Share this @internewscast.com

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Tuesday weighs a tax case that attracted scrutiny after Justice Samuel Alito rejected claims that he should not participate in it because of his ties with one of the lawyers involved.

The case, Moore v. U.S., concerns a novel constitutional question about whether people can be forced to pay taxes on stakes in foreign-owned companies even if they have not derived any income from them.

David Rivkin, one of the lawyers involved in the case against the federal government, interviewed Alito in two articles published in The Wall Street Journal that addressed recent claims of ethics violations on the court and the power of Congress to legislate on the issue.

After it faced pressure for months over alleged ethics lapses, the court last month announced a new code of conduct that immediately attracted criticism because the justices are left to enforce it themselves.

In September, Alito issued a statement saying there was “no valid reason” for him to step aside in the tax case.

Rivkin represents Washington state-based Charles and Kathleen Moore, who invested in an India-based company. He is not arguing the case Tuesday.

It is a rare occasion for the Supreme Court to delve into the meaning of the Constitution’s 16th Amendment, which outlines Congress’ power to order the collection of income taxes.

Some tax experts say the case could have broad ramifications, leading to more challenges to other tax provisions and potentially threatening any future effort to enact a “wealth tax.”

The case focuses on a provision of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act that imposed a one-off tax on shares held in foreign companies. It stated that people could not defer paying taxes on ownership stakes in such companies.

The Moores say that in 2005, they invested $40,000 in a company called KisanKraft Machine Tools. Although the company was profitable, they say they did not receive dividends, with the money instead being reinvested in the business. Because of that, the Moores did not pay taxes on what the U.S. government defined as income from the company from 2006 to 2017.

After the new law was enacted, the Moores ended up paying almost $15,000 in additional taxes, which they then sought a refund for. They argue that the tax was unlawful on the grounds that an increase in the value of a capital investment does not constitute income.

A federal judge and the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals both ruled in favor of the government, prompting the Moores to seek Supreme Court review.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Iran strikes Kuwaiti oil tanker in drone attack off Dubai coast: report

Iranian Drone Allegedly Targets Kuwaiti Oil Tanker Near Dubai, Report Claims

A Kuwaiti oil tanker situated off the coast of Dubai was engulfed…
ABC7 Chicago Job: Desk Assistant

Join ABC7 Chicago: Exciting Career Opportunity as a Programming Producer

ABC 7 Chicago, the leading news outlet in the area, is on…
Disgraced human rights boss shares cryptic post after arrest

Former Human Rights Leader Posts Enigmatic Message Following Recent Arrest

Sheryl Davis, the former head of San Francisco’s Human Rights Commission, has…
Teens face potential life-long consequences after Jacksonville Beach 'Senior Skip Day' arrests

Jacksonville Beach ‘Senior Skip Day’ Arrests Could Impact Teens’ Futures Permanently

According to Ken Jefferson, First Coast News’ crime and safety expert, the…
All the details: Anne Hathaway and Meryl Streep kick off 'The Devil Wears Prada 2' global tour in fashion-forward looks

Anne Hathaway and Meryl Streep Stun in Stylish Outfits at Start of ‘The Devil Wears Prada 2’ World Tour

Two decades after “The Devil Wears Prada” captivated cinema-goers, Meryl Streep, Anne…
Windsurfer collides with whale in unbelievable video

Windsurfer Encounters Whale in Astonishing Video Footage

In an astonishing stroke of luck, a windsurfer narrowly escaped serious harm…
Gavin Newsom's emo 'belonging campaign' harshly rejected by California auditors

California Auditors Criticize Gavin Newsom’s ‘Belonging Campaign’: A Closer Look at the Controversy

California auditors have criticized a segment of Governor Gavin Newsom’s initiative to…
Video shows latest Los Angeles street takeover as mob wreaks havoc, vandalizes occupied city bus

Chaotic Los Angeles Street Takeover: Crowd Causes Destruction and Targets City Bus

A startling video has captured a scene of anarchy in the streets…
Canadian murder suspect on most-wanted list arrested in Mississippi, was in US illegally, DHS says

Canadian Murder Suspect on Most-Wanted List Apprehended in Mississippi, Found to be in U.S. Illegally, According to DHS

Last week, one of Canada’s most sought-after fugitives was apprehended in Mississippi,…
Pilots shot down by friendly fire during Iran missions already back to dropping bombs

Resilient Pilots: Overcoming Friendly Fire and Returning to Iran Missions

In a remarkable turn of events, pilots who were downed by friendly…
Palmdale Street shooting on Jacksonville's Northwest side leaves man dead

Two Sustain Serious Injuries in Separate Overnight Shootings Across Jacksonville on Monday

Jacksonville, Fla. — In a series of unrelated events, two individuals have…
Explosive device discovered near suburban New York apartment building

Suspicious Device Found Near New York Suburb Apartment Complex

An unexplained explosive device was found just outside the entrance of a…