'House of horrors' suspect accused of holding stepson captive hit with new charges as she denies allegations

A woman from Connecticut, Kimberly Sullivan, is now facing additional charges in a disturbing case where she allegedly kept her stepson captive in a “house of horrors” for over 20 years. This case has captured widespread attention due to its shocking nature.

Kimberly Sullivan, age 57, has been charged with two counts of first-degree kidnapping, alongside accusations of assault, intentional cruelty to persons, and unlawful restraint. These charges reflect new findings as the investigation into this harrowing situation progresses, according to reports from Court TV.

The allegations against Sullivan remain consistent with those she faced last year, with updates integrating the latest developments in the case. During a bond hearing held on March 13, 2025, at Waterbury Superior Court, Sullivan appeared alongside her attorney, Jason Spilka. The hearing was documented by Jim Shannon of Hearst Connecticut Media, with images distributed via the Associated Press pool.

Kimberly Sullivan in court with her lawyer.

In defense of his client, Sullivan’s attorney, Ionnis Kalodis, has firmly stated, “This wasn’t true then, it isn’t true now,” challenging the accusations as false.

According to court documents, Sullivan is accused of confining her stepson, identified only as “S,” in a storage closet for at least 22 hours a day. This alleged confinement began when he was just 11 years old in March 1996. By the time Sullivan was taken into custody, her stepson was 32 years old, highlighting the prolonged duration of this alleged captivity.

Sullivan is accused of locking her stepson in a storage closet for at least 22 hours a day since he was 11 years old in March 1996, according to court records. The stepson, referred to as “S” in court documents, was 32 years old when Sullivan was arrested. 

A police affidavit revealed S told investigators he was fed only two sandwiches and one water bottle each day, and was provided with a second water bottle “for bathing.”

Connecticut house of horrors kimberly sullivan child abuse

Kimberly Sullivan was arrested after allegedly abusing her stepson in their Waterbury, Connecticut home. (Jim Shannon/Hearst Connecticut Media via AP)

A dirty bathroom is seen in Kimberly Sullivan's Connecticut house

This image provided by the Waterbury Police Department shows the home where a Connecticut man told authorities his stepmother held him captive for two decades since he was a boy. (Waterbury Police Department via AP)

In February 2025, S lit Sullivan’s Waterbury house on fire to escape captivity. He was just 68 pounds when firefighters pulled him from the burning building. 

Last year, Sullivan was granted access to her stepson’s new identity, medical records and current address after asking a judge to hand over the information, according to WFSB.

Kimberly Sullivan arrested

Kimberly Sullivan is taken into custody by the Waterbury Police Department on March 12. (Waterbury Police Department)

“The state’s position, stripped of its appeal to ‘victim’ protection, amounts to this: the accuser may assume a new identity, relocate to an undisclosed address, and the defendant charged with serious felonies arising from their decades-long relationship must be kept in the dark,” Kaloidis reportedly argued in the court filing.

The move sent shockwaves throughout S’s family, with the victim’s biological mother blasting the request from Sullivan’s defense team.

A dirty bedroom is seen in Kimberly Sullivan's Connecticut house

This image provided by the Waterbury Police Department shows the home where a Connecticut man told authorities his stepmother held him captive for two decades since he was a boy. (Waterbury Police Department via AP)

“If you look at any domestic violence situation, you’re not going to let the person who is being the evil person around the one who needs to be protected,” Tracy Vallerand told the New York Post

“It’s appalling that they even had the audacity to request that.”

Vallerand reportedly gave up custody of S decades ago, leaving the child with her ex, who died in 2024, and Sullivan. 

Sullivan has pleaded not guilty to all charges and remains free on $300,000 as she awaits trial.

Sullivan’s attorney did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital’s request for comment. 

-->

You May Also Like
Barrington woman receiving thousands in property tax refunds sent out by Cook County Treasurer's Office after year-long delay

Cook County Finally Delivers: Barrington Resident Receives Long-Awaited Property Tax Refunds Worth Thousands

CHICAGO (WLS) — The ABC7 I-Team has revealed new developments in their…
NYC Schools Chancellor Kamar Samuels makes $363K -- more than Mayor Mamdani: source

NYC Schools Chancellor Kamar Samuels Tops Mayor Mamdani’s Salary with $363K Earnings: Source

New York City Schools Chancellor Kamar Samuels commands an impressive annual salary…
Texas giant troll burns down in Pease Park fire as heartbroken artist Thomas Dambo speaks out

Pease Park Fire Destroys Beloved Texas Troll Sculpture: Artist Thomas Dambo Shares His Heartfelt Response

A beloved giant troll sculpture in Texas met a tragic end last…
Capitol rioters clamor for payouts from Trump's new 'anti-weaponization' fund despite backlash

Capitol Rioters Seek Compensation from Trump’s ‘Anti-Weaponization’ Fund Amid Controversy

David Johnston, a former lawyer, took part in the Capitol riot with…
Manhunt underway for suspect after Virginia deputy killed, another injured in ambush; $10K reward offered

Virginia Manhunt: $10K Reward Offered as Suspect Sought in Deadly Deputy Ambush

A large-scale, coordinated manhunt is currently taking place in Virginia as authorities…
Mayhem breaks out between anti-ICE protesters, police at Newark's Delaney Hall

Clashes Erupt Between Anti-ICE Demonstrators and Police at Newark’s Delaney Hall

Chaos erupted Saturday night during ongoing protests against ICE at Newark’s Delaney…
Californians disapprove of Governor Gavin Newsom in latest poll

New Poll Reveals Growing Discontent with Governor Gavin Newsom Among Californians

Governor Gavin Newsom’s performance has sparked a division among primary voters, as…
Meteor fireball shakes homes spooks New England residents

Spectacular Meteor Fireball Rattles Homes and Stuns New England Residents

On Saturday afternoon, a meteor dramatically burst over New England, creating a…
Chicago teen takeover prevention: A Boy and His Dream hosts Mollison Elementary Restore the Youth Field Takeover in Bronzeville

Chicago Teens Reclaim Youth Spaces: Inspiring Event at Mollison Elementary in Bronzeville

CHICAGO (WLS) — Taking a stand against the disruptive teen gatherings that…
Rabid bat found in residential area triggers warning from police

Police Issue Alert After Rabid Bat Discovered in Local Neighborhood

A recent discovery of a rabid bat in a residential vicinity of…
Manhunt underway for suspect in Virginia accused of killing sheriff's deputy

Virginia Authorities Launch Manhunt for Suspect in Fatal Shooting of Sheriff’s Deputy

Authorities in Virginia have launched a manhunt for a suspect believed to…
Mackenzie Shirilla's texts surface as 'hell on wheels' driver's appeal collides with Netflix's 'The Crash'

New Texts Reveal Controversial Insights in Mackenzie Shirilla’s Case as Netflix Releases ‘The Crash

Newly unveiled jail calls and text messages are casting new perspectives on…