Asking Eric: Without public weigh-ins, weight-loss motivation falters


How Public Weigh-Ins Fuel Weight-Loss Success: Insights from Eric

Dear Eric: Like many, my weight fluctuates significantly. Throughout the years, I’ve participated in numerous weight-loss programs, consistently reaching my desired weight each time, with a notable 100-pound loss at one point. I adhere to these programs almost entirely, finding the weekly weigh-ins particularly encouraging.

I’ve developed some positive habits along the way, such as exercising five to six times weekly and significantly upping my vegetable intake. However, once I hit my target weight and stop attending regular weigh-ins, I tend to overeat. Although I continue to weigh myself at home, it doesn’t seem to inspire me to manage my eating habits. Is there a way to maintain that weight-loss motivation without having to invest in yet another program that’s essentially a weekly public weigh-in?

– Seeking Self-Motivation

Dear Self-Motivation: You might find an accountability partner to be incredibly helpful. This could be someone who is also on a journey to improve their eating habits or body image, or simply a friend or family member who supports you wholeheartedly. Alternatively, consider joining an online community or forming your own group for support.

Your experience suggests that the act of weighing in and sharing your progress with others who understand your objectives is a powerful motivator. This process seems to work well because it fosters clear expectations without inducing shame. You can recreate this environment by openly sharing your goals and expectations with others, inviting them to witness your progress. They can celebrate your successes and offer encouragement when you face setbacks.

From what you’ve written, it seems that the habit of weighing in and then reporting back to others who know what your goals are is really motivating. It also sounds like these are processes that, crucially, involve clear expectations but not shame. You can create the same dynamic by telling others what your goals are, what you expect of yourself, and asking them simply to witness your journey. They can cheer you on when you achieve a goal and can give you encouragement when you don’t.

Dear Eric: I get a holiday card from a family consisting of a mom, dad and daughter. They also have a son that died in infancy several years ago. They still put his name on the card. I think this is a little weird. Your thoughts?

– Card Question

Dear Card Question: I don’t think it’s weird. But respectfully, it doesn’t matter what I or you think about it at all. This is how this family is processing a profound loss. And, while it wouldn’t be some people’s choice, by putting their son’s name on their holiday card, they are sharing a part of their lives and their emotional journey that’s meaningful. I see this vulnerability as a gift.

While it’s perfectly fine to put a simple greeting on a holiday card, or any card, when we reach out to family and friends in this way, we’re inviting them into our lives as those lives change and challenge us. I would guess that by putting their son’s name on their card, they’re inviting the recipients to see their full family, as they see it – bonded not by life, but by love. Suffice it to say, their son is still their son and still important to them.

It’s fine if it’s not to your taste. Perhaps don’t put it on your fridge or mantel. But next year, try to see it as an invitation into their lives. You don’t have to accept said invitation but consider being grateful that they trust you enough to make the offer.

Dear Eric: I’m deaf, gradually lost my hearing and got a cochlear implant in December 1994. I wanted to respond to “Hearing Jokes”, a person with hearing loss whose hearing-impaired siblings staged an intervention because the letter writer didn’t want to get a hearing aid.

I would recommend that “Hearing Jokes” join the Association of Late Deafened Adults (ALDA) and attend some meetings either in person or online. I also recommend joining the Hearing Loss Association of America (HLAA) and attending meetings in person or online. Most of these members (by far the majority) do not identify as deaf but work to find peace of mind first with themselves and then with others.

It is a process to find ways to cope with hearing loss itself and to cope with the feelings of shame and negativity. These people can share their stories with “Hearing Loss” and help the letter writer to find a place of peace within.

– Community and Hope

Dear Community: Thank you for these great resources. Sometimes friends and loved ones won’t do what they need to do to fix a problem, medical, emotional, psychological, or other. While it’s important to support and sometimes coax them, it’s also crucial to remember that everyone has autonomy. We can’t be forced into doing what’s right for us. What I appreciate about your suggestions is that they offer the letter writer tools to change his or her own mind and to overcome the internal blocks that have impeded addressing the hearing loss in the first place.

(Send questions to R. Eric Thomas at eric@askingeric.com or P.O. Box 22474, Philadelphia, PA 19110. Follow him on Instagram and sign up for his weekly newsletter at rericthomas.com.)

©2026 Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

You May Also Like

Gov. Gavin Newsom reveals the moment he decided to spare all of California’s 548 death row inmates

Gavin Newsom Reveals Why He Spared All 548 California Death Row Inmates

Gov. Gavin Newsom has disclosed the pivotal conversation that helped persuade him…
LA City Council advances 2028 Olympics homelessness plan amid spending and cleanup concerns

LA City Council Advances 2028 Olympics Homelessness Plan Amid Costs

Los Angeles leaders are racing to contain the city’s homelessness crisis before…
9 mystery fingerprints from OJ Simpson murder case could hold new clues more than 30 years later

Nine Unidentified Fingerprints in O.J. Simpson Murder Case May Offer New Clues 30 Years Later

Nine fingerprints that went unidentified during the original O.J. Simpson murder investigation…
Melania Trump announces LSU scholarship program for former foster care kids

Melania Trump Announces LSU Scholarships for Students Formerly in Foster Care

Melania Trump on Saturday announced a multimillion-dollar partnership between Louisiana State University…
Denver man found dead at bottom of national park canyon beneath steep drop-offs

Denver Man Found Dead Below Steep Canyon Drop-Offs in National Park

Colorado authorities said Wednesday that a man was found dead at Black…
Stephen Miller pledges 'absolute loyalty' to Trump in first speech as WH chief of staff

Stephen Miller Vows ‘Absolute Loyalty’ as White House Chief of Staff

New White House Chief of Staff Stephen Miller promised “absolute loyalty” and…
Urgent weather warning as SoCal fire risk intensifies and power shutoffs loom

Southern California Fire Risk Intensifies as Urgent Weather Warning Raises Power Shutoff Threat

Southern California is facing a dangerous weekend of powerful Santa Ana winds…
Vegas lawyer Michael Sanft who represented Tupac Shakur murder suspect Duane ‘Keffe D’ Davis is found dead 

Vegas Lawyer Michael Sanft, Tupac Suspect Keffe D’s Attorney, Found Dead

Michael Sanft, the lawyer who represented Tupac Shakur’s convicted killer Duane “Keffe…
Florida teen 'morons' beat disabled man in sickening 40-minute attack at bonfire party

Florida Teens Charged in 40-Minute Bonfire Attack on Disabled Man

Four Florida men have been arrested after allegedly taking part in a…
Newsom orders California’s most reviled killers off death row – 10 of the worst who could benefit

10 Notorious California Killers Who Could Benefit From Newsom’s Order

California Gov. Gavin Newsom announced Nov. 5 that 548 people on the…
Woman fatally stabbed and found naked inside NYC massage parlor: sources

Woman Found Fatally Stabbed Naked in NYC Massage Parlor, Sources Say

A woman was found stabbed to death inside a Queens massage parlor…
US East Coast could face 'cataclysmic' megatsunami from unstable Spain volcano, scientist warns

Scientist Warns Unstable Spanish Volcano Could Trigger ‘Cataclysmic’ US East Coast Megatsunami

A volatile volcano in Spain’s Canary Islands could eventually send part of…