Judge will toss Jan. 6 defendant's case after Trump pardon
Share this @internewscast.com

Pictured left to right: Elias Costianes (Justice Department). A purported image of Elias Costianes within the U.S. Capitol during the January 6 incident (Justice Department). Background: Pictured left to right: Elias Costianes (Justice Department). A purported image of Elias Costianes within the U.S. Capitol during the January 6 incident (Justice Department). Background: President Donald Trump smiles while delivering remarks in the Oval Office of the White House, Tuesday, May 20, 2025, in Washington (AP Photo/Alex Brandon).

A federal judge in Baltimore eventually agreed with the government’s request and implemented President Donald Trump’s broad pardon for January 6 defendants to cover a man’s related but separate gun charge.

In a concise four-page memorandum and order, U.S. District Judge James Kelleher Bredar, appointed by Barack Obama, chose not to elaborate on the details – instead, pointing readers to his previous orders.

Still, the judge offered a brief summary to say that after some lengthy procedural wrangling up and down the court system, the parties, making good on their last chance, complied with the correct rule of federal civil procedure. Bredar was then obligated to dismiss the case – despite repeatedly registering strong misgivings about the proposed dismissal.

“This Court then concluded that the Pardon does not apply, and directed additional briefing with respect to the Rule 48 Motion,” the memorandum reads. “The Court now grants the Rule 48 Motion.”

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

The timeline of what, exactly, occurred before either party sought to apply the 45th and 47th president’s pardon to the gun crime case is instructive to the judge’s long askance view of the pardon request.

In February 2021, the defendant, Elias Costianes, was brought up on firearms charges following the execution of warrants by federal agents investigating the Jan. 6 riots at the U.S. Capitol Complex. At roughly the same time, federal prosecutors also brought a formally separate case, directly based on allegations that Costianes joined the pro-Trump mob at the Capitol and filmed himself inside the building.

In September 2023, Costianes pleaded guilty to one count of possession of firearms and ammunition by an unlawful user of any controlled substance. He was subsequently sentenced to serve two years in prison, followed by another two years of supervised release.

In February, on the same day he reported to prison, Costianes filed motions with the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals to have his sentence enjoined, stayed and overturned — based on Trump’s blanket pardon issued to all Jan. 6 defendants on Jan. 20.

Procedurally, the case was quickly a mess: the defendant’s pre-pardon appeal was effectively abandoned; then the 4th Circuit asked the defendant and the government to answer specific questions; instead, the parties filed a joint motion to vacate the sentence; that motion was followed by an appellate court order and additional briefing; and then came a remand back down to the district court.

At the same time, lawyers were busy at the district court level. A motion to vacate was tersely denied by Bredar in early March. Then, a motion for release from custody and to stay the sentence pending appeal was volubly nixed by the lower court in late March.

In early April, the case was back before Bredar, with instructions from the 4th Circuit to decide the pardon issue. In response to a series of rulings, the judge told both parties to clarify, fully support, and resubmit their arguments, warning them not to be conclusory.

In early May, the judge went further after looking at the resubmitted arguments – finding the DOJ actually made them in “bad faith” – but offering one final opportunity to convince him.

The government then essayed an argument about money.

“[T]he Department has determined that its resources should not be devoted to investigating and prosecuting certain in-home offenses (like Mr. Costianes’s) that would not have been discovered if the government had not investigated and prosecuted people for their conduct related to the events at or near the United States Capitol on January 6, 2021,” the government’s Rule 48 motion reads. “And because the Department would not investigate or prosecute someone in Mr. Costianes’s shoes today, the Department has further determined that the interests of justice require treating Mr. Costianes similarly. These determinations are wholly discretionary and are based on the Department’s decisions on where its resources are best spent.”

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Childcare Worker Reports Concerns about Suspected Child Predator

A former colleague of accused Melbourne paedophile Joshua Brown has told 9News…

Man Taken into Custody for Reportedly Threatening Walmart Staff and Officer with a Knife

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Yesterday, Duard Augustus Benton III, aged 58,…

Mother Attacks Daughter with ‘Sword’ in Heated Dispute: Police Report

Inset: Terri Niner (Stark County Jail). Background: The home where Terri Niner…

Man Who Engaged in Prolonged Standoff and Shot Six Police Officers Learns His Sentence

Inset: Maurice Hill (Philadelphia Police). Background: Cops duck for cover after Hill…

Judge Rules That Small Town Killing Was Not Vigilantism

A murderer who bashed and stomped on someone he thought was a…

Authorities Verify Nola Dinkins’ Remains After Mother Falsely Reported Her Abduction

Officials have confirmed that the remains found in Maryland are those of…

Teenager allegedly declared ‘I’m a genuine killer’ following man’s stabbing: Authorities

Background: News footage captures the location where Michael James O’Malley was discovered…

Governor Noem Criticizes Judge Over Block on ‘Roving’ ICE Raids as DOJ Appeals

Background: Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem speaking to Fox News Sunday on…

Gainesville Resident Accused of Assaulting Individual with Wooden Object in Copeland Park

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Ronnie Lavern Walker, 65, was taken into…

Church Pastor Confronts Alleged Assailant Armed with a Knife

A church pastor and his guest were forced to tackle a man…

Man Sentenced for Murdering Couple in Dispute Over Sports Car Sale

Background: Footage from the news depicts the location where a couple from…

Trial Begins for Dentist Accused of Poisoning Wife During Secret Affair

The process of selecting a jury commenced on Monday at the Arapahoe…