Two houses separated by a narrow gap.
Share this @internewscast.com

A £250,000 seven-year neighbours’ row over a few inches of land sparked by a doctor’s garden tap has been blasted as “ridiculous” by a top judge.

Pensioner Christel Naish and her neighbor, Dr. Jyotibala Patel, have been embroiled in a contentious legal dispute over a narrow strip of land between their homes, which is too tight for a person to comfortably pass through.

Two houses separated by a narrow gap.
The legal battle for a few inches of land could cost £250,000 in legal feesCredit: Champion News Service

Ms. Naish raised concerns that Dr. Patel’s garden tap and pipe were intruding onto her property in Ilford, East London, ultimately leading to a costly court case.

After a hearing at the Mayors and City County Court last year, Christel faced over £200,000 in legal expenses when the judge ruled in favor of Jyotibala.

But Ms Naish, 81, is now fighting on, despite being told that the case could end up costing about £500,000 if she wins.

After the trial, Christel had to pay around 65% of her neighbours’ costs, totalling around £100,000 on top of the six-figure sum she ran up herself.

However the appeal itself is costing more than £30,000, the High Court heard, and her lawyers say it could result in “another £200,000” being blown on a second trial if she succeeds.

At the High Court, senior judge Sir Anthony Mann blasted the parties for the “ridiculous” row after hearing that the tap and pipe issue which began the dispute did not even matter any more, with the tap having now been removed by Dr Patel.

Senior judge Mann said: “Hundreds of thousands of pounds about a tap and a pipe that doesn’t matter – this brings litigation into disrepute.

“You don’t care about the pipe and the tap, so why does it matter, for goodness’ sake, where the boundary lies?

“It seems to me to be a ridiculous piece of litigation – on both sides, no doubt.”

The court heard Ms Naish first moved into her semi-detached house in Chadacre Avenue as a teenager with her parents and, although she moved out, frequently returned as she worked there in the family’s tarmac business.

Moment ‘UK’s worst neighbour’ terrorises couple in 18-month tirade of foul-mouthed abuse caught on doorbell camera

She eventually moved back permanently after the death of her father in 2001, with Dr Patel and husband Vasos Vassili buying the house next door for £450,000 in 2013.

The couple’s barrister, Paul Wilmshurst, told the judge that the dispute began due to Ms Naish repeatedly complaining that a tap and pipe outside their house trespassed on her land.

Due to her “terrorising” them with her “petty and vindictive” complaints, they felt forced to sue due to the “blight” on the property’s value caused by the unresolved row, he said.

At the county court, they claimed the tiny gap between the houses – created when the previous owners of their home built an extension on a previously much wider gap in 1983 – was theirs.

They insisted that the boundary between the two properties was the flank wall of Ms Naish’s house and not the edge of her guttering hanging above, as she claimed.

Dr Jyotibala Patel outside the High Court in London.
Dr Patel and her lawyer leaving the High CourtCredit: Champion News Service

But after hearing the trial in 2023, Judge Stephen Hellman last year found for Dr Patel and Mr Vassili, ruling that Ms Naish’s flank wall was the boundary and meaning they own the gap between the houses.

However, he found against them on Ms Naish’s counterclaim, under which she sought damages for damp ingress into her conservatory caused by them having installed decking above the level of her damp proof course.

The judge found that, although the damp problem was already in existence, the installation of the decking screed was a 20% contribution to it, and awarded Ms Naish £1,226 damages.

However, because he had found against her on who owns the gap between the houses, he ordered that she pay 65 per cent of her neighbours’ lawyers’ bills, amounting to about £100,000, on top of her own costs.

Concluding his judgment, he said: “Now that the parties have the benefit of a judgment on the various issues that have been troubling them, I hope that tensions will subside and that they will be able to live together as good neighbours.”

However, Ms Naish has continued to fight and took her case to the High Court for an appeal last week, with judge Sir Anthony Mann asking why the neighbours are pressing on and demanding of Ms Naish’s barrister David Mayall: “What is the point of this litigation?”

He replied: “To be frank, two things: costs and the damp issue,” with Dr Patel’s barrister Mr Wilmshurst adding that they feel they have to fight to protect the value of their home.

“It’s because for many years the appellant has been making allegations about the trespassing nature of the [tap and pipe], thereby making it impossible for them to sell their house,” he said.

Christel Naish outside the High Court.
Ms Naish could face hundreds of thousands of pounds in legal feesCredit: Champion News Service

For Ms Naish, Mr Mayall argued that Judge Hellman’s reasoning in finding that the boundary was the flank wall was “fatally flawed” and should be overturned, although noting a second trial in the event of a successful appeal would cost the parties “another £200,000.”

He said any “reasonable purchaser” looking at the houses when they were first built and conveyed in the 1950s would have assumed that the boundary was the edge of Ms Naish’s guttering, giving her a few inches extra land.

“The only proper conclusion that he could have come to when construing the original conveyance was that the boundary ran along the outermost part of the house as constructed, including the eaves, guttering and foundations,” he said.

“He most certainly could not have concluded that a reasonable person would have understood that the boundary was in such a place as to mean that part of the dwelling as constructed – the eaves, guttering and foundations – were immediately trespassing on the neighbouring land.”

He added: “They insisted that’s where the line lay. We said it certainly doesn’t lie there and we have been ordered to pay £100,000 in costs for the proceedings below.

“What we say is a reasonable purchaser would say, ‘I own the land over which these gutters lie.’ We say there was a fence running along, which was the distance away from the wall that the flank wall of [Dr Patel’s extension] is now.”

But for Dr Patel, who appeared in court, and Mr Vassili, who watched via a video link, Mr Wilmshurst said the appeal was a challenge to findings the judge was entitled to make on the evidence.

“Overall, the judge did not overlook the contention of the appellant as to guttering, eaves and foundations: he considered it directly, evaluated it, and rejected it as being material to where the boundary was,” he said.

“The judge correctly held that the legal boundary was shown by the conveyance plans as running along the flank wall of [Ms Naish’s house], not the outermost projection.

“The appellant does not suggest that there is rule of law that means that a boundary must be synonymous with the eaves, guttering or foundations.

“As shown in this case, the court received expert evidence from an experienced land surveyor that such a state of affairs is not unusual.

“This was a question of fact in this case for the judge to determine.”

On the issue of what contribution to Ms Naish’s damp her neighbours’ decking screed caused, he added: “There is no basis on which it can be properly said that the judge was wrong to find the concrete screed was only responsible for 20% of the damp problems.

“The judge also carried out a site view and was in the best position to form an assessment of the evidence.”

After a day in court, Sir Anthony reserved judgment on the appeal.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Former cop mom slams policies that let illegal alien allegedly strike son in hit-and-run: ‘A lot of problems’

Ex-police officer mother criticizes policies allowing undocumented immigrant to allegedly hit her son in hit-and-run: ‘Numerous Issues’

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! A former police officer…
Former Jacksonville Mayor Alvin Brown out as NTSB vice president

Ex-Jacksonville Mayor Alvin Brown Files Lawsuit Against Trump Administration and NTSB

Alvin Brown was appointed vice chairman of the NTSB but was later…
French Open finals: Coco Gauff defeats Aryna Sabalenka in 3 sets

Coco Gauff Triumphs Over Aryna Sabalenka in Three-Set French Open Final

It was the first No. 1 vs. No. 2 final in Paris…
Fernandina Beach celebrates fifth annual Pride Festival during Pride month.

Fernandina Beach Hosts 5th Annual Pride Festival in Celebration of Pride Month

Fernandina Beach’s fifth Pride Parade fosters unity and inclusion with vibrant festivities,…
National Guard deployed in manhunt for survivalist accused of killing his three young daughters

National Guard Sent in Search for Survivalist Suspected of Killing His Three Young Daughters

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! The hunt has escalated…
NY searched 'Free Palestine' online more than any other state: study

Study Finds New York Leads in ‘Free Palestine’ Online Searches Among States

New Yorkers scoured the web for information on Palestine-related phrases more than…
Third teen death in national forest raises alarm as two high schoolers found shot during camping trip

Third Teenager’s Death in National Forest Sparks Concern After Discovery of Two High School Students Shot on Camping Trip

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! High school students Pandora…
Drone footage showing ground magnetic anomaly; yaw re-aligned.

Amazing New Video of Ukraine’s Operation Spiderweb: Smuggled Drone Launches and Targets Putin’s Burning Bombers

THIS is the moment a smuggled Ukrainian drone launched from the roof…
Judge approves athlete payment plan in landmark college sports decision

Court Endorses Payment Plan for College Athletes in Groundbreaking Ruling

The agreement signifies a major transformation for schools, which now have to…
Germany's Merz to 'adapt' to Trump during high-stakes meeting on tariffs, defense

Germany’s Merz to Adjust Strategy Ahead of Crucial Tariff and Defense Talks with Trump

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! German Chancellor Friedrich Merz…
Joshua Phillips faces review of life sentence for Maddie Clifton's 1998 murder

Review of Joshua Phillips’ Life Sentence in Maddie Clifton’s 1998 Case Underway

Joshua Phillips was convicted of killing 8-year-old Maddie Clifton in November 2018.…
Portrait of a smiling teenage girl wearing a black dress.

19-Year-Old Tragically Passes Away Following TikTok ‘Dusting’ Challenge, Leaving Family Heartbroken

A TEEN, 19, has died after taking part in the viral TikTok…