President Donald Trump's threat to send National Guard to Chicago raises legal questions

CHICAGO (WLS) — As Chicago anticipates a possible National Guard deployment initiated by President Donald Trump, Democratic leaders are denouncing the plan and raising questions about its legality.

In a united front, local leaders said National Guard troops are not needed in Chicago.

ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch

Mayor Brandon Johnson and Governor Pritzker said there has been no communication from the White House.

President Trump has issued an executive order designed to form specialized National Guard units focused on managing civil disturbances and ensuring public safety, ready for swift nationwide deployment.

ABC7 data team analysis of Chicago police crime numbers shows overall violent crime and homicides at their lowest level since 2014.

SEE ALSO: Illinois politicians condemn Trump’s threat to deploy National Guard to Chicago

Governor Pritzker said National Guard deployment is unwarranted, while some Republicans believe it could make a difference.

“The president of the United States is doing this for theatrics,” stated the Democratic governor. “This is not because we’ve requested it. It is not because there is some justice that he is going to seek. It is because he wants to create chaos.”

“We should have done this a long time ago so that every neighborhood in Chicago enjoys the same safety and security that we have in the suburbs,” commented Republican state Rep. Martin McLaughlin.

According to constitutional experts, the president can only nationalize the guard in cases of rebellion, foreign invasion, or when it is impossible to enforce federal laws.

“So we’ve had guardsmen in the street before, but they were ordered in by the governor… and traditionally and the statute says the governor has to give the order, which makes sense because guardsmen usually respond to natural disasters like floods, hurricanes, tornadoes, and fires,” explained Chicago Kent College of Law professor Douglas William Godfrey.

Local officials have threatened to take legal action, but that like would come after deployment.

Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul said there challenges with filing a preemptive lawsuit

Copyright © 2025 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

You May Also Like
Platner backer shrugs off his old Nazi-tied tattoo -- but says Israeli one would be red line: 'I don’t support genocide'

Controversy Surrounds Platner Backer: Dismisses Nazi-Linked Tattoo, Draws Line at Israeli Symbol

PORTLAND, Maine — At a rally for Senate candidate Graham Platner on…
'Danish capital of America' Solvang plotting against its own cops

Solvang: The Danish Capital of America Faces Internal Conflict Over Police Policies

A charming California town, often referred to as the “Danish capital of…
Judge voids Trump's $100,000 fee for new H-1B visas

Judge Overturns $100,000 Fee for New H-1B Visas Imposed by Trump Administration

Washington — On Monday, a federal judge struck down a policy introduced…
Members of international organized residential burglary ring arrested after posing as Amazon drivers, Irvine, CA break-in | Video

Tragic Discovery: Police Uncover Self-Inflicted Gunshot Death on Dixie Highway Amid Homewood Murder Probe

In a somber development in Homewood, Illinois, local authorities discovered an individual…
Pima County Sheriff issues alert for kidnapping suspect 7 miles from  Nancy Guthrie's home

Urgent Alert: Kidnapping Suspect Sought Near Nancy Guthrie’s Residence in Pima County

In a new twist to the investigation surrounding the disappearance of 84-year-old…
NYPD cop appears to slam Knicks fan head into pole during arrest at Madison Square Garden celebration: video

NYPD Officer Allegedly Seen Forcibly Restraining Knicks Fan Against Pole Amidst Madison Square Garden Celebrations: Video Emerges

A shocking video has surfaced showing an NYPD officer forcefully pushing a…
A 7.8 magnitude quake in the Philippines kills at least 32, collapses buildings and sparks tsunami

Massive 7.8 Magnitude Earthquake Strikes the Philippines: At Least 32 Dead, Buildings Toppled, and Tsunami Triggered

An offshore earthquake with a magnitude of 7.8 rocked the southern Philippines…
Trump blasts 'crooked' California elections as Spencer Pratt falls into 3rd place in LA primary

Trump Criticizes California Elections as Spencer Pratt Drops to Third in Los Angeles Primary

In a heated outburst, President Trump branded the California primaries as “crooked,”…
Florida deputy drags 'unresponsive' beachgoer from ocean in dramatic rescue

Heroic Rescue: Florida Deputy Saves Unconscious Swimmer from Ocean’s Grip

The Volusia Sheriff’s Office in Florida has released dramatic footage capturing the…
Spencer Pratt loses LA mayor's race as Nithya Raman surges through to runoff after massive dump of ballots

Spencer Pratt Falls Short in LA Mayor Bid as Nithya Raman Advances to Runoff

Spencer Pratt’s journey in the Los Angeles mayoral race has come to…
Karmelo Anthony appeared 'distraught' moments after killing Austin Metcalf, teammate says

Teammate Reveals Karmelo Anthony’s Distress Following Austin Metcalf’s Tragic Incident

A Texas teenager, Karmelo Anthony, reportedly appeared “distressed” shortly after allegedly stabbing…
Family of rape victim at America's top party college issues chilling update

Family Shares Heartfelt Update on Tragic Case at Renowned Party School

The family of a UC Santa Barbara student, reportedly subjected to assault…