Keir Starmer speaking at a press conference.
Share this @internewscast.com

AS KING Canute found over a thousand years ago, it is quite difficult to stand on a beach and order the tide to recede. 

Today, it is equally difficult to make the argument that giving families cash is not always the best way of lifting them out of poverty. 

Keir Starmer speaking at a press conference.
Keir Starmer is under massive pressure form Labour backbench MPs to lift the 2 child benefit cap and go on a new welfare spending spreeCredit: AP

This is especially true when one particular measure becomes the symbol of whether or not you’re on the right side of the debate about child poverty.

But as someone who now can afford the comforts of life, I constantly remind myself of my childhood.

The grinding poverty that I experienced when my father was killed

in a work accident when I was 12 – leaving my mother, who had serious health problems, to fight a long battle for minimal compensation.

Having only bread and dripping in the house was, by anyone’s standards, a hallmark of absolute poverty.

Why on earth would I question, therefore, the morality of reversing a Tory policy introduced eight years ago?

This restricts the additional supplement to universal credit – worth over £3,000 a child per year – to just two children. 

My friends often mention that the fastest and simplest way to address the rise in child poverty is to reinstate the £3.5 billion needed to provide extra funds for every child in families eligible for the credit.

It is true that the policy, introduced in 2017, failed its first test.

Women did not stop having more than two children even when they were strapped for cash. It is still unclear why. 

After all, many people have to make a calculation as to how many children they can afford.

Angela Rayner says lifting 2-child benefit cap not ‘silver bullet’ for ending poverty after demanding cuts for millions

One thing is for sure: providing parents with a significant extra amount of money for each child they have while they receive benefits might encourage them to have more children.

Last week, Nigel Farage, the leader of Reform UK, expressed a similar view. His reasoning for reintroducing the benefit for the third and subsequent children is that encouraging low-income families to have more children is necessary.

Surely having children that you cannot afford to feed is the legacy of a bygone era?

All those earning below £60,000 are entitled to the basic child benefit, so the argument is about just over £60 a week extra per child.

One difficulty in having a sensible debate about what really works in overcoming intergenerational poverty is the lack of reliable statistics.

Some people have claimed, over recent days, that over 50 per cent of children in Manchester and Birmingham live in poverty. 

I fear that such claims should be treated with scepticism.

Those struggling to make ends meet – sometimes having not just one but two jobs – who pay their taxes and national insurance and plan their lives around what can be afforded, have the right to question where their hard-earned wages go.

The simple and obvious truth is that child poverty springs from the lack of income of the adults who care for them.

Transforming their lives impacts directly on the children in their family.

There is a limit to how much money taxpayers are willing to hand over to pay for another family’s children. 

Helping them to help themselves is a different matter.

So, what would I do?

Firstly, I would ensure that families with a disabled youngster automatically have the entitlement restored.

This would self-evidently apply also to multiple births. 

In both cases, life is not only more difficult, it is also harder to get and keep a job.

I would come down like a ton of bricks on absent parents.

My mum was a single parent because she was widowed; many others are single in the sense that the other partner has walked away.

The Child Maintenance Service should step up efforts to identify and pursue absent parents who do not pay their fair share towards their child. 

We, the community, have a clear duty to support and assist those in need.

To help those where a helping hand will restore them to independence and self-reliance.

But there is an obligation on individuals as well as the State, and mutual help starts with individuals taking some responsibility for themselves.

Finally, if (and this is where I am in full agreement with colleagues campaigning to dramatically reduce child poverty) we make substantial sums of money available to overcome hardship, then a comprehensive approach to supporting the families must surely be the best way to achieve this.

As ever in politics there is a trade off. What you spend on handing over cash is not available to invest in public services: that is the reality.

Help from the moment a child is born, not just with childcare but with nurturing and child development.

Dedicated backing to gain skills and employment and to taper the

withdrawal of help so that it genuinely becomes worthwhile having and keeping a job. 

A contract between the taxpayer and the individual or household.

Government is about difficult choices, that is why Keir Starmer and his colleagues are agonising over what to do next.

Angela Rayner says lifting 2-child benefit cap not ‘silver bullet’ for ending poverty after demanding cuts for millions
Portrait of David Blunkett at Sheffield Town Hall.
David Blunkett grew up on just bread and dropping at home – but he is warning that lifting the 2 child benefit cap is not the best way to tackle povertyCredit: Alamy
Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Inmates see an unlikely ally as they seek pardons: Trump

Inmates Find Unexpected Support in Trump for Pardons

The flurry of requests has been sparked by Trump’s frequent and eyebrow-raising…
Dramatic video shows violent road rage incident in downtown Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Intense Video Captures Aggressive Road Rage Encounter in Milwaukee’s Downtown Area

MILWAUKEE (WLS) — Dramatic video shows a violent road rage incident in…
Former Minnesota House Speaker Melissa Hortman to lie in state as suspect faces court date

Honoring Former Minnesota House Speaker Melissa Hortman While Suspect Awaits Court Appearance

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — On Friday, the Minnesota Capitol rotunda will host the…
Former banking titan's dirty secret with Epstein employee revealed during failed appeal

Failed Appeal Reveals Former Banking Giant’s Dark Secret with Epstein Associate

A former top banker with connections to Jeffrey Epstein has been unsuccessful…
David Beckham in a hospital bed with his arm in a sling.

David Beckham Undergoes Secret Wrist Surgery 22 Years After Injury Sustained in England Game, Reveals Victoria with Hospital Photo

DAVID Beckham has undergone a secret operation to repair a broken wrist…
Supreme Court permits Trump to end protections for 500,000 immigrants

Supreme Court Set to Announce Rulings on 6 Pending Cases This Friday Morning

One of the questions the justices are considering is whether to restrict…
Trump says he 'hopes' Congress will deliver 'big beautiful bill' for July 4th celebration

Trump Expresses Desire for Congress to Deliver Impressive Bill for July 4th Celebration

WASHINGTON — President Trump announced on Thursday that he still aims to…
Super Bowl halftime performer arrested after police say he held flag stating 'Sudan and Free Gaza.'

Halftime Show Star Detained for Displaying ‘Sudan and Free Gaza’ Banner, say Police.

A performer at Kendrick Lamar’s Super Bowl halftime performance in February has…
Jeff Bezos marries Lauren Sánchez in over-the-top wedding

Jeff Bezos Ties the Knot with Lauren Sánchez in Lavish Wedding Ceremony

He may now bezos the bride. Amazon billionaire Jeff Bezos tied the…
Ex-camp counselor arrested after allegedly threatening violent revenge on Christian camp over firing

Former camp counselor detained for purportedly threatening retaliation against Christian camp following termination

A former camp counselor was taken into custody last weekend for allegedly…
Ace Bailey's reps told team in NBA draft top five he 'wouldn't report' if selected

Ace Bailey’s Agents Informed NBA Draft Teams in Top Five That He Wouldn’t Join If Picked

Ace Bailey had some preferred destinations entering the 2025 NBA Draft, but…
Ask Anthony: Legal twist costs St. Johns Co. woman her license for 3 years

Ask Anthony: Legal Complication Causes St. Johns Co. Woman to Lose License for 3 Years

A Georgia misdemeanor led to a St. Johns County mother losing her…