Crook who stole $10K in trading cards from Tom Brady’s SoHo store is repeat scammer: NYPD
Share this @internewscast.com

A thief who managed to steal nearly $10,000 in goods from a SoHo trading card shop, owned by the renowned football star Tom Brady, reportedly visited the store three times on the day of the heist. Authorities also suspect he may have executed similar cons in Brooklyn and Tennessee, according to police statements on Thursday.

Tom Brady is seen at the opening of the CardVault by Tom Brady store in SoHo on October 07, 2025 in New York City. (Photo by Michael Simon/Getty Images for CardVault by Tom Brady)
Tom Brady is seen at the opening of the CardVault by Tom Brady store in SoHo on October 07, 2025 in New York City. (Photo by Michael Simon/Getty Images for CardVault by Tom Brady)

The initial visit to the shop on Lafayette Street occurred just before midday on October 20. The swindler deceived a cashier into believing a payment of $2,623 for Pokémon Evolution and Topps baseball cards was successful. He achieved this by tampering with the card reader to falsely indicate the transaction had gone through, even though it was actually declined, explained NYPD Chief of Detectives Joseph Kenny during a press briefing.

Later that day, the same individual returned to the store and “purchased” another $2,558 worth of cards using the same ruse on the same unsuspecting employee.

On his third and final visit, just before 6:30 p.m., he repeated the trick, leaving with an additional $4,528 in trading cards.

“For some reason, the employee hands him the credit card machine, and he manipulates it in some fashion so the sale is approved,” Kenny said. “And rinse, repeat, does the same thing. Tries the credit card, doesn’t work. ‘Here, you try it,’ and he manipulates the machine.”

NYPD released photos of a suspect who recently robbed CardVault by Tom Brady in SoHo. (NYPD)
NYPD released photos of a suspect who recently robbed CardVault by Tom Brady in SoHo. (NYPD)

Police do not suspect the store worker of being complicit in the scam, Kenny confirmed.

After police released images of the suspect, a worker at a card store in Brooklyn who called the Crime Stoppers tip line said the same man stole $500 worth of baseball cards on Oct. 1 by using a fake passport when asked for identification.

Police in Nashville called the NYPD on Nov. 14 and said they recognized the man as the suspect in a case where $3,000 worth of collector playing cards were stolen using the same trick, Kenny said. They told the NYPD they believed the suspect sold the cards on eBay and at baseball card shows in Alabama.

“So this guy, he’s all over the place,” Kenny said, adding that attempts to use facial recognition software to identify the man have failed.

The Manhattan card store employee described the suspect as “friendly” and “engaging,” and said he told the worker that he went to Pace University, but police believe that’s a lie, Kenny said.

The SoHo store, which is part of a new chain, CardVault by Tom Brady, specializes in trading cards and high-end sports memorabilia. Brady owns a 50 percent stake in the company

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
AT&T Turned Kevin McCarthy's Cellphone Records over to Jack Smith

AT&T Hands Over Kevin McCarthy’s Phone Records to Special Counsel: What This Means for the Investigation

In a significant development, special counsel Jack Smith has acquired cellphone records…
Members of international organized residential burglary ring arrested after posing as Amazon drivers, Irvine, CA break-in | Video

Crystal Lake City Clerk Nicholas Kachiroubas Receives 5-Year Sentence for Child Pornography and Grooming Offenses

A Crystal Lake resident and city clerk has received a prison sentence…
China formally arrests 18 leaders of underground Zion Church amid religious crackdown

China Officially Arrests 18 Leaders of Undergound Zion Church in Ongoing Religious Crackdown

In a significant legal move, Chinese officials have officially charged 18 leaders…
Chicago-area native Bobbi Brown talks growing up in Wilmette, finding way to makeup

Wilmette Roots to Makeup Mogul: Bobbi Brown Shares Her Inspiring Journey from Chicago Suburbs to Beauty Icon

CHICAGO (WLS) — A visionary in the beauty industry, she crafted a…
Boyfriend of woman who vanished at California beach bonfire speaks out, makes plea for public's help

Partner of Missing California Beach Bonfire Attendee Urges Public Assistance

The boyfriend of a missing Utah woman, who disappeared earlier this month…
Alabama Teacher of the Year arrested after video shows her beating son with belt

Alabama Teacher of the Year Detained Following Video Alleging Child Discipline with Belt

A teacher previously honored as “Teacher of the Year” at an Alabama…
NFL Week 12 Thursday Night Bettors Guide: Bills at Texans

Comprehensive Betting Insights for NFL Week 12: Bills Face Off Against Texans on Thursday Night

BILLS at TEXANS 8:15 p.m., Bills favored by 5½, Over/Under 43½ HANK’S…
7th Crash in 2 Years: Jacksonville business begs for guardrail on property after latest car crash

Jacksonville Business Demands Urgent Safety Measures After 7th Car Crash in Two Years

Repeated collisions by speeding vehicles have plagued a Jacksonville business, igniting a…
Holiday crime fears grow as ‘jugging’ thieves target shoppers carrying cash and gifts: ‘Only a matter of time’

Rising Concern Over ‘Jugging’ Thieves Targeting Shoppers with Cash and Gifts This Holiday Season

Across the nation, authorities are urging shoppers to stay alert as they…
Tisch stays on watch: Zohran Mamdani must let NYPD commissioner run the department

Tisch Continues Oversight: Zohran Mamdani Urged to Allow NYPD Commissioner Full Control

Zohran Mamdani should refrain from interfering with Jessie Tisch’s role as police…
Fox News ‘Antisemitism Exposed’ Newsletter: Hating on Miss Israel

Unmasking Prejudice: Fox News’ Controversial Take on Miss Israel Sparks Outrage

Fox News’ “Antisemitism Exposed” newsletter offers insights into the escalating incidents of…
Alaska school district admits 'mistake' after adding 'does not endorse' disclaimer to Constitution pamphlet

Alaska School District Acknowledges Error in Adding Disclaimer to U.S. Constitution Pamphlet

In a surprising turn of events, the Anchorage School District in Alaska…