Portrait of Marlean Ames sitting in a chair in a law office.
Share this @internewscast.com

A WOMAN who says she was passed over for a promotion because she is straight just scored a big win in the Supreme Court.

The justices ruled Thursday in her favor, slamming a rule that made it harder for “majority” workers to sue for discrimination.

Portrait of Marlean Ames sitting in a chair in a law office.
Marlean Ames was a longtime employee at the Ohio Department of Youth ServicesCredit: Reuters
The U.S. Supreme Court building.
The Supreme Court sided Ames, who said her gay boss unfairly passed her over for a promotionCredit: Reuters
Woman and man sitting at a conference table during a meeting.
The court unanimously backed Ames, with support from both conservative and liberal justicesCredit: Reuters

The case stems from a dispute in Ohio.

Marlean Ames, who has been with the Ohio Department of Youth Services since 2004, alleged she was bypassed for a job opportunity because her supervisor, who is gay, chose another gay woman for the position instead.

Ames filed what is known as a “reverse discrimination” lawsuit, and ended up losing in lower courts because of a controversial requirement.

That rule, known as the “background circumstances” test, made it harder for straight or white workers to sue.

Previously, individuals like Ames had to provide evidence indicating their employer’s prejudice against the majority, such as statistics or a history of similar incidents, as reported by CNN.

She couldn’t provide that, and judges tossed her case as a result.

Nonetheless, the Supreme Court overturned that requirement, with liberal Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson authoring the majority opinion that detailed the ruling.

Jackson said it was wrong to apply different rules based on someone’s race, gender, or sexual orientation.

“These requirements do not vary based on whether or not the plaintiff is a member of a majority group,” she wrote.

She called the background circumstances rule a “judge-made” test that “flouts that basic principle.”

Supreme Court rules people CAN wild camp in National Park

The court’s decision was unanimous, with both conservative and liberal justices backing Ames.

The ruling wipes out the extra hurdle for plaintiffs like her in at least five appeals courts across the country.

It doesn’t mean Ames automatically wins her case, but now she gets another shot in court.

Her lawyer celebrated the move as a major win for fairness.

“We wanted to make sure that the same laws and standards apply to everyone,” Xiao Wang, who directs the University of Virginia School of Law’s Supreme Court Litigation Clinic, told CNN.

“This Supreme Court ruling makes it easier for courts to root out unlawful discrimination in the workplace.”

In the footnotes of the official Supreme Court opinion, Justice Clarence Thomas agreed with the ruling, but added a harsh warning about DEI efforts.

He wrote that major companies were “obsessed” with diversity programs and had gone too far.

“American employers have long been ‘obsessed’ with ‘diversity, equity, and inclusion’ initiatives and affirmative action plans,” Thomas wrote.

“Initiatives of this kind have often led to overt discrimination against those perceived to be in the majority.”

BACK TO THE COURTS

The case was heard in February 2025 and drew strong support from justices during oral arguments.

Even the Biden and Trump administrations said the court of appeals’ reasoning was flawed and needed to reconsider.

Still, Ohio officials are standing firm.

“The court made clear that this case is not over,” said Dominic Binkley, a spokesperson for Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost.

“We look forward to fully pressing those arguments as the case moves forward because the Ohio Department of Youth Services did not engage in unlawful discrimination.”

Since she started working for the department, Ames steadily rose through the ranks before the alleged snub in 2017.

The new ruling sends her case back down for further proceedings, but with a level playing field this time.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Blue city's homicide increase 'flashing red warning light' to soft-on-crime experiment: expert

Expert Warns Surge in Homicides Signals Critical Alert in City’s Crime Policy Experiment

A significant rise in homicides in Boston has experts raising concerns, highlighting…
Dallas Rabbi Arrested for Child Molestation

Shocking Allegations: Dallas Rabbi Faces Child Molestation Charges

An Israeli-born rabbi who made headlines spreading discredited claims about “Palestinian mass…
Florida teacher keeps job after birthday song complaint

Florida Teacher Retains Position Despite Controversy Over Birthday Song Incident

An elementary school teacher in Polk County, Florida, will continue teaching after…
What to know about the Louvre heist investigation

Unraveling the Louvre Heist: Key Insights and Breakthroughs in the Ongoing Investigation

By Nicolas Vaux-Montagny and Sam Metz, Associated Press PARIS (AP) — A…
‘We don’t want anyone to starve’: Rep. Angie Nixon urges DeSantis to declare state of emergency

Rep. Angie Nixon Calls on DeSantis to Address Growing Hunger Crisis with Emergency Measures

According to State Representative Angie Nixon, the continuation of the federal government…
Amazon announces new round of layoffs

Amazing Shake-Up: Amazon Reveals Strategic Layoffs in Latest Workforce Realignment

Amazon has announced plans to significantly increase its investment in artificial intelligence…
Andrew Nuñez, San Bernardino deputy, shot and killed; gunman leads police on Upland, California Motorcycle chase on 210 Freeway

San Bernardino Deputy Andrew Nuñez Fatally Shot; Suspect Flees on Motorcycle in High-Speed Chase on 210 Freeway

UPLAND, Calif. — A dramatic motorcycle pursuit concluded with a severe collision…
Pope Leo XIV will pray at the site of the 2020 Beirut port blast in his first foreign trip

Pope Leo XIV to Commemorate 2020 Beirut Port Tragedy with Prayer During First International Visit

Pope Leo XIV is set to embark on his inaugural foreign visit…
Suspect with lengthy rap sheet arrested for alleged Pam Bondi 'murder-for-hire' scheme: FBI

FBI Arrests Notorious Suspect in Alleged Pam Bondi Murder-for-Hire Plot

A Minnesota man with a record of violent behavior is now facing…
Federal food benefits and preschool aid to run dry starting Saturday if shutdown continues

Federal Food and Preschool Support Face Closure Starting This Saturday Amid Ongoing Shutdown

As the clock ticks towards Saturday, millions of Americans face the possibility…
Taiwan general warns China’s military drills could be preparation for blockade or war, vows to resist

Taiwan’s Top General Alerts on China’s Drills: Possible Prelude to Blockade or Conflict, Pledges Strong Defense

EXCLUSIVE: Taiwan’s Ministry of National Defense has revealed that China is conducting…
'We're working on staying': Jon Stewart discusses his future as host of 'The Daily Show'

Jon Stewart Opens Up About His Future Plans as ‘The Daily Show’ Host

Jon Stewart is reportedly negotiating to continue his role as the host…