Ex-FBI official flags possible scam as third alleged Nancy Guthrie letter emerges

A retired police K-9 handler is voicing concerns over the public management of the Nancy Guthrie investigation, questioning the rationale behind the choice not to use cadaver dogs. As the inquiry enters its seventh week with scant developments, he describes this decision as “illogical.”

“It feels like we’re just chasing illusions,” remarked Michael Gould, a former K-9 investigator with both the NYPD and Nassau County Police Department.

Despite his concerns, Gould mentioned to Fox News Digital that it is highly plausible that investigators are pursuing leads discreetly and may be more advanced in their efforts than it appears to the public.

“Cadaver dogs, or human remains detection dogs, stand as the foremost technology humans have for detecting the scent of missing individuals,” he stated on Tuesday. “These dogs are recognized in court as a scientific tool. Therefore, the sheriff’s decision to forgo their use baffles me.”

Three Pima Deputies examine a flyer taped to the mailbox outside Nancy Guthrie's home in Tucson

On February 23, 2026, Pima County deputies were seen examining a flyer taped to the mailbox at Nancy Guthrie’s residence in Tucson, Arizona. (Michael Ruiz/Fox News Digital)

According to Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos, Nancy Guthrie, the 84-year-old mother of “Today” host Savannah Guthrie, is suspected to have been forcibly taken from her Tucson home in the Catalina Foothills neighborhood during the early hours of February 1.

The Pima County Sheriff’s Department, like many local law enforcement agencies around the country, does not have its own cadaver dogs. They borrowed K-9s from the local Border Patrol office earlier in the case but are no longer deploying them as part of the investigation.

“There’s only two assumptions, two implications there, that A, she’s still alive, that’s one implication, or B, they’ve given up searching for her,” Gould said.

Nancy Guthrie and Savannah Guthrie posing together for a photo.

An undated photo of Nancy Guthrie and Savannah Guthrie provided by NBC in response to the disappearance of the 84-year-old mother of the “Today” show host. (Courtesy of NBC)

He called on the sheriff to either deploy them in a pattern search or explain why that’s not happening.

“I stretch my head to think, without him guiding us, giving us answers to this, I can’t think of any other rationale why you would say we’re putting cadaver dogs on hold,” Gould said. “It defies logic.”

Nanos, for his part, told Fox News Digital earlier that if he deemed they were needed, he’d send them back out. He declined to discuss specific leads or evidence.

An investigator searching the grounds near Nancy Guthrie's property in the Catalina Foothills.

Law enforcement agents check vegetation areas around Nancy Guthrie’s home in Tucson, Feb. 11, 2026. (Ty ONeil/AP Photo)

“Anything is possible,” he said when asked if he believed Guthrie is still alive.

However, with the investigation dragging on for more than 40 days, Gould said the case does not fit the profile of an abduction.

“After six weeks, without proof of life, without anything else, the family has come to terms with the fact, I think, that this is a homicide investigation, and it’s got to be treated like that,” he said.

Investigators walking past houses and through a neighborhood in search of Nancy Guthrie

An investigator looks inside a culvert in the neighborhood where Annie Guthrie, daughter of missing Nancy Guthrie, lives just outside Tucson, on Feb. 10, 2026. (Ty ONeil/AP Photo)

In a heartbreaking Instagram video posted last month, Savannah Guthrie thanked millions of supporters for their prayers and acknowledged that her mother may no longer be alive.

The elder Guthrie’s pacemaker last synced with her Apple devices around 2:30 a.m. on Feb. 1. There was a light trail of blood outside of her front door, which authorities later said belonged to her. And nothing significant had been stolen.

Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos speaks to reporters in Arizona.

Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos speaks to the media in Catalina, Arizona, on Feb. 3, while answering questions about the search for Nancy Guthrie. (Jan Sonnenmair/Getty Images)

Authorities issued a silver alert, describing Guthrie as a vulnerable adult whose life depends on prescription medication and who has mobility issues that could have prevented her from traveling far on foot.

WATCH: Nancy Guthrie’s Nest doorbell cam records masked suspect

Her Nest doorbell camera was missing, but the FBI and Google were able to recover video of a masked suspect at her doorstep. He visited her home at least once prior, according to federal law enforcement sources — on Jan. 11.

He is described as standing around 5 feet, 9 inches to 5 feet, 10 inches tall with a medium build. He remained unidentified as of Tuesday morning.

Two men were briefly detained as separate warrants were being served in connection with the case. Both were released without charges. The most recent was on Feb. 13 after the FBI towed his Range Rover from a Culver’s parking lot and raided his mother’s home, which is about 2 miles from Guthrie’s.

A Pima County Sheriff's deputy standing during a law enforcement operation at an intersection in Tucson, Arizon

Pima County officers at the intersection of Camino de Michael and East Orange Grove Road in Tucson on Feb. 13, 2026. The location is approximately two miles from Nancy Guthrie’s home. (DWS for Fox News Digital)

“It was considered a kidnapping so they were investigating as a life and death situation — that’s why they executed a lot of search warrants that people questioned the legitimacy of the search warrant,” Gould said. “But if you’re thinking of the fact that somebody might still be alive and being held hostage, it’s different than a homicide investigation.”

Since then, updates have slowed to a trickle. But a task force of Pima County homicide detectives and FBI agents remains on the investigation.

“If there’s tips coming in, it’s not a cold case,” Gould said. “I feel confident that this is gonna be a solve, but not on our timeline.”

FBI agents inspect a Range Rover following a traffic stop related to Nancy Guthrie's disappearance

A Pima County sheriff’s deputy inspects a Range Rover following a traffic stop in Tucson, Feb. 13, 2026. Sources tell Fox News Digital that the stop is connected to a search warrant served at a home near Nancy Guthrie’s house. (Kat Ramirez for Fox News Digital)

Tips could come in from someone in jail, from a relative of the suspect, a romantic partner or even an accomplice, he said.

“Very rarely is there only one person that knows what happened,” he told Fox News Digital.

Savannah Guthrie standing on the Today show set at Rockefeller Plaza.

Savannah Guthrie visits the “Today” show at Rockefeller Plaza in New York on March 5, 2026. (Charles Sykes/Invision/AP)

And although a mixed DNA sample is still undergoing analysis in a private lab in Florida, he predicts that genetics will play a key role in cracking the case.

“It’s gonna be resolved,” he said. “And people are going to be surprised by the outcome of it.”

There is a combined reward of more than $1.2 million for information that leads to Guthrie’s recovery.

The family is asking anyone with information to dial 1-800-CALL-FBI.

<!–>

–>

You May Also Like

Vile dad killed baby son who wouldn't stop him crying while he played video games

Father killed baby son for crying while playing video games

A Hawaii father is accused of fatally injuring his 3-month-old son after…
Two public safety officers shot at NYC housing complex; suspect dead

2 Public Safety Officers Shot at NYC Housing Complex; Suspect Dead

Two public safety officers were shot Monday at a New York City…
Pentagon ignored warnings before Iran drone killed 6 US service members in Kuwait, whistleblower claims

Pentagon Ignored Iran Drone Warnings Before 6 US Troops Died

US military officials dismissed warnings that a command post in Kuwait lacked…
Massachusetts bank vice president dies after being struck by bullet amid argument between two other relatives

Massachusetts Bank VP Killed by Stray Bullet in Relatives’ Dispute

A Massachusetts bank vice president died after being struck by a bullet…
Pope Leo XIV hit in the face by flying rosary during farewell Mass in Peru, video shows

Video Shows Pope Leo XIV Hit by Flying Rosary at Peru Farewell Mass

Pope Leo XIV appeared to be hit near the eye by a…
Elderly homeowner’s hired help turns into squatter nightmare made worse by blue state laws: report

Elderly Homeowner Says Hired Helper Became Squatter as Blue State Laws Complicate Eviction: Report

A 76-year-old California homeowner says a man she hired to repair plumbing…
Trump border crackdown drives encounters to record October low as zero-release streak hits 18 months, DHS says

Trump Border Crackdown Drives Record-Low October Encounters, DHS Says

Rep. Pat Fallon urges Republicans to stay firm on border security Rep.…
California sues OpenAI after Hugging Face hack, other incidents

California Sues OpenAI Over Hugging Face Hack and Other Incidents

California Attorney General Rob Bonta filed a lawsuit against OpenAI on Monday,…
Dem Congressman's Claim About Elon Musk, DOGE, and the FAA Stoppage Needed a Serious Fact Check

Fact-Checking a Democratic Congressman’s Elon Musk, DOGE FAA Claim

The FAA imposed a nationwide ground stop on flights Friday. Yet during…
Nvidia short-seller warned in May of CEO Jensen Huang's ties to suspected Chinese spy

Elon Musk Among Thousands Backing Jensen Huang Nvidia CEO Petition

Thousands of Nvidia employees and technology leaders, including Elon Musk, have signed…
TikToker arrested after big cat mauls teen to death during video shoot at private farm

TikToker Arrested as Big Cat Kills Teen in Private Farm Video Shoot

A TikToker and a private farm owner have been arrested after a…
California loses top spot for international students to New York

New York Overtakes California as Top US Destination for International Students

California has lost its crown as America’s top destination for international students,…