Roe 'Was Fragile' and Ginsburg Warned About That
3.9k Share this



On Friday’s “PBS NewsHour,” New York Times columnist David Brooks argued that Roe v. Wade was always a “fragile” ruling and pointed out that former Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg expressed similar concerns about the decision back in 1992. Brooks also argued that it was always a risky proposition to hang abortion’s legality on the Roe decision and it’s important to note that there is a difference between arguing abortion is a constitutional right and arguing for its legality as a matter of policy.

Brooks said, “Ruth Bader Ginsburg made this point back in 1992, that that decision was so big, she said it’s fragile. It’s — and then law professors, even very pro-choice law professors, have always said, we’re worried about this decision. It’s not a great decision. They liked the outcome. They worried about the decision. So, it was fragile. And so, hanging all that on that decision was always going to be — it was waiting to go off. And then Alito just ran through it. I — personally — there are two separate issues here: Should abortion be a right that people get to enjoy? Should — does the Constitution guarantee that right? And it’s important to separate those two things.”

Follow Ian Hanchett on Twitter @IanHanchett



3.9k Share this
You May Also Like

Lewis Hamilton faces Monaco ban if he refuses to take out nose piercing

Lewis Hamilton faces a BAN from racing at Monaco this weekend if…

Share trading craze hit by cost of living crisis, warns AJ Bell boss

The worsening cost of living crisis has dampened small investors’ enthusiasm for…

Rishi Sunak made Vardy’s credit card binges look tame: HENRY DEEDES on Chancellor’s spending spree

Rishi Sunak made Rebekah Vardy’s credit card binges look tame: HENRY DEEDES…

World Health Assembly to Increase W.H.O. Funding by as Much as $600 Million a Year

The World Health Assembly, which is the decision-making body of the World…

Meghan Markle Visits Uvalde in Personal Tribute to Shooting Victims

Meghan Markle paid a personal visit Thursday to a memorial for the…

Yankees’ Josh Donaldson Apologizes to Jackie Robinson’s Widow Over ‘Inappropriate’ Remark

Yankees third baseman Josh Donaldson formally apologized to the widow of famed…

Pets like hamsters and guinea pigs could be CULLED to stop monkeypox spread under new guidance

Pets could be culled to protect from monkeypox under ‘last resort’ guidelines…

Media Try to Blame FDA for Biden’s Baby Formula Shortage

His Fraudulency Joe Biden’s baby formula shortage is such an unmitigated disaster,…