Justice Department Seeks to Reopen Criminal Case Against Kilmar Abrego Garcia - Internewscast Journal
Justice Department Seeks to Reopen Criminal Case Against Kilmar Abrego Garcia

The Justice Department is seeking to reinstate criminal charges against Kilmar Abrego Garcia, arguing in a late Monday filing that a federal judge wrongly dismantled a case he described as an “abuse of prosecuting power” against a man who had been mistakenly deported to a prison in El Salvador.

Federal prosecutors are challenging a May decision by U.S. District Judge Waverly Crenshaw, who dismissed human smuggling charges against the Salvadoran national. The ruling delivered a striking rebuke to the Justice Department under President Donald Trump, whose administration has faced repeated allegations that it pursued some defendants for political reasons.

Crenshaw concluded that Abrego Garcia would not have been charged at all if he had not prevailed in a lawsuit over his 2025 deportation. The decision was a setback for the Trump administration, which returned him to the United States only after obtaining a criminal indictment.

The judge did not go so far as to say prosecutors acted with “actual vindictiveness,” a demanding legal standard that typically requires direct proof, such as an admission that charges were brought in retaliation. Still, Crenshaw found sufficient evidence of “presumptive vindictiveness,” pointing in part to the timing of the indictment.

The human smuggling case stemmed from a 2022 traffic stop in Tennessee, an episode Homeland Security had known about for more than two years before Abrego Garcia was deported. According to the court’s findings, officials reopened the matter and began pursuing it aggressively only after Abrego Garcia was ordered returned to the United States.

Crenshaw also cited public statements by U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche, who was serving as a deputy at the time, saying they suggested the Justice Department was focusing on Abrego Garcia because he had won his wrongful-deportation case.

In a brief submitted Monday night to the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, federal prosecutors said Crenshaw’s analysis was flawed. They argued that Blanche’s remarks showed a valid basis for prosecution, not retaliation. His reasoning, they wrote, reflected a “normal assessment of the societal interest in punishment” rather than an “improper penalty.” The statements, the brief said, “explained that the government was seeking to protect the public and confirm its prior assertions about Abrego’s criminal activity.”

Prosecutors also argued that even if Blanche’s comments suggested hostility toward Abrego Garcia, they should not control the outcome because the charges were brought by Rob McGuire, then the acting U.S. attorney for the Middle District of Tennessee. That position repeats an argument Crenshaw had already rejected, finding that McGuire’s motives were not the only ones relevant to the case.

Crenshaw’s ruling noted the sustained oversight of the case by top Justice Department officials, including regular communications between McGuire and Associate Deputy Attorney General Aakash Singh, in finding that the criminal case was thoroughly tainted. Crenshaw also noted that prosecutors never called as a witness the investigator who actually reopened the case, to explain why.

Abrego Garcia, 31, is a Salvadoran citizen with an American wife and child who has lived in Maryland for years although he immigrated to the U.S. illegally as a teenager. A 2019 order by an immigration judge prohibited his deportation to El Salvador, finding he had a “well founded fear” of a gang that had targeted his family there. The judge allowed him to live and work in the U.S. under Immigration and Customs Enforcement supervision, but he was not given residency status.

Blocked from re-deporting Abrego Garcia to El Salvador, the Trump administration has vowed to deport him to a third county, threatening to send him to Uganda, Eswatini, Ghana and, most recently, Liberia. Abrego Garcia has said he would agree to be deported to Costa Rica, which has said they will accept him, but the government has so far declined to send him there.

He is fighting deportation to Liberia in a separate federal court case in Maryland.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Mullin: 'Kind of Makes Sense' That Systems Are Going Down Due to Inability to Handle AI/SI Speed

Sen. Markwayne Mullin Says System Failures Make Sense as AI Outpaces Infrastructure

During Monday’s edition of Fox News Channel’s “Hannity,” Department of Homeland Security…
Markwayne Mullin took his government plane to LSU-Texas game as thousands were stranded in FAA ground stoppage

Sen. Mullin Took Government Plane to LSU-Texas Game Amid FAA Halt

WASHINGTON — While thousands of travelers remained stranded at airports nationwide Saturday,…
Ivy League student slashed in neck, suspect accused was arrested just weeks before

Ivy League student slashed in neck; suspect was arrested weeks earlier

A man is facing charges after police say a college student was…
Good Samaritan fatally stabbed foiling NYC dog-napping

Good Samaritan Fatally Stabbed While Stopping Dog Theft in NYC

A passer-by who stepped in to stop a brazen dog-napping in Brooklyn…
Video captures pit bull biting LAPD officer during Skid Row arrest

Video Captures Pit Bull Biting LAPD Officer During Skid Row Arrest

A police officer was bitten below the belt by a pit bull…
Criminal past of Illinois ethanol plant bomb scare suspect includes multiple felonies, 2 prison stints

Illinois Ethanol Plant Bomb Threat Suspect Has Multiple Felonies, Two Prison Terms

FBI probes explosive device found near Illinois ethanol plant Federal authorities launched…
Deal on stalled airline safety bill announced by Cruz with families of D.C. plane crash victims

Sen. Cruz Announces Airline Safety Bill Deal With DC Crash Families

Texas Republican Sen. Ted Cruz said Tuesday that House and Senate negotiators…
Washington man disembowled by hippo on honeymoon safari before wife saves him

Washington Man Survives Hippo Attack on Honeymoon as Wife Saves Him

Fellas, if she won’t punch a hippo in the face to save…
Riverboat worker Leelah Hager made anguished FaceTime call to dad while in Mississippi River after tanker smashed into ship

Leelah Hager FaceTimes Dad After Mississippi River Tanker Crash

A riverboat worker aboard the vessel struck by a tanker in New…
California sheriff's deputy, special officer put on leave after 5-second conversation with ICE agents

California Deputy, Special Officer Put on Leave Over ICE Talk

Two employees of the Orange County Sheriff’s Department have been placed on…
8-year-old Haitian boy detained by ICE in San Diego released from custody

8-Year-Old Haitian Boy Detained by ICE in San Diego Is Released

An 8-year-old Haitian boy detained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement in…
The Post's 225 icons: How Lorne Michaels turned 'SNL' into an institution

How Lorne Michaels Turned Saturday Night Live Into a Cultural Institution

To mark our 225th birthday, The New York Post is celebrating Gotham’s…