Louisiana Republicans reject bill that would address split jury verdicts, a Jim Crow-era practice
Share this @internewscast.com

BATON ROUGE, La. (AP) — On Wednesday, a Louisiana bill designed to provide incarcerated individuals, who were convicted by now-outlawed split juries, the chance to request a new trial was shut down by Republican state senators, effectively ending the proposal.

Approximately 1,000 inmates in Louisiana were convicted under this non-unanimous jury system, which has origins in the racist “Jim Crow” era laws and was declared unconstitutional by the U.S. Supreme Court in 2020. Advocates argue that it is long overdue for Louisiana to correct this injustice and offer these individuals the opportunity for a fair trial.

Bill supporters highlighted numerous cases of individuals who, after being wrongly convicted by split juries, were eventually exonerated after spending many years in prison. They argued that the bill could have paved the way for others who might be innocent and convicted under non-unanimous juries to have another opportunity at a just trial.

The bill would have added non-unanimous verdicts to a list of claims for which an inmate can seek a retrial. Proponents reiterated that the legislation would only have created the opportunity to do so and that it would not have automatically granted a retrial or release.

During debate in the state Senate on Wednesday, Republican lawmakers raised concerns about overburdening courts and district attorneys with additional trials. Proponents said whether a new trial is granted is ultimately at the discretion of district attorneys.

Opponents also raised concerns about the cases being decades-old with some witnesses possibly dead or evidence lost. Supporters countered that old cases are tried all the time and that transcripts of testimony from the original trials could be used.

“This is about what’s right, not about what’s easy or convenient,” Sen. Royce Duplessis, the New Orleans Democrat who authored the bill, said to his colleagues.

Louisiana adopted the practice of split jury convictions in 1898 during a constitutional convention that was fueled by efforts to maintain white supremacy after the Civil War. Diluting the voice of Black jurors allowed the often-white majority to determine the outcome.

Louisiana voters did not get rid of the practice until 2018, two years before the Supreme Court ruled that it was a violation of the 6th Amendment’s guarantee of the right to an impartial jury.

At the time, Louisiana and Oregon were the only states that allowed split decisions — 10-2 or 11-1 jury votes — to result in convictions. The Oregon Supreme Court granted new trials to hundreds of people. But Louisiana’s Supreme Court rejected arguments to apply the ruling retroactively.

“If we choose to vote down this bill we’re saying that justice has an expiration date,” Duplessis said. “We have an opportunity in Louisiana to remove this stain, because right now we are the only ones wearing it.”

The bill failed on a vote of 9-26, along party lines. Given the overwhelming lack of support for the bill in the Senate and that there is only a month left in this year’s Legislative Session, the measure currently has no viable path forward and is likely dead.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Yankees' Jazz Chisholm out of Subway Series lineup with shoulder issue

Yankees’ Jazz Chisholm Misses Subway Series Game Due to Shoulder Problem

The Yankees, struggling with a six-game losing streak and several player absences,…
Man in a black jacket holding a red chainsaw.

Elon Musk Unveils New Political Party to Restore American ‘Freedom’ Following Fallout with Trump and Departure from White House

ELON Musk has launched a new political following his explosive row with…
Bobby Jenks, 2-time All-Star and former White Sox closer, dies at 44

Former White Sox Closer and Two-Time All-Star Bobby Jenks Passes Away at 44

He was an All-Star in each of the next two seasons while…
Lolita, a killer whale, performing at the Miami Seaquarium.

What Led to Lolita’s Death? The World’s Loneliest Whale Dies Weeks After Millionaire Promised to Aid Orca’s Release After 50 Years

BELOVED orca Lolita, who was known for her mind-blowing tricks and decades…
Alabama fireworks mishap turns boat into fireball on Fourth of July, six hospitalized

Alabama Fireworks Incident Ignites Boat on Fourth of July, Six Hospitalized

They went out with a bang. A poorly rigged fireworks set-up in…
Michael Douglas says he has no intentions of returning to acting

Michael Douglas announces he doesn’t plan on acting again

Michael Douglas is enjoying his time away from Hollywood. The Oscar winner,…
TX Police Officer Shot in Neck at ICE Detention Center, Multiple Suspects Arrested Wearing Body Armor

Texas Police Officer Shot in the Neck at ICE Detention Center; Several Suspects Wearing Body Armor Arrested

Here’s the situation: late on the Fourth of July in Alvarado, Texas,…
Heather Graham flaunts body in several bikinis during Italy vacation

Heather Graham Shows Off Stunning Bikinis on Italian Getaway

There is no one else who is soaking up the sun more…
Sharon Osbourne disinvites greedy band from Ozzy's Black Sabbath farewell concert

Sharon Osbourne Disinvites Band from Ozzy’s Black Sabbath Farewell Concert Due to Greed

Sharon Osbourne said she disinvited a greedy band from her husband Ozzy…
I overheard my brother fighting with his wife — should I say something?

I overheard my brother arguing with his wife — should I intervene or stay out of it?

DEAR ABBY: I inadvertently received a voicemail from my brother that captured…
How weather conditions set the stage for the deadly Texas flash floods

How Weather Factors Contributed to the Devastating Texas Flash Floods

WASHINGTON (AP) — A massive amount of moisture in the atmosphere powered…
Muddy interior of a flood-damaged cabin with overturned furniture.

Texas Flood Tragedy: 50 Dead Including 15 Children, 27 Girls Missing from Camp Mystic

AT least 50 people including children have been killed in the Texas…