Grief-stricken mother demands 911 dispatcher reform
Share this @internewscast.com

Cheryl Collins called 911, pleading for assistance to save her daughter’s life. However, the Baker County dispatcher who answered couldn’t provide CPR instructions.

BAKER COUNTY, Fla. — Cheryl Collins’ voice cracked with fear as she pleaded with a Baker County 911 dispatcher for help.

“My daughter passed out on the floor and I don’t know what to do.”

Her 28-year-old daughter, Emily, was lying unresponsive on the bathroom floor. Cheryl had made the call that no parent wishes to make. She was desperate, terrified, and hoping that someone on the other end could guide her in rescuing her daughter.

“Do I do anything like compressions or anything?” Cheryl asked.

“You’re completely fine. Yes, ma’am. You are fine. I’ll get someone headed that way,” the dispatcher replied.

Yet, Collins did not receive the crucial instructions she so urgently needed. There were no CPR directions, no medical help provided. Only the assurance that help was on its way.

“Help me with CPR or something,” Cheryl pleaded moments later.

The response from the dispatcher: “It’s going to get quiet for just a second while I’m talking to rescue, but stay on the line with me, OK?”

Emily Collins had struggled with chronic illness, but this time, her mother said, something was different. She hoped a dispatcher would tell her how to perform CPR until paramedics arrived.

The dispatcher later admitted what no caller wants to hear during an emergency.

“I am not able to give CPR instructions over the phone,” she said. Um, I’m not sure if that was something you wanted to start doing, um, but they are coming as quick as possible.”

Cheryl watched helplessly as the minutes dragged on. Emily never regained consciousness.

“Anthony, those 9 minutes were the longest 9 minutes you could ever imagine,” Cheryl said.

Now, the family is left with unimaginable grief and a list of painful questions. 

Florida law is clear: all 911 dispatchers must be trained in CPR and able to provide over-the-phone instructions. If they’re not, the law requires them to transfer the call to someone who is.

That didn’t happen in Emily Collins’ case in November 2024.

“You don’t know if CPR could have saved your daughter’s life,” Anthony Austin said to Cheryl. “But you didn’t even have the chance to find out.”

“And now I blame myself and I blame the 911 dispatcher and the sheriff’s office,” she replied.

Dennis Collins, Cheryl’s husband, shook his head during the interview.

“I can’t believe it. It’s unimaginable that they wouldn’t tell you how to save a life,” he said.

In response to questions from Anthony Austin, Baker County Undersheriff Randy Crews confirmed the dispatcher was not trained in CPR when she took the call.

“Since the incident involving Miss Collins’ daughter Emily, the Baker County Dispatch Division has taken significant steps to improve our emergency response capabilities,” Crews said in a statement.

He said the county is now implementing Emergency Medical Dispatcher (EMD) training and adding over-the-phone CPR guidance for dispatchers. 

Crews acknowledged that limited resources have long posed a challenge.

“Baker County is a fiscally constrained county, and maintaining full staffing remains a challenge,” he said. “I submitted a request to the Baker County Board of Commissioners for additional funding to support both increased dispatcher staffing and the cost of EMD training. That request was approved, and we are moving forward with these enhancements.”

For Cheryl and Dennis Collins, the changes are welcome, but too late to save Emily.

“We’re not giving up until we get something done for Baker County and its residents,” Cheryl and Dennis Collins said.

Anthony Austin reached out to Baker County commissioners for comment on funding and what oversight is in place to ensure 911 dispatchers comply with state law. The Ask Anthony team is also investigating 911 dispatch protocols in neighboring counties.

If you have a problem you can’t solve, email AskAnthony@firstcoastnews.com  

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
ATK Scotty's Jacksonville murder case rests, testimony for Ksoo will continue

ATK Scotty’s Murder Trial in Jacksonville Concludes, Testimony for Ksoo Set to Continue

Leroy Whitaker, also known as ATK Scotty, is being tried for the…
Kelley Wolf struggles to enter family home during live stream after Scott Wolf drops restraining order

Kelley Wolf Faces Difficulties Entering Family Home on Live Stream After Scott Wolf Lifts Restraining Order

Kelley Wolf encountered difficulties when attempting to enter her family home, just…
345 Park Avenue NYC shooting: Off-duty NYPD officer Didarul Islam funeral to take place Thursday

Funeral for Off-Duty NYPD Officer Didarul Islam, Victim of 345 Park Avenue NYC Shooting, Scheduled for Thursday

NEW YORK — The memorial service for NYPD officer Didarul Islam, who…
NYC shooting timeline shows gunman moved with speed in cross-country drive that ended with office bloodshed

Timeline of NYC Shooting Reveals Gunman’s Quick Cross-Country Drive Leading to Office Tragedy

Four individuals have lost their lives after a man launched an attack…
Japanese TV footage of several beached whales in Tateyama, Chiba prefecture.

Tragic Video Captures Whales Stranded on Japanese Shore Following Russian Earthquake and Tsunami Alert

HEARTBREAKING footage shows giant whales washed up on a beach in Japan…
Colorado dentist accused of poisoning his wife felt trapped in his marriage, prosecutor says

Prosecutor claims Colorado dentist alleged of wife’s poisoning felt stuck in marriage

CENTENNIAL, Colo. (AP) — Prosecutors allege that a Colorado dentist, accused of…
Scott Jennings Nails Americans' Flip to Trump After Being a Critic Himself: ‘I Didn’t Get It’

Scott Jennings Explains Americans’ Shift Toward Trump Despite His Initial Criticism: ‘I Didn’t Understand It’

During his appearance on the “PBD” podcast on Tuesday, host Patrick Bet-David…
New: The Story Behind the No Good, Horrible, Very Bad Day North Carolina Democrats Had

Breaking Down North Carolina Democrats’ Terrible, No Good Day

As reported by my colleague Ward Clark earlier, a significant event unfolded…
Jimmy Hoffa's family calls on Trump to release FBI files

Hoffa Family Urges Trump to Unseal FBI Documents

Fifty years ago today, at 2:30 p.m. in the parking lot of…
Russian doctors perform surgery during Kamchatka Peninsula earthquake

Doctors in Russia conduct surgery amidst Kamchatka Peninsula earthquake

A dramatic video captures courageous doctors in Russia proceeding with surgery amidst…
Center Point principal placed on leave following arrest

Center Point School Principal Suspended After Recent Arrest

The following story was written by Terry Schrimscher of the Trussville Tribune.…
Senate confirms Emil Bove to appeals court despite whistleblower complaints, controversy

Senate Approves Emil Bove for Appeals Court Amid Whistleblower Allegations and Controversy

The Senate confirmed Emil Bove’s appointment to the Third Circuit Court of…