Share this @internewscast.com

A new study has revealed which club in the Premier League has been the biggest under-achiever in the 2023-24 season, based on their expected points compared to spending.

Manchester City pipped Arsenal to the title at the end of a dramatic title race that initially looked set to see Liverpool also vie for the championship on the final day before dropping away. 

In doing so, Pep Guardiola’s side made it four in a row – the first side to ever do so – vindicating their heavy yet intuitive spending over the duration of the ex-Barcelona boss’ tenure once again.

The study calculates the expected points for each team in the Premier League based on figures from their most recent financial accounts (2022-23), to show which club has proven the best value for money over the course of the season. 

Pep Guardiola's Manchester City won the Premier League on the final day after beating West Ham 3-1

Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City won the Premier League on the final day after beating West Ham 3-1

Manchester United were unsurprisingly among the biggest spenders according to the data

Manchester United were unsurprisingly among the biggest spenders according to the data

The expected tally of points is reached based on the historic impact of spending on accrued points. According to the Times, teams that spend double the median expenditure usually end up on 66 points, while those spending 20 per cent less earn 42.  

Perhaps unsurprisingly, given their huge expenditure in recent transfer windows, Chelsea have come out as the biggest underachievers in the list. 

The Blues managed to secure Europa League football despite a very poor first half of the campaign, yet Mauricio Pochettino left on Tuesday night by mutual consent with his future having been under heavy scrutiny throughout the tail end of the season. 

Yet after a total expenditure of £607million on wages and amortisation in 2022-23 and another £75m in agents’ fees in 2023-24 – a league-high total of £682m – the club were expected to earn 87 points, some 24 fewer than their actual return of 63.

‘Chelsea’s sizeable amortisation and agents fees costs — both at least 20 per cent more than the next-highest clubs — meant they had the highest overall costs in the league,’ said chief intelligence officer of Twenty First Group Omar Chaudhuri.

‘Their budget, relative to the average team in the league, would historically have delivered around 87 points, so 63 points represents a significant underachievement.

‘However, their form from April onwards was in line with an 87-point season, suggesting they might be on the path to performing closer in line with their budget next season.’

The Blues are joined at the bottom of the list by fellow big-hitters Manchester United whose 60 points were deemed 14 below their expected target following an outlay of £535m in the same three categories. 

Mauricio Pochettino left Chelsea by mutual consent on Tuesday evening following a sixth place finish

Mauricio Pochettino left Chelsea by mutual consent on Tuesday evening following a sixth place finish

The Argentine boss had lost only three games in 2024 in a brilliant climax to the campaign 

Manchester United also fell far below their expected points after total costs of £535million

Manchester United also fell far below their expected points after total costs of £535million

Sheffield United are sandwiched between the two giants with a -21 point difference from their £118m expenditure in a woeful campaign that sees the Blades immediately return to the Championship, with Burnley level with United on -14 although they spent far less (£129m).

At the other end of the table, the four teams that secured Champions League football in Man City, Arsenal, Liverpool and Aston Villa take up the top four spots in the pound-for-pound success table. 

The Gunners lead the way, having over performed by a stunning 27 points – more than the season tallies of Luton, Burnley and Sheffield United – with their total costs of £399m predicted to earn them 62 points that would have placed them seventh in the 2023-24 final table.

Mikel Arteta’s side invested 25-40 per cent less than the likes of Chelsea and United, but out-performed them by 26 and 29 points respectively in the end. 

Chaudhuri added: ‘Arsenal’s level of overachievement exceeds even the level Liverpool achieved as they competed for titles between 2018 and 2022, but it hasn’t been enough to tip them into the 90-point range needed to win the league.

‘Manchester City continue to overachieve. Their spending has been comparable to Chelsea and Manchester United, who have shown that £500million+ annual spend is not a guarantee of 80 points, let alone 90.’

Second were Unai Emery’s Aston Villa with a 14-point over performance, followed by Liverpool (+10) and champions City (+9). 

Manchester City interestingly had the second highest overall spend – £629m – yet finished fourth in this study, indicating the accuracy and efficiency of their recruitment department.  

Mikel Arteta's side finished top of the pound-for-pound success table after over achieving by 27 points

Mikel Arteta’s side finished top of the pound-for-pound success table after over achieving by 27 points

Sheffield United finished the lowest of the newly-promoted sides in terms of under-achieving, finishing 21 points shy of their expected total

Sheffield United finished the lowest of the newly-promoted sides in terms of under-achieving, finishing 21 points shy of their expected total

Newcastle and Bournemouth both finished seven points better off than expected with outlays of £292m and £157m respectively, ahead of four teams tied on +6. 

West Ham (£216m), Crystal Palace (£182m), and Brighton (£172m) all spent roughly similar amounts and finished ninth (52 points), 10th (49 points) and 11th (48 points) respectively. 

As for Tottenham, who also ended up six points better off than their expected tally, they splashed £379million to finish 10th in the pound-for-pound table behind the other three.

Fulham ended up three points better off than expected judging by the data after an outlay of £197m earned them 47 points, while Brentford performed exactly as expected ending up on 39 points after splashing £138m.

Both Everton (48 points) and Wolves (46 points) finished just a point worse off than they ought to have, with the Toffees’ actually ending the season on 40 points due to points penalties though the study has not taken this into account. 

Unai Emery's Aston Villa pulled off a remarkable campaign to finish in the Champions League spots, some 14 points above expectation

Unai Emery’s Aston Villa pulled off a remarkable campaign to finish in the Champions League spots, some 14 points above expectation

Manchester City won a sixth Premier League title in seven years but only finished fourth

Manchester City won a sixth Premier League title in seven years but only finished fourth

Premier League’s pound-for-pound success table
Team Wages (2023) Amortisation (2023) Agents Fees (2024) Total costs Expected Points Actual Points Difference
Arsenal £235m £139m £25m £399m 62 89 27
Aston Villa £194m £93m £21m £308m 54 68 14
Liverpool £373m £108m £32m £512m 72 82 10
Man City £423m £145m £61m £629m 82 91 9
Newcastle United £187m £87m £19m £292m 53 60 7
Bournemouth £100m £41m £16m £157m 41 48 7
Crystal Palace £131m £40m £11m £182m 43 49 6
West Ham £137m £65m £14m £216m 46 52 6
Brighton & Hove Albion £128m £33m £11m £172m 42 48 6
Tottenham £251m £109m £20m £379m 60 66 6
Fulham £139m £46m £12m £197m 44 47 3
Brentford £99m £31m £8m £138m 39 39 0
Everton £159m £78m £11m £247m 49 48 -1
Wolves £142m £79m £13m £234m 47 46 -1
Luton Town £61m £16m £2m £80m 34 26 -8
Nottingham Forest £145m £41m £13m £199m 44 36 -8
Burnley £86m £36m £7m £129m 38 24 -14
Man United £331m £170m £34m £535m 74 60 -14
Sheffield United £81m £32m £5m £118m 37 16 -21
Chelsea £404m £203m £75m £682m 87 63 -24
*Data from Twenty First Group, via The Times 

Luton and Nottingham Forest than fall in 15th and 16th place respectively, the Hatters spending a league low £80m in the three cost categories but finishing eight shy of their 34 expected. 

Forest also missed out on their expected tally by eight points, having been predicted to reach 44 – the same as Fulham – having spent £199m.

Overall, as many might predict, the study suggests a trend of the clubs finishing higher up the table operating on the most efficient financial system, recruiting players for prices that either under or accurately equate to their output on the field. 

Likewise, those that fell lower down the table seemed to spend inflated amounts on players that don’t necessarily seem to make as much of a difference on the field, Chelsea and Man United notably among the biggest spenders.  

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

PSG Teams Up with The Weeknd for Exclusive Home Jersey Release

Paris Saint-Germain and The Weeknd have strengthened their creative collaboration by launching…

New Balance Unveils Tekela v5: The Latest in Precision Control Football Boots

New Balance has lifted the curtain on the Tekela v5, the fifth generation…

Cause of Death Disclosed for 13-Year-Old Soccer Player Found on Roadside After Coach’s Murder Charge

A 13-year-old soccer player found dead at the side of a road…

Wolves willing to let Pedro Neto leave for Arsenal or Tottenham under specific terms

Wolves will not stand in Neto’s way if a Champions League club…

Behind the Scenes: England’s Under-21 Stars Outshine Glastonbury & The Misstep by M&S with the Lionesses

England’s Under-21s captured the nation’s imagination, with a staggering 3.7million (37 per…

The MLS Archive Collection to Feature Retro Jerseys for 10 Additional Clubs in 2025

For the upcoming 2024 season, five MLS clubs, including Inter Miami and…

Unveiling the Success of England’s U21 Team: Candid Conversations with Ashley Cole, Wagamama Team Dinners, and Oasis Anthems Inspire Young Lions to Victory

It is the day before the European Championship final and while some players…

Manchester United Needs to Back Erik ten Hag as Arsenal Did with Mikel Arteta, but Bruno Fernandes and Marcus Rashford Won’t Lead to Titles

In an exclusive column for talkSPORT.com, Mark Goldbridge delivers his verdict on the…

Fans Across the Globe Honor Diogo Jota: Liverpool Faithful Sing “You’ll Never Walk Alone” at Anfield; Banner Displayed During Portugal vs. Spain Women’s Euros Match

Emotions were heightened during Portugal’s match against Spain at the Women’s Euros…

Transfer Secrets: Newcastle Chases Three New Targets, Spurs Compete for Premier League Star, Eberechi Eze’s Preferred Team Revealed, Plus Man City vs. Liverpool in EFL Talent Showdown

NEWCASTLE UNITED are exploring a move for MARSEILLE centre back Leonardo Balerdi.…

“Moonbeams Murray Emerges from Hiding, Highlighting the Sensible Leadership of Rangers’ New Management, Writes GARY KEOWN”

No wild promises, talk of ‘low-ego decision-making’, a clear statement that this…