Luigi Mangione argues double jeopardy in bid to drop murder case, suppress evidence
Share this @internewscast.com

The defense team for the man charged with the assassination of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson submitted a motion to the New York Supreme Court on Thursday. They seek to suppress evidence in the prosecution’s case and request a complete dismissal of the charges.

Luigi Mangione’s lawyer, Karen Friedman Angifilo, stated in the filing that statements Mangione made to the Altoona, Pennsylvania police prior to his December 9 arrest should not be admitted at trial.

She argues that two police officers, who found the suspect inside a McDonald’s, “effectively had Mr. Mangione in custody” by blocking the restaurant’s exit during interrogation, without arresting him and informing him of his Miranda rights beforehand.

Friedman Angifilo argues that such questioning violated her client’s Fifth Amendment rights, and thus, his statements made to those officers should be excluded from the trial. 

Luigi Mangione is escorted by NYPD into a van after being extradited from Pennsylvania for the murder of United Healthcare CEO, Brian Thompson.

Luigi Mangione is escorted from an NYPD helicopter in New York City on Thursday, Dec. 19, 2024. Mangione is accused of murdering United Healthcare CEO Brian Thompson. (Rashid Umar Abbasi for Fox News Digital)

Police also found a small item “enclosed in cardboard and wrapped in tape.” Inside was a computer chip which was also taken as evidence.

Further, the motion seeks to ban the state “from eliciting lay non-eyewitness identification testimony at trial.” The state seeks plans to call NYPD Detective Oscar Diaz and Altoona police officers Joseph Detwiler and Tyler Frye to identify Mangione through surveillance footage based on their “familiarity with the defendant.”

“Here, the proposed witnesses are not eyewitnesses to the crime,” according to the motion. “Moreover, the witnesses had no interactions with Mr. Mangione prior to the video surveillance to make them ‘sufficiently familiar’ with Mr. Mangione.”

The defense also asked the court to dismiss the terrorism charges against Mangione, alleging that the grand jury that indicted him “failed to establish the required element that Mr. Mangione intended to intimidate or coerce a civilian population, influence the policies of a unit of government by intimidation or coercion or affect the conduct of a unit of government by murder, assassination or kidnapping.”

Luigi Mangione appears in court

Luigi Mangione appears in Manhattan Criminal Court for a status hearing in New York City on Friday, Feb. 21, 2025. Mangione is accused of killing UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson outside of a Manhattan hotel last year. (Curtis Means/Pool)

Finally, Friedman Angifilo asked the state of New York to drop the entire case against her client, claiming that trying him at the state and federal levels concurrently constitutes double jeopardy and thus a violation of Mangione’s Fifth Amendment rights. 

“This Court is all that stands between justice and Mr. Mangione being forced to stand trial against illegally obtained evidence, terrorism-related charges that have no application to the alleged shooting of one man and concurrent prosecutions that violate the Double Jeopardy Clause and his constitutional rights,” the motion concludes. 

The Manhattan District Attorney’s Office said they will respond in court filings of their own.

Mangione, 26, was also indicted in the Southern District of New York on federal charges of stalking and murdering Thompson, as well as using electronic communications, interstate travel and a firearm when he allegedly killed the healthcare insurance CEO.

Luigi Mangione departs the courtroom following his arraignment

Luigi Mangione departs the courtroom following his arraignment in New York City Criminal Court on Monday, Dec. 23, 2024. (Rashid Umar Abbasi for Fox News Digital)

He was also charged federally with one count of using a firearm to commit murder, one count of interstate stalking resulting in death, one count of stalking through use of interstate facilities resulting in death and one count of discharging a firearm that was equipped with a silencer in furtherance of a crime of violence. 

Mangione is accused of ambushing Thompson outside a Manhattan hotel where UnitedHealthcare’s annual shareholder conference was being held on Dec. 4, 2024. Prosecutors believe the fatal shooting was meant to send a message to the healthcare insurance industry based on a manifesto found on the suspect when he was arrested days after Thompson’s murder.

He would face the death penalty if convicted. 

Fox News Digital’s Audrey Conklin contributed to this report. 

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Report: Now John Bolton's Name Comes Up in the Russia Collusion Hoax—Did He Bury Evidence?

Report: John Bolton Implicated in Alleged Russia Collusion Hoax – Evidence Concealment Questioned

The Russia Collusion story is like the Jeffrey Epstein saga: neither will…
Chicago weather tomorrow: Heat Advisory issued for Monday; heat index expected to exceed 100 degrees in parts of area

Chicago Weather Update: Heat Advisory for Monday with Heat Index Over 100 Degrees Expected in Some Areas

CHICAGO (WLS) — Potentially dangerous heat is expected to impact the Chicago…
Public hanging in Zahedan, Iran.

Concerns Grow that Iran May Execute 30,000 in a Repeat of the 1988 Massacre amid Intensified Crackdown

IRAN’S merciless regime is plotting to kill tens of thousands of prisoners…
At least 3 people shot within an hour in separate bloody incidents at NYC Dominican Day Parade: sources

Three People Shot in Separate Incidents During NYC Dominican Day Parade: Sources

Police and sources reported that at least three individuals were injured in…
Kidnapping survivor, once dismissed as a liar, now retrains police to help victims

Formerly dismissed as a liar, kidnapping survivor now trains police to assist victims

Denise Huskins, who was accused of lying after surviving a home invasion…
Nighttime search and rescue operation at sea.

Search Underway for Missing Passengers After Plane Crashes Into Sea Off California Coast, Debris Found on Shore

A significant search and rescue operation is currently underway after a plane…
Mavi Garcia wins women's Tour de France stage, becomes oldest stage winner at 41

Mavi Garcia Secures Victory in Women’s Tour de France Stage; Sets Record as Oldest Stage Winner at 41

The 41-year-old Spaniard clinched the second stage on Sunday with a solo…
Suspect walking in a parking lot near Or Tor Kor Market in Bangkok, Thailand.

Tragic Mass Shooting at Bangkok Market Leaves At Least Six Dead

AT least six people have been killed after a gunman opened fire…
Tesla Cybertruck owner recounts how thief exploited auto-lock feature to enter vehicle in Downey, California

Tesla Cybertruck Owner Shares How Thief Abused Auto-Lock to Break into Vehicle in Downey, California

A warning for owners of Teslas equipped with the auto-lock feature: Car…
Mike Johnson backs Ghislaine Maxwell speaking on Epstein

Mike Johnson Supports Ghislaine Maxwell’s Statements About Epstein

On Sunday, House Speaker Mike Johnson suggested it would greatly benefit the…
Secret Service thwarts potential threat near Trump's White House grounds with rapid response

Secret Service Swiftly Neutralizes Possible Threat Near Trump’s White House

The U.S. Secret Service announced on Sunday night that they have taken…
JSO disperse '600 to 700' minors near Friendship Fountain for 'takeover' event

Police Disperse Hundreds of Minors Gathered at Friendship Fountain for ‘Takeover’ Event

The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office said the incident violated the city’s local curfew…