Nancy Guthrie ransom notes exposes sick plot against family, ex-FBI agent claims

A retired FBI agent suggests the family of Nancy Guthrie should consider paying half of the demanded bitcoin ransom to test whether it might finally provide clues to her location.

Earlier this week, TMZ received two alleged ransom notes requesting one bitcoin—approximately $72,000—in exchange for information about the 84-year-old’s disappearance from her Arizona residence. These notes also promised to deliver the kidnappers “on a silver platter.”

Jennifer Coffindaffer, a former FBI agent, shared her insights with Newsweek, saying, “Testing the waters in this situation means offering half a bitcoin to see the response it generates.”


A photo of Nancy Guthrie on display at a TV station with handwritten notes and prayers from the public.
Purported ransom notes reveal a sick plot to continue to “torment” Nancy Guthrie’s family for a quick profit, according to a former FBI agent. Getty Images

She pondered, “Will they accept it? Convert it into pesos? It’s traceable internationally. How does it transition into currency, or do they simply leave it untouched?” The notes imply that the elderly mother of “Today” show host Savannah Guthrie might have been taken to Mexico.

Coffindaffer added, “Once the money is gone, it’s gone. However, that final clue could be invaluable. To me, it would be worth the risk.”

Since Guthrie’s abduction from her Tucson, Arizona, home on February 1, investigators have yet to identify any suspects or uncover significant new leads in the case.

Multiple purported ransom notes were sent in the weeks following her disappearance — including several sent to TMZ.


Savannah Guthrie and her siblings making a statement regarding their mother Nancy's disappearance.
The purported notes were sent just as Savannah Guthrie made her “Today” show return. Instagram / Savannah Guthrie

The latest notes to the outlet were sent from the same anonymous person who demanded one bitcoin two months ago.

The sick sender noted in the first note that the grandmother was dead but the prior offer to “deliver [the kidnappers] on a silver platter” still stands.

In a second note, the sender claimed to have seen Guthrie alive with her captors in the Mexican state of Sonora.

The pair of notes were sent just as Guthrie’s daughter, Savannah Guthrie, made her emotional return to NBC’s “Today” show for the first time since her mom vanished.

You May Also Like
World Cup worker, 22, killed while walking home from SoFi Stadium

22-Year-Old World Cup Worker Killed on Walk Home From SoFi Stadium

A 22-year-old SoFi Stadium employee, who was reportedly just two days into…
NYC couple gets engaged atop NYPD car during Knicks parade

NYC Couple’s Knicks Parade Proposal Atop NYPD Car Goes Viral

As Jalen Brunson, OG Anunoby and the rest of the New York…
Pastor Breaks Record by Preaching for 96 Hours: 'Jesus Is Worthy'

Pastor Sets Record With 96-Hour Marathon Sermon Declaring Jesus Is Worthy

A Baptist pastor known for his passion for Scripture has reportedly set…
Polymarket predicts win for Espaillat, Lander, Valdez and Lasher

Polymarket Election Odds Favor Espaillat, Lander, Valdez and Lasher

With limited polling available before Tuesday’s closely watched contested congressional primaries in…
WHCD Shooting Suspect Cole Allen Loses Fight to Remove Top Prosecutors from Case - Internewscast Journal

WHCD Shooting Suspect Cole Allen Loses Fight to Remove Top Prosecutors from Case

A federal judge on Monday declined to disqualify Acting Attorney General Todd…
US military conducts strike on another vessel carrying alleged narco-traffickers, killing 2

US Military Strike on Suspected Drug-Trafficking Vessel Kills 2

The U.S. military said Sunday it carried out a deadly strike on…
Los Angeles is Burning Again. Karen Bass and Gavin Newsom Are Once Again Slow Rolling Their Response

Los Angeles Fires Ignite New Backlash Over Karen Bass and Gavin Newsom’s Slow Response

A warehouse fire broke out Wednesday in Boyle Heights, east of Downtown…
Southwest jet struck by ground equipment vehicle at Memphis airport

Southwest Flight Struck by Ground Vehicle on Memphis Airport Tarmac

A Southwest Airlines aircraft was hit by a ground service vehicle while…
Zohran Mamdani Targets Pro-Israel PAC Again as ‘Monsters’ Remark Fuels Anti-Jewish Violence Concerns - Internewscast Journal

Zohran Mamdani Targets Pro-Israel PAC Again as ‘Monsters’ Remark Fuels Anti-Jewish Violence Concerns

Mayor Zohran Mamdani is standing by his decision to describe a pro-Israel…
Major dispute to threaten Trump's Iran deal over billions in frozen Tehran funds: expert

Expert Warns Frozen Iranian Funds Dispute Could Derail Trump’s Iran Deal

As American and Iranian negotiators gathered in Switzerland on Sunday, a regional…
Mom accused of starving to death her 20-month-old daughter on just 250 calories a day

Mother Accused of Starving 20-Month-Old Daughter to Death on 250 Calories a Day

A Missouri mother is facing accusations that she fatally starved her 20-month-old…
US and Iran wrap second day of talks after rough start; Trump made remarks that Iran called insulting, prompting a temporary pause

US and Iran Conclude Second Day of Talks After Trump Remarks Trigger Brief Pause

OBBUERGEN, Switzerland — Senior officials from the United States and Iran concluded…