Historic NYC plaza left in abysmal disrepair with destroyed pavement, defective lights

New York's Iconic Plaza Crumbles: Damaged Pavement and Faulty Lighting Leave Historic Site in Disrepair

Foley Square, a historically significant area nestled among Manhattan’s iconic public institutions, is currently marred by neglect. The square, known for its public art, is suffering from damages, including broken street lamps and hazardous pavement conditions.

This city-managed green space, which has witnessed numerous high-profile protests such as Occupy Wall Street and anti-ICE rallies, received an “unacceptable” rating in last year’s city audit. This is a stark contrast to its previously favorable evaluations, and even officials from the Mamdani administration acknowledge the ongoing deterioration months later.

“We recognize the need for upgrades in this park and are actively seeking solutions for its restoration,” a representative from the city Parks Department recently informed The Post.

Local residents and visitors echo these concerns as they contend with the square’s dilapidated state, surrounded by municipal buildings and state and federal courthouses.

“It needs a lot of improvement,” remarked Alex, a 26-year-old dog walker from Manhattan, highlighting the litter, animal waste, and missing pavement chunks from the square’s sun-shaped mosaic walkway.

During a recent visit by The Post, an improvised trash can made from a steel oil drum was overflowing with garbage, while several NYPD barriers lay overturned, and street lamps remained non-functional at night.

The public site’s apparent neglect has led to several fellow dog-walkers tripping and “bust[ing] their face open” because of the uneven ground, Alex said.

“Kids can trip and fall, dogs can step on glass if the walkers aren’t paying attention,” she said.

“Things like that are very dangerous, especially since this is supposed to be clean [and] safe for the public.” 

The Parks representative said department employees work to regularly clean up Foley Square, including during scheduled trash removals twice a day.

The entire site was last renovated with an $18 million facelift in 2000, complete with upgraded pavements, new benches, improved fountain drainage, enhanced lighting and plantings, the agency said.

The square, named after Tammany Hall-era district leader Thomas Foley, also contains Thomas Paine Park, which has racked up a handful of similar litter, sidewalk and homeless assistance complaints in recent years, according to 311 complaint data.

The plaza has been the site of raucous Occupy Wall Street rallies as well as protests over the Dakota Access Pipeline and the police-involved death of Staten Island dad Eric Garner.

Last summer, the square played host to a massive anti-ICE protest that saw over 80 protesters arrested.

At least some New Yorkers say the increased attention to the area from the protests has only spotlighted the negligent conditions, not exacerbated it.

“[The protests] actually bring more recognition to the park because when people see it they’re like, ‘Hey what’s going on over there?’ ” Alex said.

Parks only started to dole out “unacceptable” ratings to Thomas Paine Park in June, when the site’s cleanliness and overall condition were described as “unacceptable” because of graffiti and weeds.

Some New Yorkers say the square has fallen into even worse disrepair since.

“A few months ago, it didn’t look like this,” said city resident Omahira Arce, who was visiting the Civic Center area with her daughter last week. “When I was a kid, this didn’t look like this.

“Somebody could trip and fall,” the 41-year-old said, pointing to the broken pavement under her feet. “That’s a lawsuit.”

Arce’s 23-year-old daughter Sanaya said, “There should be a lot more effort” to repair the plaza “or at least enthusiasm about getting it done.”

You May Also Like

Lindsay Clancy holdout juror asks for one thing in new video after mistrial drama

Lindsay Clancy Holdout Juror Makes Video Plea After Mistrial

PLYMOUTH, Mass. — Michael Desronvil, the only juror who continued to believe…
Celebrity publicist rescues unconscious LA surfer from rough surf

Celebrity publicist rescues unconscious surfer from rough Los Angeles surf

A California woman plunged into turbulent ocean water and kept an unconscious…
Lone woman death row inmate Christa Pike says she's 'at peace' ahead of execution — as Tennessee gov. denies last-ditch bid for clemency

Tennessee death row inmate Christa Pike at peace after clemency denial

Christa Pike, the first woman sentenced to death in Tennessee in 200…
Grandmother sues after alleged AI facial recognition error led to months in jail, experts sound alarm

Grandmother Sues Over Alleged AI Facial Recognition Error That Led to Months in Jail

A Tennessee grandmother is suing the city of Fargo, North Dakota, and…
Lindsay Clancy holdout juror asks for public's focus to be returned to '3 angels'

Lindsay Clancy Holdout Juror Urges Focus on Her Three Angels

The lone juror whose position led to a mistrial in Lindsay Clancy’s…
NASA plans unpiloted Starliner test flight after astronauts got stuck at space station in 2024

NASA Plans Uncrewed Starliner Test After 2024 ISS Stranding

NASA and Boeing are targeting December or January for the launch of…
Jack Smith accused of 'corrupt' probe of Trump, Republican lawmakers

Republicans Accuse Special Counsel Jack Smith of ‘Corrupt’ Trump Investigation

WASHINGTON — Former special counsel Jack Smith faced sharp questioning Tuesday from…
Creep allegedly kidnapped woman, held her captive while trafficking her

Man Allegedly Kidnapped Woman, Held Her Captive for Trafficking

A Massachusetts man who was out on bail allegedly kidnapped a woman…
Baby girl with six toes is found dead in dumpster outside California school – as cops probe chilling theory

Baby Girl With Six Toes Found Dead in Dumpster Outside California School as Police Investigate

A 19-year-old mother was arrested Tuesday after the body of her four-month-old…
LSU frat pledges allegedly waterboarded, forced to chug milk in hazing rituals: report

LSU Fraternity Pledges Allegedly Waterboarded, Forced to Chug Milk

Louisiana State University has placed two fraternities on interim suspension while officials…
Lindsay Clancy's push to probe holdout juror hits snag before pivotal retrial hearing

Lindsay Clancy Bid to Probe Holdout Juror Hits Snag Ahead of Retrial

PLYMOUTH, Mass. — A Massachusetts judge is expected to hear arguments Tuesday…
US visa clash exposes Sudan’s forgotten war as foreign powers compete for strategic foothold

US Visa Clash Puts Sudan’s Forgotten War, Foreign Rivalry in Focus

Sudan’s military leader is rejecting a U.S.-backed push for a ceasefire after…