Crook who stole $10K in trading cards from Tom Brady’s SoHo store is repeat scammer: NYPD
Share this @internewscast.com

A thief who managed to steal nearly $10,000 in goods from a SoHo trading card shop, owned by the renowned football star Tom Brady, reportedly visited the store three times on the day of the heist. Authorities also suspect he may have executed similar cons in Brooklyn and Tennessee, according to police statements on Thursday.

Tom Brady is seen at the opening of the CardVault by Tom Brady store in SoHo on October 07, 2025 in New York City. (Photo by Michael Simon/Getty Images for CardVault by Tom Brady)
Tom Brady is seen at the opening of the CardVault by Tom Brady store in SoHo on October 07, 2025 in New York City. (Photo by Michael Simon/Getty Images for CardVault by Tom Brady)

The initial visit to the shop on Lafayette Street occurred just before midday on October 20. The swindler deceived a cashier into believing a payment of $2,623 for Pokémon Evolution and Topps baseball cards was successful. He achieved this by tampering with the card reader to falsely indicate the transaction had gone through, even though it was actually declined, explained NYPD Chief of Detectives Joseph Kenny during a press briefing.

Later that day, the same individual returned to the store and “purchased” another $2,558 worth of cards using the same ruse on the same unsuspecting employee.

On his third and final visit, just before 6:30 p.m., he repeated the trick, leaving with an additional $4,528 in trading cards.

“For some reason, the employee hands him the credit card machine, and he manipulates it in some fashion so the sale is approved,” Kenny said. “And rinse, repeat, does the same thing. Tries the credit card, doesn’t work. ‘Here, you try it,’ and he manipulates the machine.”

NYPD released photos of a suspect who recently robbed CardVault by Tom Brady in SoHo. (NYPD)
NYPD released photos of a suspect who recently robbed CardVault by Tom Brady in SoHo. (NYPD)

Police do not suspect the store worker of being complicit in the scam, Kenny confirmed.

After police released images of the suspect, a worker at a card store in Brooklyn who called the Crime Stoppers tip line said the same man stole $500 worth of baseball cards on Oct. 1 by using a fake passport when asked for identification.

Police in Nashville called the NYPD on Nov. 14 and said they recognized the man as the suspect in a case where $3,000 worth of collector playing cards were stolen using the same trick, Kenny said. They told the NYPD they believed the suspect sold the cards on eBay and at baseball card shows in Alabama.

“So this guy, he’s all over the place,” Kenny said, adding that attempts to use facial recognition software to identify the man have failed.

The Manhattan card store employee described the suspect as “friendly” and “engaging,” and said he told the worker that he went to Pace University, but police believe that’s a lie, Kenny said.

The SoHo store, which is part of a new chain, CardVault by Tom Brady, specializes in trading cards and high-end sports memorabilia. Brady owns a 50 percent stake in the company

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Atlanta airport reports 5-hour TSA lines

Atlanta Airport’s TSA Woes: Navigating 5-Hour Security Delays

WASHINGTON — On Sunday, passengers at the globe’s busiest airport faced grueling…
Azerbaijan National Anar Rustamov scammed Medicare out of $90 Million, Feds

Unmasking the $90 Million Medicare Fraud: The Shocking Case of Azerbaijan’s Anar Rustamov

An individual from Azerbaijan, who unlawfully entered the United States, orchestrated an…
DeSantis doesn’t rule out a 2028 presidential run: ‘We’ll see’ 

DeSantis Hints at Potential 2028 Presidential Bid: “We’ll See

Florida Governor Ron DeSantis recently hinted at the possibility of another bid…
Trump's latest White House renovations include new path to West Wing

Trump Unveils New Pathway to West Wing in Latest White House Renovations

WASHINGTON — In a striking transformation, President Trump is revamping the West…
Muir Beach's 16th century England hideaway transports you to a whole new world

Step Back in Time: Discover Muir Beach’s Enchanting 16th Century English Hideaway

Located just a short 20-minute drive from San Francisco’s iconic Golden Gate…
Pima County sheriff warns in NBC interview DNA tech issues in Nancy Guthrie case may take ‘months’ to resolve

Sheriff Addresses Mistakes in Nancy Guthrie Investigation, Urges Captor to Release Her as Family Seeks Assistance

As the search for Nancy Guthrie approaches the two-month mark, the leading…
Colombian military plane crashes in Amazon rainforest, number of casualties unknown

Colombian Military Plane Crashes in Amazon Rainforest: Casualties Remain Uncertain

BOGOTA, Colombia — A military cargo aircraft met with disaster shortly after…
Stocks set to surge after Trump postpones ultimatum for Iran

Market Poised for Growth as Trump Delays Iran Decision

Stocks are poised for a significant upswing as the trading week begins,…
Helicopter crashes through roof of Florida warehouse, killing 2

Tragic Helicopter Accident Claims Two Lives After Crashing Into Florida Warehouse Roof

Heart-wrenching images emerged following the crash of a helicopter into a Florida…
Noem spent $20,000 on horses, $3,800 on hair and makeup for Mt. Rushmore ads, invoices show

Invoices Reveal Noem Allocated $20,000 on Equestrian Expenses and $3,800 on Hair and Makeup for Mt. Rushmore Campaign

Democratic lawmakers disclosed on Monday that taxpayers had footed a bill exceeding…
Sheriff Chris Nanos shrugs off missteps in Nancy Guthrie case, calls for captor to ‘let her go’ as family pleads for help

Unraveling the Nancy Guthrie Case: Sheriff Nanos Urges Captor’s Release Amidst Family’s Desperate Plea

As the search for Nancy Guthrie approaches the two-month mark, the lead…
Tonga earthquake: Preliminary magnitude 7.6 earthquake strikes near Tonga in the South Pacific Ocean, USGS says

Powerful 7.6 Magnitude Earthquake Rocks South Pacific Near Tonga, Reports USGS

A powerful earthquake with a preliminary magnitude of 7.6 rocked the waters…