Ashlee Buzzard denies murdering daughter Melodee, won’t face death penalty

In a recent court appearance, California mother Ashlee Buzzard entered a plea of not guilty to charges of murdering her daughter, Melodee. Santa Barbara prosecutors announced they would not pursue the death penalty in this case.

The 40-year-old is accused of ending the life of her 9-year-old daughter, whose body was discovered in a secluded region of southern Utah on December 6, following a nearly two-month search effort.

Authorities revealed that Buzzard embarked on a road trip across several states with her daughter. The journey tragically concluded with the girl being shot multiple times in the head. School officials reported Melodee missing in mid-October when Buzzard failed to clarify her daughter’s prolonged absence.

Melodee’s identity was confirmed through familial DNA matching her mother’s, as announced on Monday. Earlier, investigators found cartridge cases at the Utah scene that matched those found in Buzzard’s Lompoc, California home.

Buzzard was apprehended on Tuesday and formally charged with first-degree murder the following day, tied to her daughter’s tragic shooting.

In Friday’s arraignment, Buzzard’s attorneys refuted special allegations, including claims that she fired a weapon resulting in death and committed the murder by lying in wait, as reported by local NBC station KSBY.

Prosecutors said they’ll be seeking a life sentence without parole, but not the death penalty, when they head to trial. A pre-preliminary hearing was scheduled for Jan. 7.

Santa Barbara County Sheriff Bill Brown told reporters during a press conference on Tuesday that he believes Melodee was killed in a premediated fashion on Oct. 9, shortly after she and her mom crossed the border into Utah. Buzzard is believed to have returned to California alone the following day.

Investigators believe the pair wore wigs when they traveled, as seen in surveillance footage from a rental car location in Lompoc on Oct. 7. Police also said Buzzard went so far as to swap the license plate of the vehicle she rented to avoid detection. The Chevy Malibu was seen on video driving with New York plates, but returned with its original plates on Oct. 10.

This image made from surveillance footage captured at a rental car company on Oct. 7, 2025, and released by the Santa Barbara County Sheriff's Office, shows Melodee Buzzard, left, and Ashlee Buzzard, right, in Lompoc, Calif.
This image made from surveillance footage captured at a rental car company on Oct. 7, 2025, and released by the Santa Barbara County Sheriff’s Office, shows Melodee Buzzard, left, and Ashlee Buzzard, right, in Lompoc, Calif. (Santa Barbara County Sheriff’s Office via AP)

The criminal complaint against Buzzard contends that her alleged crime involved “great violence, great bodily harm, threat of great bodily harm or other acts disclosing a high degree of cruelty, viciousness or callousness.” Investigators have not yet offered any insight into a motive for the killing.

Buzzard, whose has been described by family members as bipolar and mentally unstable, will remain behind bars ahead of trial.

You May Also Like

MICHAEL RUIZ: DA identifies 49 local killers slated for Newsom's death row clemency — and their crimes

DA Identifies 49 Killers Slated for Newsom Death Row Clemency

A California district attorney is drawing attention to the devastating crimes tied…
At least 5 confirmed dead in collapsed NYC building as massive rescue operation continues

NYC Building Collapse Kills at Least 5 as Major Rescue Continues

Rescuers recovered a fifth body from the rubble of a collapsed Brooklyn…
Oklahoma man, 73, executed for plotting murder of lover's husband, offers no last words

Oklahoma Man, 73, Executed Over Plot to Kill Lover’s Husband

This photo provided by the Oklahoma Department of Corrections shows James Pavatt…
Report: Alice Huang Is in China, Jensen Huang Is in Hot Water, and Nvidia Has Some Explaining to Do

Report: Alice Huang in China as Jensen Huang Faces Nvidia Scrutiny

Alice Huang, the businesswoman U.S. officials suspect of spying for China, is…
Israel's political shake-up enters new phase as former PM plays kingmaker — and deadline looms

Israel’s Former PM Emerges as Kingmaker as Coalition Deadline Nears

Israel’s newly elected parliament was sworn in Tuesday, opening a political transition…
Texas man Ciro Tomlian identified as suspect in TPUSA UT attack

Texas Man Ciro Tomlian Identified as Suspect in Turning Point USA Utah Attack

Texas authorities have identified the man accused of assaulting students at a…
Suspected DUI driver arrested on 3 murder counts after deadly North Hollywood crash, police say

Suspected DUI Driver Arrested on 3 Murder Counts After Deadly North Hollywood Crash

A 61-year-old man suspected of driving under the influence was arrested on…
NYC building collapse: Fifth body recovered as first responders search for survivors

NYC Building Collapse: Fifth Body Recovered as Rescuers Continue Search for Survivors

First responders work at the scene of a collapsed building in Brooklyn,…
Arizona State University triathlete Hannah Henry's killer Eric Hodge sentenced for fatal hit-and-run

Eric Hodge Sentenced in Fatal Hit-and-Run That Killed Arizona State Triathlete Hannah Henry

The family of Hannah Henry, an Arizona State University triathlon champion killed…
Democrat Colom will be Mississippi's first Black senator in more than 100 years, AP projects

AP projects Democrat Colom will become Mississippi’s first Black US senator in over 100 years

Democrat Scott
Executions set for Oklahoma murderer James Pavatt and Texas killer Josh Rubio

Oklahoma Murderer James Pavatt, Texas Killer Josh Rubio Face Execution

Two men were scheduled to be executed in the United States on…
Illegal immigrant arrested after dragging, striking ICE officer in Chicago suburb: DHS

DHS: Migrant Arrested for Dragging, Striking ICE Officer Near Chicago

Authorities probe ICE vehicle-ramming incident in New Jersey Criminal defense attorney Josh…