Internewscast Journal
  • Home
  • US News
  • Local News
  • Health
  • People
  • Guest Post
  • Support Our Cause
Internewscast Journal
  • Home
  • US News
  • Local News
  • Health
  • People
  • Guest Post
  • Support Our Cause
Home Local news 100 Years After a Man Was Convicted for Teaching Evolution, the Debate on Religion in Schools Continues
  • Local news

100 Years After a Man Was Convicted for Teaching Evolution, the Debate on Religion in Schools Continues

    A century after a man was convicted of teaching evolution, the debate on religion in schools rages
    Up next
    Chinese satellites complete groundbreaking mission 22,000 miles above Earth
    Chinese Satellites Achieve Revolutionary Milestone 22,000 Miles in Space
    Published on 10 July 2025
    Author
    Internewscast
    Tags
    • After,
    • Century,
    • Clarence Darrow,
    • convicted,
    • Daniel Mach,
    • debate,
    • Education,
    • evolution,
    • Greg Abbott,
    • Holly Meyer,
    • James Hudnut-Beumler,
    • John T. Scopes,
    • man,
    • Mary Elizabeth Castle,
    • Politics,
    • rages,
    • Religion,
    • Robert H. Tuttle,
    • schools,
    • science,
    • Suzanne Rosenblith,
    • Teaching,
    • The,
    • U.S. news,
    • was,
    • William Jennings Bryan
    Share this @internewscast.com
    FacebookXRedditPinterest

    NASHVILLE, Tenn. – A century ago, a public high school educator faced trial in Dayton, Tennessee, for teaching the concept of human evolution. The effects of this event are still evident nationally today.

    The court records identify the case as State of Tennessee v. John T. Scopes. It is famously referred to as the “Monkey Trial.” This proceeding escalated into a national spectacle, featuring a courtroom clash between a prominent, agnostic defense lawyer and a well-known fundamentalist Christian politician who supported the Bible on the stand.

    In a sweltering, pre-air conditioning courtroom, the trial became a linchpin for a tense debate that wasn’t just a small-town aberration.

    “This is a broad-based culture war of which the Scopes trial is just one place lightning struck,” states James Hudnut-Beumler, a professor specializing in American religious history at Vanderbilt University in Nashville, Tennessee.

    Today, new state laws requiring the display of the Ten Commandments in public school classrooms are facing legal challenges. As the Supreme Court leans right, there is an ongoing conservative push to infuse more religion — often Christianity — into taxpayer-funded education. Advocates of religious diversity and church-state separation are countering it in capitols, courts and public squares.

    “We are fighting on an almost daily basis,” says Robert Tuttle, a religion and law professor at George Washington University Law School in Washington, D.C.

    That Tennessee jury found Scopes guilty of violating the state’s Butler Act — of teaching “any theory that denies the story of the Divine Creation of man as taught in the Bible.”

    A century later, the role of religion in public schools — and whether to keep it out entirely — is still being fiercely debated.

    Some perceive a threat to their spot in the culture

    While attempts to interlace America and the divine are not new, from the last half of the 20th century to today they are driven by a perceived threat among white Christians who think their dominant spot in politics and culture is being eroded by secularism or multiculturalism, Tuttle says.

    Other recent examples of the debate over religion in schools include adding chaplains and Bibles to classrooms, infusing designated prayer time into the school day and expanding voucher programs that can be used at religious schools. At the Supreme Court, the justices effectively stopped the first taxpayer-funded Catholic charter school and gave parents a religious exemption for LGBTQ+-related instruction.

    Tuttle’s scholarship was used in the recent federal appeals court ruling that declared Louisiana’s Ten Commandments law unconstitutional, citing a similar Kentucky law the Supreme Court ruled against in 1980.

    Tuttle and his co-author, Ira Lupu, assert that the principles underlying the Establishment Clause — the First Amendment’s ban on the government establishing a religion — remain alive despite arguments that cite a change made in a 2022 school prayer ruling by the Supreme Court.

    “We have good reasons not to concede the battlefield to the forces aimed at eliminating the idea of a secular state,” their article states. “When they overclaim their victories, others should speak up.”

    The day after the court ruling, Republican Gov. Greg Abbott signed the Texas Ten Commandments bill that had easily passed the GOP-controlled state legislature. Lawsuits have been filed to block it and the Arkansas law that was approved earlier this year.

    Abbott has taken on a Ten Commandments issue before. He reiterated his support for the new law while celebrating the 20th anniversary of his 2005 Supreme Court victory that prevented efforts to tear down the Commandments monument on the grounds of the state Capitol.

    “I will always defend the historical connection between the Ten Commandments and their influence on the history of Texas,” he says in a video posted on X.

    Texas Values, a conservative Christian law and policy nonprofit, rallied support for the Texas bill. If other ideals are shared in the classroom, the Ten Commandments should be able to be shared as well, says Mary Elizabeth Castle, director of government relations for the organization.

    A similar argument was made in 1922 by Scopes prosecutor William Jennings Bryan, a onetime populist firebrand who became the face of the anti-evolution movement.

    “If the Bible cannot be taught, why should Christian taxpayers permit the teaching of guesses that make the Bible a lie?” Bryan wrote in The New York Times. “A teacher might just as well write over the door of his room, ‘Leave Christianity behind you, all ye who enter here.’”

    The arc of the religion-in-schools debate is long

    About 60 years earlier, advances in biblical criticism caused conservative Christians to double down on rejecting anything they believe conflicted with their interpretation of the Bible, human evolution included, says Hudnut-Beumler. He blames weaponized post-World War I rhetoric for spreading anti-evolution beliefs to legislation. He sees parallels to today.

    “Whatever we’re going through now,” he says, “it’s the product of people manufacturing rhetoric in a way that stokes fear.”

    Castle sees the 2022 school prayer decision as a step in the right direction. “There’s always just going to be that conflict where people are trying to trample on religious freedom,” she says, “and so that’s why we do the work that we do.”

    The American Civil Liberties Union, joined by other legal groups, is representing the families in Louisiana, Arkansas and Texas that sued to block new Ten Commandments laws. A much younger ACLU, boosted by the star power of defense attorney Clarence Darrow, represented Scopes, who agreed to be a test case challenging the Butler Act and to bring attention to Dayton.

    Daniel Mach, who directs the ACLU program on freedom of religion and belief, sees a through line between 1925 and what he describes as a present-day assault on the separation of church and state.

    “There are those who want to use the machinery of the state — and in particular, our public schools — to impose their religious beliefs on everyone else,” Mach says. “The constitutional guarantee of church-state separation has served us as a nation quite well over the years in general. And there’s simply no reason to turn back the clock now.”

    In 1925, the ACLU lost the Scopes case. It would be more than 40 years before the Supreme Court would overrule an anti-evolution teaching ban. But the trial, which took place from July 10-21, dealt a big hit to Bryan’s reputation. He died days after it ended.

    Though a brief legal circus, the trial inflamed social divisions. Conservatives and fundamentalists in the Midwest and South felt mocked by those they considered liberal, East Coast elites. “They were humiliated,” Tuttle says. “That’s internalized, and it carries through.”

    In the 1940s, tensions flared with a school funding case before the Supreme Court. They returned in the 1960s when the justices ruled against school-sponsored prayer and Bible readings. It was upsetting, Tuttle says, to conservative Christians who saw schools as a source of morality.

    “The link you see with the Scopes case is a sense of alienation and devaluing of what civic experience means to them,” he says.

    Suzanne Rosenblith, an expert on religion in public education at the University at Buffalo in New York, sees the wave of court cases as primarily First Amendment tensions.

    “Your argument for removing something can be seen as ensuring that Congress makes no law respecting the establishment of religion. And my wanting something included, that’s my way of exercising my right to religious freedom,” she says. “And it could be on the same issue.”

    A lesson to be learned from the last 100 years, Rosenblith says, is that America remains a pluralist democracy and needs to be approached as such.

    “All sides are going to win some and lose some,” she says. “But how can we treat each other, especially those with whom we disagree on these significant issues, how do we treat each other more seriously?”

    ___

    Holly Meyer is global religion news editor for The Associated Press. AP’s religion coverage receives support through the AP’s collaboration with The Conversation US, with funding from Lilly Endowment Inc. The AP is solely responsible for this content.

    Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.

    Share this @internewscast.com
    FacebookXRedditPinterest
    You May Also Like
    Trump plans to tour Texas flood damage as the scope of the disaster tests his pledge to shutter FEMA
    • Local news

    Trump Set to Visit Texas to Assess Flood Damage as the Disaster Challenges His Promise to Close FEMA

    WASHINGTON (AP) — As President Donald Trump travels to Texas on Friday…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    Fifth defendant in U of I pro-Palestine protest pleads guilty
    • Local news

    Fifth Participant in University of Iowa Pro-Palestine Protest Enters Guilty Plea

    URBANA, Ill. (WCIA) — A second individual involved in the disturbances at…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    'Got the baby!': Good Samaritan saves 7-month-old girl abandoned in Little Italy after carjacking
    • Local news

    “Hero Rescues Abandoned 7-Month-Old Girl Following Little Italy Carjacking”

    CHICAGO (WGN) — Last Thursday, Earl Abernathy was stuck in traffic on…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    Asian shares are mixed after Wall Street closes higher and edges to more records
    • Local news

    Asian Markets Show Mixed Performance Following Wall Street’s Record-Breaking Close

    MANILA – Asian markets displayed mixed results amid cautious trading on Friday.…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    Trump-Harvard fight escalates after president said deal was close
    • Local news

    Tensions Rise Between Trump and Harvard Following President’s Claims of Imminent Agreement

    (The Hill) — The Trump administration is intensifying its conflict with Harvard…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    San Diego renters turn to 'speed roommating' as rent increases
    • Local news

    San Diego Renters Embrace ‘Speed Roommating’ Amid Rising Rent

    SAN DIEGO (KUSI) Since last year, rent rates increased by 4.1% in…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    South Korea, US and Japan hold aerial drill in demonstration of strength against North Korea
    • Local news

    South Korea, US, and Japan Conduct Joint Aerial Exercise to Showcase Strength Against North Korea

    SEOUL – Senior military leaders from South Korea, the U.S., and Japan…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    Several roads flooded, power outages across Coastal Empire, Lowcountry
    • Local news

    Flooded Roads and Power Outages Hit Coastal Empire and Lowcountry

    SAVANNAH, Ga. () — Officials warned residents of several roads across Chatham…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    Rubio to meet China's foreign minister in Malaysia as US-Chinese tensions mount
    • Local news

    Rubio Set to Meet China’s Foreign Minister in Malaysia Amid Escalating US-China Tensions

    KUALA LUMPUR – U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio is concluding his…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    Tear gas deployed during protest at immigration raid in Ventura County
    • Local news

    Tear Gas Used at Protest Against Immigration Raid in Ventura County

    Editor’s note: affiliate KTLA reached out to the U.S. Department of Homeland…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    Blue-state leaders weigh new laws to deal with financial fallout from Trump's big bill
    • Local news

    Leaders in Blue States Consider New Legislation to Address Financial Impact of Trump’s Major Bill

    State legislators are rushing to address the anticipated financial impact of President…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    Trump to hit Canada with 35 percent tariff
    • Local news

    Trump Proposes 35% Tariff on Canada

    President Trump announced Thursday his administration would impose a 35 percent tariff…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    Woman charged in St. Augustine stabbing due back in court after ruled competent
    • US

    Woman Accused in St. Augustine Stabbing Scheduled to Return to Court Following Competency Ruling

    Arieana Gibbs, aged 22, had previously been deemed unfit to stand trial…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    Andre Agassi snaps at commentator over celebrity Wimbledon questions
    • US

    Andre Agassi Responds Firmly to Commentator’s Celebrity Wimbledon Inquiries

    Andre Agassi is at Wimbledon to talk tennis, not to fawn over…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    Man who shot his estranged wife to death is found guilty
    • Crime

    Man Convicted for Fatally Shooting Estranged Wife

    Background: News footage captures the aftermath of the incident where Tony Morris…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    Blue logo for BravoCon 2025
    • Celeb

    Madison LeCroy Shares Baby Teddi’s Homecoming Date

    The countdown is on. Madison LeCroy’s baby girl, Teddi, is set to…
    • Internewscast
    • July 11, 2025
    Internewscast Journal
    • Home
    • Privacy Policy
    • DMCA Notice
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Guest Post
    • Support Our Cause
    Copyright 2023. All Right Reserverd.