonate a bomb to distract authorities.

Federal prosecutors leveled weapons of mass destruction charges against the accused plotters Adam Fox, Barry Croft Jr., and Daniel Joseph Harris, characterizing the alleged plot as one of “domestic terrorism.” The trio were first indicted on lesser charges in December 2020, along with Kaleb FranksBrandon Caserta, and Ty Garbin. Garbin pleaded guilty to the kidnapping plot in January 2021, receiving a more than six-year prison sentence.

Complications in the case started to surface with the publication of a BuzzFeed News article about the role of a government informant, suggesting that the government knew about the plot through the duration.

Then, late last year, their defense attorney tried to turn the case on its head, depicting it as one about the “egregious overreaching by the government’s agents.”

“The key to the government’s plan was to turn general discontent with Governor Whitmer’s COVID-19 restrictions into a crime that could be prosecuted,” their attorneys wrote late December. “The government picked what it knew would be a sensational charge: conspiracy to kidnap the governor. When the government was faced with evidence showing that the defendants had no interest in a kidnapping plot, it refused to accept failure and continued to push its plan.”

“Setting Up a Ruse”

The Western District of Michigan’s Chief U.S. District Judge Robert J. Jonker, a George W. Bush appointee, rejected the defendants’ argument — at least at this stage.

“They must show that the undisputed evidence demonstrates both government inducement and a patently clear absence of predisposition as a matter of law,” Jonker wrote. “Defendants fail to carry their burden because the evidence on both issues is decidedly disputed as it almost inevitably is at this stage of the case.”

The judge added that the defense lawyers did not furnish a “single case” in which a court dismissed an indictment on entrapment grounds during this phase of the case.

Though the men’s attorneys claimed the government “conceived and controlled every aspect of the alleged plot,” the judge wrote “simply setting up a ruse—even an extended one—or running a confidential source, or even proposing a criminal act is not enough.”

Even at a trial, criminal defendants face a high bar to launch a successful entrapment defense, which requires them to show government inducement and their lack of predisposition to commit the crime. Juries are often reluctant to acquit criminal defendants who allegedly agree to commit sensational crimes of terrorism based on allegations that a government agent goaded them to do it.

Christopher M. Gibbons, an attorney representing lead defendant Fox for the Michigan-based Gibbons & Boer firm, did not immediately respond to Law&Crime’s email requesting comment.

Read the ruling, below:

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Source: This post first appeared on

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Gainesville resident detained for threatening two individuals with a gun at Cabana Beach Apartments

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Last night, 33-year-old Naytrellis Naytravone Enoch was…

New Revelations Unveiled in ‘God’s Misfits’ Murder Plot

Clockwise from top left: Tad Bert Cullum, Tifany Machel Adams, Cora Twombly,…

Breaking News: Haircut Ends in Tragedy as Texas Man Fatally Shot, Suspect Commits Suicide

A man has succumbed to his injuries after being shot multiple times…

Georgia Teen Allegedly Kills Parents and Seeks Sympathy on TikTok, Contacts True Crime Influencer: Report

Teenager Sarah Grace Patrick from Georgia, who is accused of murdering her…

Man Sentenced for Setting Ex on Fire After Dousing Her in Vodka

Inset: Daniel N. Pace (Peoria County Jail). The apartment complex where Pace…

Judge Overturns Trump’s Anti-Transgender Passport Policy

President Donald Trump addresses the media alongside Elon Musk in the Oval…

Man Suspected of DUI Involved in Separate Incidents Resulting in Deaths of Boy and Woman, Police Report

Inset left: Braylen Hardy (GoFundMe) Inset right: Antonio Tremayne Weldon, Jr. (Jefferson…

“The Fourth Amendment Isn’t a Recent Concept”

A California federal court has halted the Trump administration from executing immigration…

Four Individuals Accused of Kidnapping and Assaulting Bushwalker

Four people have been charged after a bushwalker was allegedly kidnapped and…

Hawthorne Resident Arrested for Threatening Driver with a Gun Following Accident

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Andrew Manuel Cabeza, aged 38 and a…

Son Reportedly Confessed to Killing Family and Dog

Background: The site in New Mexico where the remains of Mestre’s mother,…

Florida Woman Accused of Stealing Car from Expectant Mother

Inset: Chanel Anderson (Osceola County Corrections). Background: Big Dan”s Car Wash in…