Trump admin can keep immigrant grad student locked up: Judge
Share this @internewscast.com

Inset: Mahmoud Khalil addressing the press (WCBS). Background: President Donald Trump attentively listens during a cabinet session at the White House in Washington, as Secretary of State Marco Rubio speaks, dated Monday, March 24, 2025 (Pool via AP).

A U.S. federal judge has refused to mandate the release of a Columbia University graduate student detained by immigration agents, although he legally resides in the country with a green card. The judge stated that the student must provide evidence to “demonstrate” how his detention inflicts “irreparable harm” on him, notwithstanding the judge’s opinion that it was “likely” unconstitutional.

“He has failed to submit the necessary evidence required for the different claims he needs to substantiate,” commented U.S. District Judge Michael Farbiarz in a ruling issued Wednesday from New Jersey.

The American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC), along with co-counsel, is suing President Donald Trump and the Department of Homeland Security on behalf of Mahmoud Khalil, a 30-year-old who was detained on March 8 and is now facing deportation for what Homeland Security claims is a violation of Trump’s orders, which call for the removal of anyone deemed a “national security and public safety threat.”

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

A government memo obtained by NBC News said Khalil was told this by the Trump administration: “The Secretary of State has determined that your presence or activities in the United States would have serious adverse foreign policy consequences for the United States.”

His lawyers say the Trump administration has “unconstitutionally silenced” Khalil and others living in the U.S. from “speaking, hearing, or engaging with viewpoints critical of the U.S. government” through deportation and other means.

Khalil and two other plaintiffs claim they “fear government retaliation for engaging in constitutionally protected expression critical of U.S. foreign policy and supportive of Palestinian human rights.” This includes ceasing interactions with one another in public and isolating themselves, “fearing that their associations may draw scrutiny” and various punishments, their lawsuit says, including deportation and criminal prosecution.

Khalil has been in ICE custody in Louisiana since his arrest on March 8. His lawyers argue that the efforts to deport him violate his due process rights and should be “void for vagueness,” according to their March 17 motion for preliminary injunctive relief.

“The Petitioner is likely to succeed on the merits of this unconstitutional vagueness argument,” Farbiarz, a Joe Biden appointee, said Wednesday. “But this does not entitle him to a preliminary injunction.”

More from Law&Crime: ‘Not for unelected judges to decide’: Trump admin says tariffs are ‘immune from judicial scrutiny’ as it appeals order blocking levies

According to Farbiarz, while the government’s actions were “likely” unconstitutional — with Secretary of State Marco Rubio improperly using Trump’s statutes and “arbitrary enforcement” to detain him — Khalil still has to prove why he should be released before a final judgment is handed down. Farbiarz said he has not, so he will remain locked up for the time being.

“The Secretary’s determination deserves, and gets the highest respect,” Farbiarz explained. “But arbitrary enforcement can also be a danger, when one person is given the job, if his determination veers too far away from the standard set down by Congress. Here, the Secretary’s did.”

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Trump Administration Files Lawsuit Against California Over Increased Egg Prices

Left: President Donald Trump addresses a lunch gathering with African leaders in…

Man Caught on Camera Before Shooting Claims Memory Loss: Police

Background: The apartment complex in Rochester, Minn. where the alleged shooting took…

Botched Botox Procedure Causes Facial Paralysis in Patient: Police Report

Left: Rosa Mena. Right, top and bottom: An illegal “Med Spa” Mena…

Original ‘Gone Girl’ Sherri Papini’s Strange Reversal: Insists on Kidnapping Story After Serving Time for Fake Abduction

Sherri Papini was jailed for admitting that her supposed 2016 kidnapping was…

Husband Charged in Death of Doctor Found in House Fire: District Attorney

Background: News footage of the January house fire in San Marino, Calif.…

E. Jean Carroll Wins Another Court Battle Against Trump

Left: E. Jean Carroll, a former magazine columnist, enters a vehicle outside…

Intoxicated Oklahoma Woman Falls Asleep and Accidentally Suffocates Newborn Twin After Consuming White Claw Seltzers: Authorities

An Oklahoma woman is facing charges after police say she fell asleep…

Woman fatally shot her partner in the head, then transported the body in her car

Left: Tahj Matthias Ji’Reh Wall (Mecklenburg County Sheriff’s Office). Right: Melvin Hopper…

Family of woman purportedly killed by roommate initiates lawsuit

Tamilore Odunsi (GoFundMe). The family of a Texas nursing student, who was…

DOJ Claims Rifle Was Obtained with Assistance by Trump Assassination Plotter

Left: Donald Trump playing golf at Turnberry golf course during his visit…

Individual Attacks Victim in Throat in Store Checkout Queue

Backdrop: The Spinx convenience store located at 498 The Parkway in Greenville…

Travis Decker: Authorities Locate Hiker Resembling Fugitive, Closing Idaho Manhunt for Child Killer

The U.S. Marshals task force has called off its pursuit of Travis…