Share this @internewscast.com
A Florida House Democrat on Wednesday launched a longshot effort to call a special legislative session to address gun-related issues after recent mass shootings in Uvalde, Texas, and Buffalo, N.Y.

Florida Supreme Court justices expressed skepticism Thursday about a challenge by cities and counties to a 2011 state law that threatens stiff penalties if local officials pass gun-related regulations.

During arguments in the closely watched case, justices asked questions and made comments that indicated they did not agree with city and county contentions that the law is unconstitutional.

“You make a very plausible kind of policy argument,” Justice Carlos Muniz said at one point to Edward Guedes, an attorney for the local governments. “But it just doesn’t seem like there’s any sort of constitutional foundation for what you’re talking about.”

At another point, Chief Justice Charles Canady pointed to part of the state Constitution that involves the relationship between the Legislature and municipalities.

“Our (previous) cases are very clear about the superiority of legislative power in this arena. Am I wrong about that?” Canady asked Guedes. “And so that’s why this whole case is kind of mystifying to me because underlying what the Legislature has done (in the gun law) is this express constitutional provision.”

Florida since 1987 has barred cities and counties from passing regulations that are stricter than state firearms laws, and the penalties in the 2011 law were designed to strengthen that “preemption.” The law, for example, could lead to local officials facing $5,000 fines for passing gun regulations.

The case does not challenge the underlying 1987 law but contends the penalties in the 2011 law are unconstitutional, in part, because they violate legal immunities for local officials and governments. Also, Guedes argued that the 2011 violates the constitutional separation of powers because it would lead to courts delving into the motivations or intentions of local elected officials.

More than 30 cities and counties and dozens of local officials challenged the 2011 law after the 2018 mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland that killed 17 people. State Agriculture Commissioner Nikki Fried joined the challenge, which has drawn briefs from prominent groups on both sides of the issue, including the National Rifle Association and the Giffords and Brady gun-control organizations.

The 1st District Court of Appeal last year upheld the law, spurring the cities and counties to go to the Supreme Court.

While the timing was coincidental, Thursday’s arguments came amid a refueled national debate about gun issues after mass shootings in Uvalde, Texas, and Buffalo, N.Y. Florida Democrats also have sought to force a special legislative session on gun issues, though the idea stands virtually no chance amid Republican opposition.

Along with penalties against individual local officials for passing gun-related regulations, the 2011 law would allow members of the public and organizations to receive damages and attorney fees if they successfully sue local governments for improper gun regulations.

Attorneys for the local governments wrote in a 2019 court document that city and county officials had been urged to take actions after the Marjory Stoneman Douglas shooting. Those requests involved such things as requiring procedures or documentation to ensure compliance with background checks and waiting periods for gun purchases and requiring reporting of failed background checks.

But the attorneys said local governments refrained from going ahead with the proposals because of the potential penalties in state law.

During Thursday’s arguments, Guedes did not dispute the Legislature’s authority to preempt local decision-making power but took issue with the potential punishments.

“There is no question, underlying all of this is the notion of the preeminence of the state Legislature to preempt substantive areas of law. We don’t disagree with that,” Guedes said. “But this is a legislative firehose to put out a birthday candle.”

While justices had extensive back and forth with Guedes, justices only briefly questioned state Chief Deputy Solicitor General Daniel Bell. In part, Bell pointed to the Legislature’s authority over local governments.

“Local officials have only those powers that are not inconsistent with general law, which means they are subject to the plenary control of the Legislature,” Bell said. “With that hierarchy established, there is no reason the Legislature wouldn’t be able to provide penalties for its statute.”

The Supreme Court typically takes months before issuing rulings. The case stems from three lawsuits that were consolidated in Leon County circuit court. The challenges were filed by cities and counties from various parts of the state, such as Tallahassee, Gainesville, Orlando, St. Petersburg, Fort Lauderdale and Miami Beach.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Foster Farms expands corn dog recall

Foster Farms Expands Recall: Corn Dogs Pulled from Shelves Nationwide Over Safety Concerns

In a concerning health alert, injuries linked to pieces of wood found…
Thatcher centennial celebration examines how Reagan partnership guides modern US-UK relations

Exploring Thatcher’s Legacy: How Her Alliance with Reagan Shapes Today’s US-UK Relations

Trump speaks with Putin one day before meeting with Zelenskyy Fox News’…
DHS to impose $1K fee for migrants granted humanitarian parole

New DHS Rule: $1,000 Fee Introduced for Humanitarian Parole Recipients

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) announced on Thursday a significant change…
State attorneys general sue Trump administration for canceled solar program funding

State Attorneys General Challenge Trump Administration Over Solar Program Funding Cuts

On Thursday, more than a dozen state attorneys general filed a lawsuit…
Kim Kardashian wanted Sarah Paulson to 'bring it' when the star dressed up as her in 'All's Fair'

Kim Kardashian Challenges Sarah Paulson to ‘Bring It’ in Epic ‘All’s Fair’ Costume Showdown

LOS ANGELES — The glitz and glamour of Hollywood were in full…
Teen street musician jailed for leading anti-Putin song performance in St. Petersburg: report

Teen Street Musician Arrested for Performing Anti-Putin Song in St. Petersburg: Report

A teenage street performer has been incarcerated in St. Petersburg for leading…
Fox News True Crime Newsletter: Alex Murdaugh's money man, Charles Manson's cult, 'Smiley Face' killer theory

Fox News True Crime Newsletter: Insights into Alex Murdaugh’s Financial Confidant, Charles Manson’s Cult, and the ‘Smiley Face’ Killer Hypothesis

MIRACULOUS ESCAPE: A chilling video has surfaced showing a gunman stalking a…
Trump to meet with Zelenskyy as Ukraine pushes for powerful American Tomahawk missiles amid ongoing war

Trump-Zelenskyy Meeting: Ukraine’s Strategic Bid for American Tomahawk Missiles Amid Conflict

President Donald Trump is slated to host Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy at…
Hamas Reprisals: Terror Group Accused of Killing Pregnant Woman, 5-Year-Old in Gaza

Hamas Retaliations: Accusations Arise Over Killing of Pregnant Woman and Child in Gaza

A venomous snake’s nature is to be feared, and in this instance,…
'No Kings' protest Chicago: Demonstrators preparing to gather downtown in Grant Park on Saturday to oppose Trump administration

Demonstrators Set to Convene in Grant Park for ‘No Kings’ Protest Against Trump Administration

CHICAGO — On Saturday, the organizers of the “No Kings” protest anticipate…
Daniel Cameron banking on his name ID to overcome lackluster fundraising in Kentucky Senate race

Can Daniel Cameron’s Name Recognition Outshine Fundraising Gaps in the Kentucky Senate Race?

In a lively gathering in Louisville, Kentucky, Senate hopeful Daniel Cameron addressed…
LA county reaches tentative $828M agreement to settle 400 more claims of sexual abuse

LA County Agrees to $828M Settlement for 400 Sexual Abuse Claims: A Major Step Towards Justice

Los Angeles County has reached a preliminary agreement worth $828 million to…