Asking Eric: Introduction of a child changes dynamic for longtime housemates


Eric's Dilemma: How a New Child Transforms the Dynamic Between Longtime Housemates

Dear Eric,

My 40-year-old daughter has resided for a decade with a kind, recently retired older gentleman. This man has an adult son and daughter-in-law, both of whom struggle with drug addiction.

Recently, the daughter-in-law was arrested due to a domestic violence incident that occurred in front of their 4-year-old child. Consequently, a protective order now prevents her from approaching her husband.

In light of these events, the gentleman my daughter lives with has temporarily assumed care for his grandson. He is open to the idea of taking on long-term guardianship should the need arise.

My daughter understands his decision and harbors no resentment towards his temporary custody of the child.

However, a challenge has emerged. My daughter holds a demanding job that requires daily travel and occasional overnight stays. This professional commitment makes a full night’s sleep essential, yet she is losing rest due to the health issues the grandson experiences at night.

Should she have a long talk with the man and share that she needs to find another place to live in order for her safety, driving and working? She and the man get along great. But she is wondering what she should do: leave him and thank him for the past and wish him the best or stay there and do her best?

– Restless Housemates

Dear Housemates: A talk is the right path forward. No matter the circumstances, housemates often find that, after a while, their needs change, even though they still like each other. It’s normal for life factors to motivate moves. Talking it through helps alleviate hurt feelings.

Your daughter should think about the obligation she feels toward the man and his grandson. It’s understandable that, after such a long friendship, she wants to support him. But is she the best person to provide said support? Part of the tension may be coming from the fact that she’s trying to fulfill a role that another person – a relative, or home health aide or a social worker – is better suited for. So, she should also ask the man what support he needs and, if she feels capable, help him brainstorm the best way to get that support.

Dear Eric: My late husband and I married nine years ago; both of our previous spouses had died. We were both in our 80s.

At the onset, we had agreed to split all of our expenses 50/50 and we wrote up a pre-nup. As time passed, his daughter began to question our financial arrangement, so she decided to take over his banking and accounts. That was fine with me.

Later on, she also unilaterally decided to monitor his health arrangements as well. She and her brother decided to take him off his cancer treatment and medicine.

He passed recently and I wanted to be involved with the funeral arrangements. I was highly upset that she refused to talk with me about them.

From that day until now, no one from his family has ever reached out to me or asked me how I’m doing. Thanksgiving and Christmas have gone by, and I still harbor hostile thoughts about his whole family as being unkind, unfeeling and uncaring about me as the person who took wonderful care of him physically and emotionally. I need to let this go but it keeps cropping up in my consciousness frequently. How do I move on?

– Abandoned by Family

Dear Family: I’m so sorry that you were treated this way. It’s not right, as you know. While it’s possible that your late husband’s children struggled to accept your marriage because of their own grief over losing their mother, they shouldn’t have made you suffer for it. Grief is difficult and complicated; navigating it can be difficult without help. But help is available.

Your own grief may be one of the reasons that this behavior has been so hard to move past. It’s possible that the cruel way they treated you has kept you from processing your husband’s death. So, I’d recommend talking to a therapist or a faith leader about what you’re going through. You might also join a grief support group. These experiences will always be a part of your story, but by processing your feelings, you can reduce their power over you.

It may also be helpful to remember that nothing your late husband’s family did or does can take away the years you shared and the love you felt for each other. Try to focus on that and lean on those who love and care for you for support.

(Send questions to R. Eric Thomas at eric@askingeric.com or P.O. Box 22474, Philadelphia, PA 19110. Follow him on Instagram and sign up for his weekly newsletter at rericthomas.com.)

©2026 Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

You May Also Like

Rhode Island Police Fatally Shoot Sailboat Theft Suspect in Gunfire

Rhode Island Police Fatally Shoot Sailboat Theft Suspect in Gunfire

Intense body camera footage captured the moment Rhode Island police officers got…
Private Jet Carrying 9 Crashes Near Mar-a-Lago in Florida

Private Jet Carrying 9 Crashes Near Mar-a-Lago in Florida

Private jet crashes near Mar-a-Lago in Palm Beach A Learjet 60 carrying…
Fire Rips Through Mississippi Police Department That Fatally Shot 1-Year-Old Kohen Wiley

Fire Rips Through Mississippi Police Department That Fatally Shot 1-Year-Old Kohen Wiley

A fire tore through the headquarters of the Senatobia Police Department in…
West Virginia Frat Hazing Raids Serve as ‘Wake-Up Call,’ Expert Says

West Virginia Frat Hazing Raids Serve as ‘Wake-Up Call,’ Expert Says

Authorities are reviewing evidence seized from the Lambda Chi Alpha house at…
Lawless e-bike riders turn NYC's Central Park into danger zone as fed-up locals push for a ban

Fed-Up Locals Push E-Bike Ban as Reckless Riders Turn NYC’s Central Park Into Danger Zone

So much for a peaceful stroll through the park. Central Park visitors…
Katie Zacharia Promotes Natural Hair, Fitness in Halloween Dress-Up

Katie Zacharia Promotes Natural Hair, Fitness in Halloween Dress-Up

WASHINGTON — Katie Zacharia is embracing the spotlight in her own way.…
Texas Jet Carrying 9 Crashes in Palm Beach, Florida, Killing All on Board

Texas Jet Carrying 9 Crashes in Palm Beach, Florida, Killing All on Board

A business jet carrying nine people plunged into the ground near homes…
University of San Francisco Retires Mascot After 90 Years Following Student Calls

University of San Francisco Retires Mascot After 90 Years Following Student Calls

A prominent California university is ending its nearly century-old mascot tradition after…
Anthropic Gives $900,000 to California Democrats Days Before Vote

Anthropic Gives $900,000 to California Democrats Days Before Vote

Silicon Valley’s artificial intelligence industry is pouring money into California Democrats’ campaign…
Shootings Near 3 College Communities Leave 1 Dead, 21 Injured

Shootings Near 3 College Communities Leave 1 Dead, 21 Injured

Shootings in three college communities over the weekend killed one person and…
Savannah Guthrie's Plea for Missing Mom After Old Drawing

Savannah Guthrie’s Plea for Missing Mom After Old Drawing

“TODAY” co-host Savannah Guthrie renewed her public appeal for information about her…
Staten Island Man Who Lost Nearly 200 Pounds to Run NYC Marathon

Staten Island Man Who Lost Nearly 200 Pounds to Run NYC Marathon

This year’s TCS New York City Marathon is deeply personal for Joe…