Lawyer apologizes for AI-generated errors in Australian murder case

Attorney Issues Apology for AI-Related Mistakes in Australian Murder Trial

The blunder in the Supreme Court of Victoria, Australia is another in a litany of mishaps AI has caused in justice systems around the world.

MELBOURNE, VIC — An apology was issued by a prominent Australian lawyer to a judge after inadmissible submissions were filed in a murder trial, containing fabricated quotes and invented case judgments produced by artificial intelligence.

The blunder in the Supreme Court of Victoria state is another in a litany of mishaps AI has caused in justice systems around the world.

Rishi Nathwani, a highly respected King’s Counsel in the defense, accepted complete responsibility for submitting erroneous information in the case of a teenager accused of murder, as noted in court records reviewed by The Associated Press on Friday.

“We are deeply sorry and embarrassed for what occurred,” Nathwani told Justice James Elliott on Wednesday, on behalf of the defense team.

The inaccuracies brought about by the AI led to a 24-hour postponement in reaching a resolution in the case Elliott aimed to finalize on Wednesday. On Thursday, Elliott determined that Nathwani’s client, whose identity is protected due to their age, was not guilty of murder by reason of mental incapacity.

“At the risk of understatement, the manner in which these events have unfolded is unsatisfactory,” Elliott told lawyers on Thursday.

“The court’s trust in the accuracy of counsel submissions is crucial for the proper functioning of justice,” Elliott emphasized.

The erroneous submissions included invented quotes from a supposed legislative speech and nonexistent case references allegedly from the Supreme Court.

The errors were discovered by Elliott’s associates, who couldn’t find the cases and requested that defense lawyers provide copies.

The lawyers admitted the citations “do not exist” and that the submission contained “fictitious quotes,” court documents say.

The lawyers explained they checked that the initial citations were accurate and wrongly assumed the others would also be correct.

The submissions were also sent to prosecutor Daniel Porceddu, who didn’t check their accuracy.

The judge noted that the Supreme Court released guidelines last year for how lawyers use AI.

“It is not acceptable for artificial intelligence to be used unless the product of that use is independently and thoroughly verified,” Elliott said.

The court documents do not identify the generative artificial intelligence system used by the lawyers.

Similarly, in the United States in 2023, a federal judge levied $5,000 penalties against two lawyers and their law firm when ChatGPT was identified as the source of fictitious legal documentation in an aviation injury lawsuit.

Judge P. Kevin Castel said they acted in bad faith. But he credited their apologies and remedial steps taken in explaining why harsher sanctions were not necessary to ensure they or others won’t again let artificial intelligence tools prompt them to produce fake legal history in their arguments.

Later that year, more fictitious court rulings invented by AI were cited in legal papers filed by lawyers for Michael Cohen, a former personal lawyer for U.S. President Donald Trump. Cohen took the blame, saying he didn’t realize that the Google tool he was using for legal research was also capable of so-called AI hallucinations.

British High Court Justice Victoria Sharp warned in June that providing false material as if it were genuine could be considered contempt of court or, in the “most egregious cases,” perverting the course of justice, which carries a maximum sentence of life in prison.

Copyright 2025 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.     

You May Also Like

Criminal past of Illinois ethanol plant bomb scare suspect includes multiple felonies, 2 prison stints

Illinois Ethanol Plant Bomb Threat Suspect Has Multiple Felonies, Two Prison Terms

FBI probes explosive device found near Illinois ethanol plant Federal authorities launched…
Supreme Court rejects case on Trump's bid to cut research grants related to DEI

Supreme Court Rejects Case Over Trump DEI Research Grant Cuts

Washington — The Supreme Court on Monday declined to take up a…
Vance’s midterm blame game hits snag as Trump’s own Israel ambassador disputes key claim

Trump’s Israel Ambassador Rebuts Vance’s Midterm Blame Claim

U.S. Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee is rejecting Vice President JD Vance’s…
New California tax plan targets wealthy after Prop 40 defeat

New California Tax Plan Targets Wealthy After Proposition 40 Defeat

California voters have rejected a billionaire tax, but the debate over how…
State Department presses Egypt to respect religious freedom as Christian convert faces possible execution

US Presses Egypt as Christian Convert Faces Execution Over Faith

The U.S. State Department is stepping up pressure on Egypt to uphold…
Man legally named Captain America charged with murder after allegedly giving victim’s girlfriend chilling note

Man Legally Named Captain America Charged With Murder After Note

Captain C. America, right, faces a first-degree murder charge in the death…
Rubio insists ‘zero evidence’ that widespread US tech outages, cyberattacks are linked

Rubio Says No Evidence Links US Tech Outages and Cyberattacks

Secretary of State Marco Rubio said Tuesday there is “no indication” that…
‘This is only a test’: Nationwide Emergency Alert System test to take place Tuesday in US | What to know

Nationwide US Emergency Alert Test Set for Tuesday: What to Know

Federal agencies and television broadcasters are urging Americans to stay calm ahead…
Exclusive | DHS gives real story on ‘world’s most wanted’ OnlyFans model -

Exclusive: DHS Reveals Truth About ‘World’s Most Wanted’ OnlyFans Model

An OnlyFans model detained while awaiting deportation has a history of illegally…
Anti-Israel activist allegedly destroyed $60 million US military aircraft at Irish airport: feds

Anti-Israel activist accused of damaging $60M US jet in Ireland

An Irish activist opposed to Israel allegedly carried out a carefully planned…
California sheriff's deputy, special officer put on leave after 5-second conversation with ICE agents

California Deputy, Special Officer Put on Leave Over ICE Talk

Two employees of the Orange County Sheriff’s Department have been placed on…
Sean Duffy vows to modernize aging air traffic system after nationwide ground stop

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy Vows to Modernize Air Traffic System After Nationwide Ground Stop

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said Monday that the United States will overhaul…