A supportive hand on the shoulder is not sex harassment - tribunal
Share this @internewscast.com

Putting a supportive hand on a female colleague’s shoulder in a ‘fatherly’ way is not sex harassment, a tribunal has ruled.

Employment Judge Robin Havard said the gesture may instead signal support and is not done in a way to humiliate or intimidate the recipient.

In the case of HR employee Yvette Rankmore, she approached a tribunal against a city council after her male supervisor placed his hand on her shoulder while giving advice.

Ms Rankore admitted that it was a ‘fatherly type gesture’ – but said she did not consider that it was ‘appropriate’ in the workplace.

Nevertheless, the tribunal noted that Ms. Rankmore didn’t address the incident with her boss and rejected her claims, stating that the male supervisor’s actions were not intended to compromise her dignity.

The employment tribunal, held in Cardiff, was told Ms Rankmore started working for the city council in 2004.

In 2023, Ms Rankmore was a people services advisor at the authority and she sat opposite Jason Carlson in the office.

The council worker alleged to the tribunal that there were occasions where Mr Carlson was ‘putting his arms around me’.

A judge at Cardiff Employment Tribunal (above) said Yvette Rankmore had 'accepted that Jason Carlson had done so in, 'a fatherly way' and that his conduct was not of a sexual nature.'

A judge at the Cardiff Employment Tribunal (above) mentioned that Yvette Rankmore acknowledged Jason Carlson did so in “a fatherly way” and that his behavior wasn’t sexual in nature.

She mentioned she ‘avoided’ visiting his desk but noted, ‘if he wanted to talk, he’d come to my desk and still put his arms around me.’

During the proceedings, Ms Rankmore told the judge that her boss would put an arm around her shoulder.

Ms Rankmore told the panel that her boss had placed an arm on her shoulder or back two or three times over a four-and-a-half month period.

Ms. Rankmore stated that Mr. Carlson acted similarly with others, and a council colleague confirmed in testimony that he would ‘place an arm on someone’s shoulder supportively when demonstrating something.’

The panel heard that in later 2023, Mr Carlson also made an ‘inappropriate comment’ about her daughter which ‘changed’ her opinion of her boss.

The following June, she raised concerns over the conduct of Mr Carlson to other senior figures at the authority.

The council worker was offered mediation but she declined this and informal resolution proceedings commenced.

The allegation of Mr Carlson putting his arm around Ms Rankmore was upheld – but it was found that he ‘had not realised this caused offence’.

According to the panel, Mr. Carlson later underwent ’emotional intelligence and management’ training and attended another session with his team about the law concerning sexual harassment.

But, in August 2024, Ms Rankmore lodged a formal resolution application and said she felt as if the informal process had not led to a ‘satisfactory outcome’.

Her concerns were not upheld and she again appealed the findings, but a subsequent hearing found both formal and informal investigations had been ‘robust and appropriate’.

The advisor took the council to a tribunal, alleging sex and sexual harassment, among other claims.

In her written evidence, she said Mr Carlson was putting his arms around her and ‘rubbing’ her back.

The panel said that they were ‘concerned’ that Ms Rankmore had ‘exaggerated’ Mr Carlson’s conduct by making it sound ‘more intimate’.

The tribunal accepted Mr Carlson’s evidence that he was a ‘tactile person’ and said he also behaved the same way towards other staff.

Employment Judge Robin Havard said the tribunal also accepted Ms Rankmore’s evidence that she found his conduct inappropriate and that it made her feel uncomfortable.

But the tribunal found that ‘Mr Carlson had placed his arm on (Ms Rankmore’s) shoulder in a supportive manner and there was no evidence to suggest that (Ms Rankmore) was ‘singled out’ for such contact.

‘Whilst this may have been unwanted conduct, the Tribunal was not satisfied that it related to (Ms Rankmore’s) sex.’

The judge said Ms Rankmore had ‘accepted that Mr Carlson had done so in, ‘a fatherly way’ and that his conduct was not of a sexual nature.’

All claims made by Ms Rankmore were brought to the tribunal too late.

But the judge said that in any event, they would have been dismissed.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

PREMIER LEAGUE TRANSFER EVALUATION: How well did your team do?

The transfer window slammed shut with an almighty bang on Monday evening…

Trump Accuses AI of Creating Video Showing Object Tossed Out of White House Window

President Donald Trump said the viral video showing an object being tossed…

Rayner Confesses to Underpaying Stamp Duty on Her New Beachfront Apartment

Angela Rayner was fighting for her political future today after admitting she didn’t…

Why I Left My GP Career to Embrace Van Life and Travel Full-Time

A doctor disclosed that he stepped down from his position as a…

Cheerleader Appears in Court Fully Dressed Up After Allegedly Concealing Infant’s Remains

A cheerleader from a Kentucky college, appearing in a bright pink dress…

The Costly Trap of Self-Storage Insurance That Could Set You Back £2,000 Annually

Individuals utilizing self-storage facilities are potentially overpaying for their insurance, with some…

Ashley Biden Hints at Starting Fresh Following Her Divorce

Ashley Biden suggested she is prepared for ‘new beginnings’ and believes things…

British Man Missing After His Boat Is Discovered Near Gran Canaria

A British man has gone missing during his solo global sailing journey…

Millie Court and Liam Reardon, Love Island 2021 Winners, Announce Split

Love Island champions Millie Court and Liam Reardon have split, four years…

Green Party Leader Faces Calls to Dismiss Deputy Over Defense of Hamas

The Green Party’s new leader came under pressure Tuesday to sack his deputy…

The Decline of Nestlé’s CEO Sparked by an Anonymous Employee Tip

Former Nestlé CEO Laurent Freixe’s exit was precipitated by an anonymous tip…

Unveiling the Hidden Dangers of Gel Manicures: From Allergies to Cancer

Recent reports about a European prohibition on a key chemical found in…