President Donald Trump's threat to send National Guard to Chicago raises legal questions

CHICAGO (WLS) — As Chicago anticipates a possible National Guard deployment initiated by President Donald Trump, Democratic leaders are denouncing the plan and raising questions about its legality.

In a united front, local leaders said National Guard troops are not needed in Chicago.

ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch

Mayor Brandon Johnson and Governor Pritzker said there has been no communication from the White House.

President Trump has issued an executive order designed to form specialized National Guard units focused on managing civil disturbances and ensuring public safety, ready for swift nationwide deployment.

ABC7 data team analysis of Chicago police crime numbers shows overall violent crime and homicides at their lowest level since 2014.

SEE ALSO: Illinois politicians condemn Trump’s threat to deploy National Guard to Chicago

Governor Pritzker said National Guard deployment is unwarranted, while some Republicans believe it could make a difference.

“The president of the United States is doing this for theatrics,” stated the Democratic governor. “This is not because we’ve requested it. It is not because there is some justice that he is going to seek. It is because he wants to create chaos.”

“We should have done this a long time ago so that every neighborhood in Chicago enjoys the same safety and security that we have in the suburbs,” commented Republican state Rep. Martin McLaughlin.

According to constitutional experts, the president can only nationalize the guard in cases of rebellion, foreign invasion, or when it is impossible to enforce federal laws.

“So we’ve had guardsmen in the street before, but they were ordered in by the governor… and traditionally and the statute says the governor has to give the order, which makes sense because guardsmen usually respond to natural disasters like floods, hurricanes, tornadoes, and fires,” explained Chicago Kent College of Law professor Douglas William Godfrey.

Local officials have threatened to take legal action, but that like would come after deployment.

Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul said there challenges with filing a preemptive lawsuit

Copyright © 2025 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

You May Also Like

Douglas Herlihy case: How investigators cracked cold case of father Paul Herlihy's beating death in New Hampshire

Douglas Herlihy Case: How Police Solved Father Paul’s Beating Death

More than 20 years after Paul Herlihy was beaten to death, court…
Robbery suspect hunted after teen killed in South LA hit-and-run

Teen Killed in South Los Angeles Hit-and-Run; Robbery Suspect Sought

Police are searching for a reckless driver allegedly tied to a string…
Alabama man allegedly decapitates family members with chainsaw hours after 911 warning

Alabama Man Accused of Chainsaw Beheading Relatives After 911 Call

An Alabama man is accused of using a chainsaw to decapitate two…
France on edge with 70,000 police deployed for unrest as authorities probe suspected terror attack near Paris

France Deploys 70,000 Police After Suspected Terror Attack Near Paris

A suspected terrorist attack near Paris on Friday has heightened tensions across…
State Department says Trump is 'spot on' with France protests after Macron decries 'stupid' comments

State Department Backs Trump on France Protests as Macron Responds

The State Department backed President Donald Trump’s assessment of France, telling News…
43 years after Beirut terror attack killed 241 Americans, rabbi recalls chaplains’ extraordinary response

43 Years After Beirut Bombing Killed 241 Americans, Rabbi Recalls Chaplains’ Heroism

Rabbi Arnold Resnicoff never planned to be in Beirut, Lebanon, on Oct.…
Notorious 'Tan Mom' claims ICE agents mistook her for illegal immigrant because of extreme tan

Tan Mom Patricia Krentcil Says ICE Mistook Her for an Immigrant

Talk about taking things beyond the pale. New Jersey’s infamous “Tan Mom”…
DOJ demands that some California counties set aside and verify alleged noncitizen ballots within 48 hours

DOJ Orders California Counties to Preserve and Verify Alleged Noncitizen Ballots Within 48 Hours

The letters mark a new escalation in the legal dispute between California…
Amish woman uses weed whacker to scare off illegal migrant allegedly threatening to kidnap her at knifepoint

Amish Woman Fends Off Alleged Knife-Wielding Kidnap Threat With Weed Whacker

An Amish woman in Pennsylvania reportedly used a weed whacker to frighten…
NY teen genius Michael Sweeney denied early high school graduation due to his age

NY Teen Michael Sweeney Denied Early Graduation Over Age

A 14-year-old New York homeschool student who is already attending community college…
DOJ preemptively sues to block Alaska Senate results if Republican narrowly loses

DOJ Seeks to Block Alaska Senate Result if GOP Loses Narrowly

The Trump administration has filed a preemptive lawsuit seeking to block certification…
DOJ probes Corey Lewandowski over improper awarding of DHS contracts under Kristi Noem

DOJ Probes Ex-Trump Aide Corey Lewandowski Over DHS Contract Awards

WASHINGTON — The Justice Department is investigating former Trump aide Corey Lewandowski…