Man sentenced for strangling Massachusetts college student to death with tank top in cold case killing

A man who strangled a Massachusetts college student with a tank top nearly 40 years ago received a life sentence on Thursday.

John Carey, age 66, was sentenced after being found guilty on March 3 of first-degree murder in the death of Claire Gravel, a student at Salem State University.

“Claire Gravel’s family has endured a four-decade-long wait for justice,” stated Essex County District Attorney Paul Tucker. “The prosecutors, along with our law enforcement partners, remained committed to Claire’s case. Today, we are gratified that the family has some answers and a measure of closure.”

At the time of his arrest for Gravel’s murder, Carey was already serving a sentence at the Massachusetts Correctional Institution in Concord for an unrelated offense from 2008.

Claire Gravel and an image of a cemetery in Salem.

Claire Gravel, who was only 20, was a Salem State student murdered in June 1986. John Carey received a life sentence for her murder on Thursday. (Getty Images; Essex County District Attorney)

The case dates back to June 29, 1986. Gravel was last seen alive between 1:30 and 1:45 a.m. after visiting Major Magleashes’ Pub in Salem with her softball team. She was dropped off at her Loring Avenue apartment in Salem shortly before she vanished.

Two days later, three workmen discovered her body in the woods.

Salem, Massachusetts graveyard

The cemetery on Bridge Street in Salem, Massachusetts, on March 30, 2011. (Yoon S. Byun/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)

The killing went unsolved for decades until investigators linked Carey’s DNA to samples collected from a tank top, the district attorney’s office said.

A wooden gavel resting on a sound block in a courtroom.

Carey was serving time for an unrelated 2008 conviction when he was charged with Gravel’s murder. (iStock)

“What he left behind was his genetic blueprint on the murder weapon,” Deputy First Assistant District Attorney Kim Faitella told jurors during her closing arguments at Carey’s trial.

At the time of his arrest for Gravel’s death, Carey was already serving a prison sentence on charges related to trying to strangle another woman to death.

–>

You May Also Like
West Suburban Medical Center: Upcoming ruling could determine future of shuttered hospital, Resilience Healthcare CEO accusations

Key Decision Looms for West Suburban Medical Center: Fate of Closed Hospital and CEO Allegations to Be Decided Soon

A heated legal battle is underway regarding the future of West Suburban…
Eight riders left dangling atop 100-foot roller coaster for over three hours at Texas amusement park

Thrilling Rescue: Roller Coaster Riders Stranded 100 Feet High for Hours at Texas Park

In a dramatic turn of events at a Texas amusement park, eight…
Illegal immigrant Jose Medina accused of killing Loyola student Sheridan Gorman caught with weapon in his pants inside jail

Loyola Student’s Suspected Killer, Jose Medina, Found with Concealed Weapon in Jail

A Venezuelan immigrant facing charges for the murder of Loyola University student…
Idaho daredevil dad balanced a running chainsaw on his chin to break world record

Idaho Dad Sets New World Record by Balancing Running Chainsaw on Chin in Daring Stunt

Chin up and face the challenge. A thrill-seeking father achieved a daring…
Booker: Iran's Leader Had Fatwa Against Nukes Until Trump Blew Things Up, They Still Have Enriched Uranium

How Trump’s Actions Dismantled Iran’s Nuclear Stance: The Untold Story of Enriched Uranium and Fatwas

During a recent segment on CNN’s “Situation Room,” Senator Cory Booker from…
Rabid bat found in residential area triggers warning from police

Police Issue Alert After Rabid Bat Discovered in Local Neighborhood

A recent discovery of a rabid bat in a residential vicinity of…
Teen nearly dies after attempting dangerous 'couch surfing' TikTok trend

Teen Hospitalized After Dangerous TikTok ‘Couch Surfing’ Trend Goes Wrong: A Cautionary Tale for Social Media Users

A teenager from Utah has miraculously survived after sustaining critical injuries while…
Marcia Lucas death: Oscar-winning 'Star Wars' editor Marcia Lucas, former wife of director George Lucas, dies at 80

Remembering Marcia Lucas: Oscar-Winning ‘Star Wars’ Editor and George Lucas’ Former Wife Passes Away at 80

Marcia Lucas, an esteemed editor who played a pivotal role in the…
Gov. Sherrill blames ICE, defends rioters after deploying troopers to quell violent mob

Governor Sherrill Criticizes ICE, Justifies Rioters Following Trooper Deployment to Control Violent Unrest

NEWARK, N.J. – Tensions escalated Friday night as organized protesters refused to…
Two-time loser Curtis Sliwa eying another NYC mayoral run in 2029

Can Curtis Sliwa Break the ‘Two-Time Loser’ Streak in 2029 NYC Mayoral Race?

For the third time, Curtis Sliwa, a former Republican contender for New…
NYC killer convicted of gunning down ex-girlfriend while she walked with their baby

NYC Man Found Guilty of Murdering Ex-Girlfriend During Tragic Street Attack with Baby Present

A ruthless Brooklyn man has been found guilty of the cold-blooded murder…
Barrington woman receiving thousands in property tax refunds sent out by Cook County Treasurer's Office after year-long delay

Cook County Finally Delivers: Barrington Resident Receives Long-Awaited Property Tax Refunds Worth Thousands

CHICAGO (WLS) — The ABC7 I-Team has revealed new developments in their…