Democrats could have a slight shot at flipping a US House seat in Utah under a new congressional map
Share this @internewscast.com

The Republican-majority Legislature in Utah approved a new congressional map on Monday, which might give Democrats a better chance to gain a seat as they aim to overcome the narrow Republican majority in the U.S. House. However, given the Republican dominance in the state, it’s still unlikely that Democrats will secure a district in the upcoming election.

Republicans currently hold all four of Utah’s House seats.

Following a court mandate, the redrawn map makes two districts slightly more competitive for Democrats, although one is more promising than the other. Despite this, all four districts still have a Republican lean. The revised map now consolidates Salt Lake City into one district extending into rural regions rather than dividing the predominantly Democratic city across several districts.

Experts in redistricting describe this proposal as the least competitive one that lawmakers reviewed, likely providing Republicans their best assurance of retaining their seats. Nonetheless, Democratic National Committee Chair Ken Martin considers it a “prime pickup opportunity.”

The districts still must be reviewed by a judge, who is expected to approve a new map by November.

Earlier in August, Judge Dianna Gibson invalidated the congressional map put in place following the 2020 census since the Legislature bypassed voter-established standards to prevent districts from unfairly favoring a political party, an act known as gerrymandering.

This required map adjustment arrives as former President Donald Trump has encouraged other Republican-led states to engage in redistricting before the midterm elections to gain additional winnable seats for the party.

Utah’s new map introduces an element of uncertainty in a state previously viewed as securely Republican. On a national scale, Democrats need to gain three House seats next year to reclaim control of the chamber from Republicans, who are striving to avoid the historical trend of a president’s party losing seats in midterm elections.

Republican state Sen. Scott Sandall, a co-chair of the Legislature’s redistricting committee, said there are a lot of things they would have done differently if not for the time crunch. Still, he thinks the judge will have no reason to reject the map.

After taking public comment on several proposals, Republicans chose to move forward with the least competitive option. Commenters appeared to favor a proposal from Democrats until the Utah Republican Party sent out an email to rally support for the map now approved by lawmakers.

Democratic state Sen. Nate Blouin was scolded by Republican leaders on the Senate floor when he said he thinks it’s no coincidence that the map most favorable to Republicans was chosen. Sandall insisted the committee did not consider political data.

A handful of Republicans joined Democrats in opposing the map.

During Monday’s special session, Republicans also amended Proposition 4 — a voter-approved ballot initiative from 2018 that sparked the redistricting case — requiring each new district to have a partisan vote share similar to Utah’s recent statewide election results. Republican Gov. Spencer Cox signed it into law later Monday, and the voting rights groups involved in the legal challenge responded with a motion arguing lawmakers were trying “to change the rules of the game.”

Jonathan Cervas, a redistricting expert at Carnegie Mellon University, ran data from past elections in Utah against the redrawn map and found that Democrats would lose every time. That indicates that the map is uncompetitive, he said.

“Although it’s not as competitive as I think the plaintiffs would want, I think it’s far better than the map that currently exists — a stark improvement,” Cervas said.

The map thrown out by Gibson more significantly divided Salt Lake County — Utah’s population center and an island of Democratic support. Before the map was adopted in 2021, one district had traded hands between Democrats and Republicans. All have since elected Republicans by wide margins.

Gibson will now review the map approved by lawmakers and consider alternate proposals from the voting rights groups. If she shoots it down, Cervas anticipates a legal battle over whether the court has authority or an obligation to put in place a map of its own.

If the revised map stands, redistricting analyst Jason Fierman thinks “it’s not insurmountable” for Democrats.

“An extremely strong candidate in a blue wave year might be able to possibly break this cycle of Democrats not winning any of these seats,” said Fierman, who has consulted on maps in other states. Former U.S. Rep. Ben McAdams could be one such candidate, he said. “This could really be a ‘game on’ moment for Democrats, but it would be challenging.”

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Ruben Torres Maldonado, detained by federal immigration agents in Niles while daughter has cancer, released

Ruben Torres Maldonado, Father of Cancer-Stricken Daughter, Freed from Immigration Custody in Niles

A father, recently taken into custody by federal immigration agents while his…
Monday Morning Minute: Running on Empty

Gavin Newsom Subtly Shifts Stance on Charlie Kirk, Aiming for Minimal Public Attention

In February, a surprising announcement stirred the political landscape: Charlie Kirk, the…
New York Daily News Flashback: “Ford to City: Drop Dead”

Historic Moment: When Ford Told NYC ‘No Bailout’ in 1975

October 30, 1975: In what is arguably its most memorable cover story,…
Qatari Prime Minister Says Hamas Violated Ceasefire with Attack on Israeli Soldiers

Qatari PM Condemns Hamas Ceasefire Breach: Attack on Israeli Soldiers Sparks Tensions

Qatar’s Prime Minister, Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman al-Thani, expressed disappointment on Wednesday,…
JetBlue flight makes emergency landing at Tampa Airport after sudden 'drop in altitude' injures passengers

Terrifying JetBlue Incident: Sudden Altitude Drop Injures Passengers, Forces Emergency Landing at Tampa Airport

A JetBlue flight en route from Cancun to New Jersey was compelled…
More than 500 arrests made under Florida's 'Super Speeder' law

Florida’s ‘Super Speeder’ Crackdown: Over 500 Arrested in Major Traffic Enforcement Sweep

As of July 1, 2025, a stringent new law in Florida is…
Chase involving Border Patrol results in crashes, ends in arrests at Warren Township High School's O'Plaine Campus: Gurnee police

High-Speed Border Patrol Chase Culminates in Arrests at Warren Township High School: A Gurnee Police Report

In a dramatic turn of events in Gurnee, Illinois, a high-speed chase…
'Gen Z' Dem candidate charged with interfering with ICE posted video of herself in mob blocking unmarked SUV

Gen Z Democrat Faces Charges for ICE Interference: Viral Video Sparks Controversy

A Democratic candidate from Illinois, running for Congress, has shared a video…
Massive crowds line up in the rain at Ole Miss for Turning Point USA event with VP Vance, Erika Kirk

Huge Turnout Braves Rain for Turning Point USA Event at Ole Miss Featuring VP Vance and Erika Kirk

In a show of unwavering enthusiasm, hundreds of University of Mississippi students…
Evidence Contradicts Claims About Charlie Kirk’s Hospitalization

New Findings Challenge Reports on Charlie Kirk’s Hospital Stay

Fresh evidence obtained by Candace Owens is calling into question official accounts…
Chicago immigration operations: Appeals court blocks order requiring CBP Chief Greg Bovino to meet with judge every day on

Appeals Court Halts Daily Meetings Between CBP Chief and Judge in Chicago Immigration Case

The U.S. Department of Justice has lodged an appeal against a federal…
JD Vance calls for reduction in legal immigration at Turning Point event

JD Vance Advocates for Cutting Legal Immigration Numbers at Turning Point Gathering

Vice President JD Vance has called for a significant reduction in legal…