Judge Dismisses Lawsuit Challenging Florida's Law to Dissolve Disney’s Special District
3.9k Share this

A federal judge dismissed a lawsuit challenging Gov. Ron DeSantis’s (R-FL) law to dissolve Disney’s special governing and tax district.

Three residents of Orange and Osceola counties claimed S.B. 4-C, the law that eliminates Disneys’ special tax district, threatens with higher taxes, limits free speech, and violates a contractual obligation.

William Sanchez, a Miami lawyer and Senate Democrat candidate, filed the suit last week.

U.S. District Court Judge Cecilia Altonaga ruled there were many reasons to dismiss the lawsuit, including the lack of standing over state issues.

Anltonaga wrote that the residents “do not plausibly allege they have suffered any concrete injury as a result of the alleged violation of Disney’s First Amendment rights, and nothing in the Complaint shows Plaintiffs have a close relationship with Disney.”

The judge also dismissed claims that dissolving the Disney corporate carveout, otherwise known as the Reedy Creek Improvement District, would limit free speech:

Far from it: Plaintiffs expressly allege that they “expect Disney and the State of Florida to litigate this matter for a significant period of time[.]” That fact alone warrants dismissal. See, e.g., Harris, 20 F.3d at 1124–25 (holding that case must be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction because plaintiff failed to show that non-parties whose First Amendment rights were allegedly violated faced hindrance in asserting their rights).

Another notable exception to the general principle that a party may not sue for violations of others’ constitutional rights applies in the First Amendment context. But that exception relaxes traditional standing requirements only when a litigant asserts a claim of First Amendment overbreadth. Plaintiffs assert no such claim here. They instead allege what is in essence a First Amendment retaliation claim on Disney’s behalf. And First Amendment retaliation claims do not qualify for watered-down third-party standing standards.

Altonaga also said that none of the plaintiff’s claims were “ripe” because the legislation does not take effect until July 2022.

In reaction to the ruling, Sanchez promised to refile another challenge on behalf of the plaintiffs by next week.

“This is just the beginning of the battle, as we are attempting to achieve justice for Florida taxpayers,” Sanchez said in a statement.

DeSantis and Florida state legislators pushed for the legislation to strip Disney of its special corporate carveout after the megacorporation opposed DeSantis’s Parental Rights in Education Act. This also comes as Disney promised to inject inject “many, many, many LGBTQIA characters in its stories.”

Ron DeSantis / Rumble

Gov. DeSantis vowed in late April that Floridians would not have to pay for Disney’s debt. He said that dissolving Disney’s carveout was in reaction to the megacompany injecting “pansexualism” into its programming for younger audiences and attacking Florida parents.

The case is Michael Foronda v. Ron DeSantis in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida.

Sean Moran is a congressional reporter for Breitbart News. Follow him on Twitter @SeanMoran3

3.9k Share this
You May Also Like

Manchester City footballer Benjamin Mendy arrives at court

Manchester City footballer Benjamin Mendy arrives at court ahead of trial accused…

Myleene Klass, Charlotte Hawkins and Alex Jones arrive for the RHS Chelsea Flower Show

Myleene Klass, Charlotte Hawkins and Alex Jones kickstarted the new week by…

Floral fancy! Princess Beatrice is elegant in £248 white and blue Reformation dress

Princess Beatrice and Edo Mapelli Mozzi looked every inch the glamorous power…

Villagers launch £11,000 appeal to save one of Britain’s oldest trees

One of Britain’s oldest trees is in danger of collapse after being…

Is the door closing on children’s jails? Axing young offender institutions is part of major review

Is the door closing on children’s jails? Axing young offender institutions is…

Beto Crashes Gov. Abbott’s Conference on Texas School Shooting

Texas gubernatorial hopeful Robert Francis “Beto” O’Rourke (D) took the opportunity to…

Man, 62, dies after being bitten by a dog at a house in Wrexham – with animal euthanised at scene

Man, 62, is mauled to death by a dog at a house…

Rowan Atkinson upsets Cotswolds neighbours with fireworks for his girlfriend’s 40th birthday party

Rowan Atkinson upsets Cotswolds neighbours with fireworks for his girlfriend’s 40th birthday…