Nancy Guthrie ransom notes exposes sick plot against family, ex-FBI agent claims

A retired FBI agent suggests the family of Nancy Guthrie should consider paying half of the demanded bitcoin ransom to test whether it might finally provide clues to her location.

Earlier this week, TMZ received two alleged ransom notes requesting one bitcoin—approximately $72,000—in exchange for information about the 84-year-old’s disappearance from her Arizona residence. These notes also promised to deliver the kidnappers “on a silver platter.”

Jennifer Coffindaffer, a former FBI agent, shared her insights with Newsweek, saying, “Testing the waters in this situation means offering half a bitcoin to see the response it generates.”


A photo of Nancy Guthrie on display at a TV station with handwritten notes and prayers from the public.
Purported ransom notes reveal a sick plot to continue to “torment” Nancy Guthrie’s family for a quick profit, according to a former FBI agent. Getty Images

She pondered, “Will they accept it? Convert it into pesos? It’s traceable internationally. How does it transition into currency, or do they simply leave it untouched?” The notes imply that the elderly mother of “Today” show host Savannah Guthrie might have been taken to Mexico.

Coffindaffer added, “Once the money is gone, it’s gone. However, that final clue could be invaluable. To me, it would be worth the risk.”

Since Guthrie’s abduction from her Tucson, Arizona, home on February 1, investigators have yet to identify any suspects or uncover significant new leads in the case.

Multiple purported ransom notes were sent in the weeks following her disappearance — including several sent to TMZ.


Savannah Guthrie and her siblings making a statement regarding their mother Nancy's disappearance.
The purported notes were sent just as Savannah Guthrie made her “Today” show return. Instagram / Savannah Guthrie

The latest notes to the outlet were sent from the same anonymous person who demanded one bitcoin two months ago.

The sick sender noted in the first note that the grandmother was dead but the prior offer to “deliver [the kidnappers] on a silver platter” still stands.

In a second note, the sender claimed to have seen Guthrie alive with her captors in the Mexican state of Sonora.

The pair of notes were sent just as Guthrie’s daughter, Savannah Guthrie, made her emotional return to NBC’s “Today” show for the first time since her mom vanished.

You May Also Like

Lindsey Graham joked 'I can't die now' after complaining he felt unwell hours before sudden death at 71

Lindsey Graham Quipped ‘I Can’t Die Now’ After Feeling Unwell Hours Before Sudden Death at 71

Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) reportedly responded with dark humor after telling someone…
When Our Loss Is Heaven's Gain

Remembering a Loved One: When Earthly Loss Becomes Heaven’s Gain

As tributes poured in following the death of Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.)…
Colt Gray, georgia teen charged in Apalachee High School shooting set to appear in court for plea

Colt Gray, Georgia Teen Charged in Apalachee High School Shooting, Due in Court for Plea

ATLANTA — A Georgia judge has scheduled a plea and sentencing hearing…
Never-before-seen 'evidence' in Scott Peterson slay case of wife Laci could clear him: bombshell documentary

New Documentary Claims Unseen Evidence Could Exonerate Scott Peterson in Laci Peterson Murder Case

A new documentary is drawing attention with what backers describe as significant,…
Kansas parents allegedly left 6 kids, including 2 infants, in hot car while they dined at fast food chain

Kansas Parents Accused of Leaving 6 Children, Including Infants, in Hot Car While Eating at Fast-Food Restaurant

A Kansas couple is accused of leaving six children, among them two…
Mitch McConnell Releases Photo in the Hospital, Says He Had a Fall

Mitch McConnell Shares Hospital Photo After Fall Raises Health Questions

Kentucky Republican Sen. Mitch McConnell shared a hospital photo and publicly addressed…
Far-left Californian's wicked two-word response to Lindsey Graham's death

California Progressive Criticized for Two-Word Comment on Lindsey Graham’s Death

A claim circulating online falsely states that Senator Lindsey Graham has died…
Sacramento sheriff goes scorched earth on Gov. Gavin Newsom

Sacramento Sheriff Unleashes Fiery Attack on Gov. Gavin Newsom

Sacramento County Sheriff Jim Cooper sharply criticized Gov. Gavin Newsom and state…
Family checks into Airbnb for the first time. Then find pictures of themselves on the wall: 'Spiraling'

Family Finds Photos of Themselves on Wall During First Airbnb Stay, Sparking Panic

A family’s Airbnb getaway became unexpectedly surreal when they stepped inside the…
St. Sabina hold Sunday Mass without Father Michael Pfleger amid Archdiocese of Chicago investigation into sexual abuse accusation

St. Sabina Holds Mass Without Father Michael Pfleger as Chicago Archdiocese Investigates Abuse Allegation

CHICAGO () — Parishioners at Saint Sabina are rallying behind Father Michael…
LA takes a spin at "SubwayTakes" swapping trains for gridlock

LA Puts Its Own Spin on SubwayTakes, Trading Trains for Traffic

A new kind of conversation is unfolding during the Los Angeles commute.…
McConnell breaks weeks of silence about health condition in new note

Mitch McConnell Addresses Health Condition After Weeks of Silence in New Note

Sen. Mitch McConnell said his latest hospital stay followed a fall. WASHINGTON…