Karen Read's voicemails to John O'Keefe played in murder trial: 'I f---ing hate you'
Share this @internewscast.com

Karen Read’s defense team has introduced new evidence about an altercation with her boyfriend, John O’Keefe, occurring the month before his alleged death in a drunken hit-and-run. Prosecutors argue that this evidence could suggest the incident was a “domestic violence homicide,” with Read unable to accept O’Keefe’s attempts to end their relationship, as revealed in a recent court filing.

Alan Jackson, one of Read’s attorneys, questioned Massachusetts State Police Sgt. Yuri Bukhenik about a series of text messages between Read and another potential romantic interest, ATF Agent Brian Higgins. Higgins was at the bar and after-party attended by Read and O’Keefe, a Boston police officer, before he was last seen alive.

“Where the defendant has introduced this evidence, it is crucial for the jury to recognize that it was the defendant who consistently refused to acknowledge the victim’s wish to end their relationship,” special prosecutor Hank Brennan stated. “The defendant made repeated hostile accusations that the victim was unfaithful, demonstrating a pattern of hostility in the days and weeks leading up to the murder.”

“This incident in Aruba seems to also be the turning point in the relationship as the defendant told Brian Higgins that her relationship with the victim was a ‘very f—ed up situation’ as she had observed the victim ‘all over [a] friend’s sister in the lobby of our hotel’ and accused the victim of ‘having hooked up with another girl.’”

Brennan said he plans to call four witnesses to the Aruba incident to testify.

Karen Read, lawyers and judge talk in court.

Karen Read, front left, joins attorneys for a sidebar with Judge Beverly J. Cannone, right, during her murder retrial on May 12, 2025. (Pat Greenhouse/The Boston Globe via AP, Pool)

“In a domestic violence homicide, evidence such as prior disputes are relevant to show the ‘volatile nature of the relationship,’” Brennan wrote.

He added that he expected their testimony to show Read’s “intent and state of mind toward the victim.”

“Brennan is smart,” said Linda Kenney Baden, a high-profile defense attorney who squared off with Jackson in 2007 when he was the lead prosecutor in the murder trial of music producer Phil Spector. “You don’t get to represent Whitey Bulger for eight years if you’re not.”

Still, she said, Jackson may have been prepared for it.

“I think even if the judge allows him to bring it in, Jackson is ready for it,” she said. “That’s why he had the Aruba text read in the whole Higgins outline.”

Read has pleaded not guilty, and her attorneys deny she ever struck O’Keefe with her vehicle.

Four weeks into the trial, prosecutors have yet to show O’Keefe’s autopsy findings to the jury or allege specifically how she intended to kill him. 

“This feels desperate to get the intent,” said Grace Edwards, a Massachusetts defense attorney who has been following the case. “I don’t think the jury will care to hear more evidence that there were issues. No relationship is perfect.”

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Historic libraries bring modern comfort to book lovers and history buffs in New England

New England’s Historic Libraries Blend Timeless Charm with Modern Comfort for Book Lovers and History Enthusiasts

In the heart of Boston, David Arsenault experiences a sense of reverence…
Did anybody win Friday's $680M Mega Millions jackpot?

Discover if Anyone Hit the $680 Million Mega Millions Jackpot on Friday!

The latest Mega Millions jackpot reached a staggering $680 million, making it…
Riverdale Amber Alert Illinois today: Police searching for kidnapping suspect Austin Bell, 4 kids, stolen car silver Acura MDX

Urgent Amber Alert: Search Underway for Suspect and 4 Missing Children in Stolen Silver Acura MDX in Riverdale, Illinois

In Riverdale, Illinois, authorities are actively searching for a suspect accused of…
Independent NJ candidate’s martial arts theatrics shakes up township meeting

Martial Arts Moves by Independent NJ Candidate Stir Excitement at Township Meeting

It felt less like a conventional town hall meeting and more akin…
Trump’s $230M DOJ settlement bid likely has few legal backstops

Trump’s $230M DOJ Settlement Proposal Faces Legal Hurdles, Experts Say

Former President Donald Trump is pursuing a substantial compensation claim, potentially amounting…
American missionary kidnapped in Niger by suspected Islamist militants, sources say

Suspected Islamist Militants Abduct American Missionary in Niger, Sources Report

The U.S. government has confirmed its awareness of an American Christian missionary’s…
More than 2 million pounds of barbecue pork jerky recalled over metal contamination

Urgent Recall: Over 2 Million Pounds of BBQ Pork Jerky Pulled from Shelves Due to Metal Contamination

Consumers are advised to dispose of the recalled jerky or return it…
MAD DADS plans justice walk and community search for answers in death of young Jacksonville father

Justice Walk: MAD DADS Lead the Charge to Uncover Truth in Young Jacksonville Father’s Tragic Death

In a determined quest for justice, the organization MAD DADS Jacksonville, alongside…
Nelly Furtado stepping away from performing for 'the foreseeable future'

Nelly Furtado Announces Hiatus from the Stage: What’s Next for the Pop Star?

More than a year after unveiling her seventh studio album “7,” Nelly…
Universities defiant on Trump's academic excellence compact as feedback deadline passes

Universities Stand Firm Against Trump’s Academic Excellence Compact as Feedback Deadline Expires

In a notable response to the Trump administration’s proposed Compact for Academic…
Army Officer Court-Martialed Over COVID Rules by Vindman Brother Finally Reinstated on Active Duty

Army Officer Rejoins Active Duty After Vindman Brother’s Court-Martial Overturns COVID Rules Case

Mark Bashaw, previously the only member of the Armed Forces to face…
German chancellor defends remarks on migrants suggesting citizens 'afraid to move around in public spaces'

German Chancellor Addresses Public Concerns Over Migrant Impact on Safety

German Chancellor Friedrich Merz has reiterated his stance on migration, asserting that…