Decision imminent in landmark US Department of Justice lawsuit over immigration enforcement in Chicago and across Illinois
Share this @internewscast.com

CHICAGO (WLS) — An important ruling is expected soon regarding a lawsuit about immigration enforcement in Illinois, which could have significant constitutional consequences.

A judge from the U.S. district court is poised to determine if a federal lawsuit against Illinois, including Cook County and the city of Chicago, concerning the collaboration with immigration enforcement, will proceed or be thrown out.

The ABC7 I-Team reviewed court filings in the case to learn more about the arguments that the U.S. Department of Justice is making.

ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch

The lawsuit was filed in February shortly after U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi took office.

The federal government contends that Illinois laws restricting cooperation between Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and local police are unlawfully obstructing immigration enforcement, potentially endangering public safety.

In one example included in the filing, federal officials allege a suspect wanted on an immigration detainer was being held in Cook County jail in August 2024, and following state and local laws, jail officials refused to honor ICE’s detainer.

That individual was released, and months later, the DOJ claims they were “subsequently arrested.. for criminal sexual assault and abuse of a minor.”

The examples listed in the court filings do not include any specific details, such as the suspects names or local law enforcement agencies involved in the investigations.

ABC7 Chief Legal Analyst Gil Soffer said while the Illinois TRUST Act and Chicago Welcoming City ordinance may not be found to be outright illegal, it comes down to how they are enforced.

“The state generally would have a right not to cooperate, or affirmatively volunteer to cooperate with the feds,” Soffer said. “It doesn’t have the right to obstruct the feds, and that’s really the key question.”

Soffer said the case boils down to the line between state and federal rights.

“What are the powers of the feds? What are the powers of the states? How do you separate them, and how do you honor each of them?” Soffer said. “This case calls that very concept into question.”

In their filed arguments, U.S. attorneys assert federal powers are “broad and undoubted over the subject of immigration and the status of aliens,” and that prohibiting collaboration makes immigration enforcement “nearly impossible.”

But immigration enforcement has been occurring in Illinois since President Donald Trump took office for his second term.

While ICE has not released the number of arrests at the local or state level, federal data published by Syracuse University’s TRAC, and reviewed by the I-Team, shows from January to March of this year, 6,430 new deportation proceedings were filed in Illinois immigration court.

Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul told the I-Team he believes a judge weighing in on this issue is necessary, even if the issue at the center of the case has been argued and settled before.

“I’m pleased that the Department of Justice chose to sue Illinois first, so that we can get clarity for our local law enforcement departments throughout the state,” Raoul said, adding that this has been litigated twice before.

Raoul said of the verdicts in those cases, “The 10th Amendment protects states against being commandeered by the federal government to do what is the federal government’s work.”

In court filings, the state of Illinois has argued there are no federal laws that compel state or local police to “facilitate or effectuate civil immigration detentions” while underscoring local law enforcement will always comply with federal warrants, separate from detainers.

“Congress’s power to determine who may lawfully be in the United States does not include the power to conscript state and local police as federal immigration agents,” the state has argued.

Raoul said he expects the case to be dismissed.

“There is no state department of immigration enforcement. There is no city department of immigration enforcement,” Raoul told the I-Team. “We’ve accepted for a long time now that that is the job of the federal government.”

Cook County and the city of Chicago have also argued the U.S. has failed to state a claim and the case should be dismissed.

Northern District of Illinois Judge Lindsay Jenkins is expected to make a decision on whether the case moves forward or is dismissed any day now.

Copyright © 2025 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Supreme Court National Guard news: Supreme Court ruling keeps Donald Trump's Chicago National Guard deployment blocked, for now

Supreme Court Upholds Block on Trump’s Chicago National Guard Deployment: What It Means for the City

WASHINGTON — In a significant decision on Tuesday, the Supreme Court blocked…
Morgan Geyser now: Wisconsin judge sends suspect in Slender Man stabbing of Payton Leutner back to mental health institution

Breaking Update: Morgan Geyser’s Return to Mental Health Facility in Slender Man Case Shocks Wisconsin

In Madison, Wisconsin, a woman previously involved in a near-fatal attack on…
Brown University students shaken as relief, anger collide after suspected shooter's death

Brown University Community Reacts to Suspected Shooter’s Death: Relief and Anger Emerge

The Brown University community, along with residents of Providence, can finally exhale…
Israeli hostages freed, Iran hit, ceasefire held — 2025 shattered idea that US was exiting the Middle East

Israeli Hostages Released, Iran Targeted, Ceasefire Maintained: 2025 Underscores Continued U.S. Engagement in the Middle East

In recent years, Washington has often declared its intention to scale back…
4 indicted in foiled New Year's Eve terror bombing plot targeting Southern California businesses

Southern California Bombing Plot Thwarted: Four Indicted in New Year’s Eve Terror Scheme

In a significant development, four people have been federally charged in a…
Woman dies in NJ senior home fire that injures 8 police officers

Tragic NJ Senior Home Fire Claims Life, Injures 8 Brave Officers: A Community in Mourning

An early morning blaze erupted at a senior housing facility in New…
Delaware state trooper killed in DMV shooting incident, gunman also dead with no active threat: officials

Tragic Shooting at Delaware DMV: State Trooper and Gunman Confirmed Dead, No Ongoing Threat

A tragic event unfolded at a Division of Motor Vehicles building in…
NC Judge Jerry Tillett Caught in Violent N‑Word Tirade

North Carolina Judge Jerry Tillett Involved in Controversial Incident Involving Offensive Language

A prominent former Senior Resident Superior Court Judge, now a candidate for…
Cities across Europe revise Christmas traditions, triggering public backlash

European Cities Tweak Christmas Traditions: Public Outrage and Cultural Debate Ensue

‘Modern’ nativity sparks outrage in Belgium In a provocative twist to traditional…
South Austin, Chicago crime: Third suspect charged in beating of Larry Gilkey on CTA bus in 700-block of South Cicero Avenue

Third Suspect Charged in South Austin, Chicago CTA Bus Assault on Larry Gilkey

CHICAGO (WLS) — Chicago police announced on Tuesday that a third individual…
DOJ sues Illinois JB Pritzker, Attorney General Kwame Raoul over law protecting immigrants at courthouses, hospitals

DOJ Initiates Legal Action Against Illinois Governor JB Pritzker and Attorney General Kwame Raoul Over Immigrant Protection Law at Courthouses and Hospitals

The Department of Justice has initiated legal action against Illinois Governor JB…
Jacksonville gears up for Gator Bowl: Traffic plans, shuttle options for fans

Jacksonville Prepares for Gator Bowl with Comprehensive Traffic and Shuttle Plans for Fans

As the 2025 TaxSlayer Gator Bowl approaches, Jacksonville’s city leaders are meticulously…