Share this @internewscast.com

WASHINGTON — After supporters of then-President Donald Trump stormed the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, ominous fencing was erected to protect surrounding buildings.

One of the buildings that needed protecting was the grand marble structure across the street from the Capitol: the Supreme Court.

But during oral arguments on Thursday over Colorado’s effort to kick Trump off the Republican primary ballot, the justices asked little about a key question in the case: Was Jan. 6 an insurrection?

Instead, the court looks likely to rule in favor of Trump on other grounds, allowing the justices to avoid taking sides on such a contentious issue.

Based on the two-hour oral argument, it appeared there was a majority that would find that states do not have the authority to enforce Section 3 of the 14th Amendment, which bars people who previously held government positions and “engaged in insurrection” from holding federal office.

Justices asked questions on all manner of legal technicalities, including whether the president is covered by Section 3 and whether Congress needs to pass legislation to enforce it. In skirting the insurrection question, they also probed who gets to decide whether an insurrection took place, with several suggesting states should not have that power.

The only justice to directly press the insurrection question was Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, a liberal appointed by President Joe Biden.

Jackson asked Trump’s lawyer, Jonathan Mitchell, whether he would concede that his client had engaged in insurrection.

Mitchell pushed back, saying, “President Trump did not engage in any act that can be plausibly characterized as insurrection.”

An insurrection, he added, “needs to be an organized, concerted effort to overthrow the government of the United States through violence.”

Jackson appeared incredulous at the narrow definition of the term.

“So your point is that a chaotic effort to overthrow the government is not an insurrection?” she asked.

“This was a riot. It was not an insurrection,” Mitchell responded.

In finding that Trump was ineligible, the Colorado Supreme Court held that Section 3 does apply to the president and that Trump had engaged in insurrection.

Previously, a lower court judge had ruled that there was an insurrection but concluded that Section 3 could not be enforced.

That followed a five-day hearing in a lower state court in which evidence that was submitted included Trump’s tweets, videos of the events of Jan. 6 and the report issued by the now-defunct House committee that investigated the attack.

One recurring theme during the Supreme Court arguments Thursday was the sense of unease on the bench at the idea of the justices having to review a flurry of state court rulings like the one in Colorado barring not just Trump but future presidential candidates from running for office based on claims that they were involved in an insurrection.

Justice Amy Coney Barrett, one of Trump’s three appointees to the court, wondered how the justices were supposed to review the evidence that Colorado courts relied on in concluding there was an insurrection.

She wondered if the justices might have to “watch the video of the Ellipse” and draw their own conclusions, a reference to Trump’s speech on Jan. 6 in which he encouraged his supporters to march to the Capitol.

Justice Samuel Alito, a fellow conservative, seemed to be thinking along similar lines.

“Would we have to have our own trial?” he asked.

Alito was among several justices who expressed concern about other states reaching different conclusions to the Colorado courts, leading to a potentially chaotic election.

At times it appeared that the only person in the courtroom who wanted to speak about how to define an insurrection was Jason Murray, the lawyer representing Colorado voters who say Trump is ineligible.

“We are here because, for the first time since the War of 1812, our nation’s capitol came under violent assault,” he said during his opening remarks.

The attack, he added, “was incited by a sitting president of the United States to disrupt the peaceful transfer of presidential power.”

As far as the Supreme Court is concerned, whether that constitutes an insurrection is likely to remain an open question.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Today in History: November 2, Howard Hughes takes ‘Spruce Goose’ on its only flight

Historic Aviation Milestone: Howard Hughes’ ‘Spruce Goose’ Takes Sole Flight on November 2, 1947

Today marks Sunday, November 2, 2025, the 306th day of the year,…
Carbon capture pipelines have struggled to advance. A project in Nebraska found success

Breakthrough in Nebraska: Carbon Capture Pipeline Project Achieves Milestone Amid Industry Challenges

In a groundbreaking move, the Tallgrass Trailblazer Pipeline began operations in September,…
Outrage as Swedish court refuses to deport convicted rapist, PM promises crackdown

Swedish Court’s Decision Sparks Controversy: PM Vows Tougher Stance on Deportation Laws

A controversial decision by a Swedish appeals court to allow a convicted…
Cruise ship allegedly leaves 80-year-old woman behind on island, daughter demands answers after death

Tragic Oversight: Daughter Seeks Justice After Cruise Ship Allegedly Abandons 80-Year-Old Mother on Island, Leading to Her Death

The daughter of an elderly woman who died after reportedly being left…
Trump administration faces a deadline to tell judges whether it will use contingency funds for SNAP

Deadline Looms for Trump Administration’s Decision on SNAP Contingency Funds Usage

President Donald Trump’s administration is under pressure to respond by Monday to…
War Department escalates campaign against narco-terror at sea with 15th strike: 'They will not succeed'

Defense Department Intensifies Maritime Operations Against Narco-Terrorism with 15th Targeted Strike: ‘Their Efforts Will Fail

The U.S. military has conducted another offensive against what it identifies as…
November’s Super Beaver Moon will be the closest and brightest of the year

Don’t Miss November’s Stunning Super Beaver Moon: 2023’s Closest and Brightest Lunar Spectacle!

On Tuesday night, sky enthusiasts should prepare for an impressive celestial event…
Second inmate in three days dies at Columbia County jail

Alarming Trend: Second Inmate Death in Three Days at Columbia County Jail Raises Serious Concerns

In Lake City, Florida, a female inmate was declared dead after being…
Hamas hands over 3 deceased hostages to Red Cross, Israel says

Hamas Transfers Bodies of 3 Hostages to Red Cross Amidst Ongoing Israel Conflict

In a significant announcement on Sunday, the office of Prime Minister Benjamin…
Sean Brasfield | Father of 18-year-old murdered by stepfather Wellington Dickens III who also killed 3 other children in NC

Heartbreaking Tragedy in NC: Father of Slain Teen Seeks Justice After Stepdad’s Rampage Claims Four Young Lives

In a heart-wrenching tragedy in Durham, North Carolina, the father of Sean…
Matthew Schaefer's late goal helps Islanders beat Blue Jackets

Matthew Schaefer’s Clutch Goal Seals Victory for Islanders Over Blue Jackets

This glimpse into the Islanders’ future was nothing short of thrilling. Matthew…
Ultra-Orthodox protesters in Jerusalem rally over Israel’s draft exemption as clashes break out

Jerusalem Erupts: Ultra-Orthodox Protesters Clash Over Israel’s Military Draft Exemption Controversy

Tens of thousands protest military draft in Jerusalem In a dramatic display…