Share this @internewscast.com

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Friday agreed to consider in a case whether municipal ordinances that bar homeless people from camping on public property violate constitutional protections against “cruel and unusual punishment.”

The justices will review an appeals court ruling, the only one of its kind, which found that ordinances in Grants Pass, Oregon, are prohibited under the Constitution’s 8th Amendment.

The ruling in question was issued by the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in 2022 and applies to all nine states within its jurisdiction, including California. Several of those states have large populations of homeless people.

Among those asking the Supreme Court to overturn the appeals court are local officials in Los Angeles, San Francisco, Phoenix and other cities.

The appeals court ruled 2-1 that Grants Pass, which is about 250 miles south of Portland, cannot “enforce its anti-camping ordinances against homeless persons for the mere act of sleeping outside with rudimentary protection from the elements, or for sleeping in their car at night, when there is no other place in the city for them to go.”

The decision only applies in situations in which homeless people “are engaging in conduct necessary to protect themselves from the elements when there is no shelter space available,” the court added.

The ruling was met with considerable criticism within the appeals court itself, with the entire bench deciding narrowly against reconsidering it in a 14-13 vote.

The decision was a “dubious holding premised on a fanciful interpretation of the 8th Amendment,” wrote one dissenter, Judge Diarmuid O’Scannlain. The ruling has the effect of “paralyzing local communities from addressing the pressing issue of homelessness, and seizing policymaking authority that our federal system of government leaves to the democratic process,” he added.

Lawyers for Grants Pass defended the city’s actions, saying there is “nothing cruel or unusual about a civil fine for violating commonplace restrictions on public camping.”

Theane Evangelis, one of the city’s lawyers, said in a statement that the appeals court ruling has “contributed to the growing problem of encampments in cities across the West.”

The ordinances in question bar sleeping or camping on publicly owned property including sidewalks, streets, bridges and city parks. Punishment can include fines of up to several hundred dollars and exclusion orders barring people from public property.

The case arose after a group of homeless people challenged the application of the ordinances. Lawyers for the plaintiffs said in court papers that the city’s plan is to “drive its homeless residents into neighboring jurisdictions by making it impossible for them to live in Grants Pass without facing civil and criminal penalties.”

Homeless people are being punished for “simply existing,” the lawyers added.

Ed Johnson, a lawyer at the Oregon Law Center who represents the plaintiffs, said in a statement that nothing in the lower court ruling prevents cities from prohibiting camping, it just addresses whether people can be punished for it.

“Nevertheless, some politicians and others are cynically and falsely blaming the judiciary for the homelessness crisis to distract the public and deflect blame for years of failed policies,” he added.

The Supreme Court in 2019, before the appointment of Justice Amy Coney Barrett created a 6-3 conservative majority, declined to take up a similar case from Idaho in which the city of Boise was seeking to enforce a criminal prohibition against camping on public property.

In that case, the 9th Circuit ruled in 2018 that such prosecutions would violate the 8th Amendment. In its 2022 ruling, the same court extended that reasoning to civil penalties, prompting the city to ask the Supreme Court to intervene.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Columbia University student among 5 killed in New York tour bus crash after Niagara Falls visit

Columbia University Student Among 5 Victims in New York Bus Crash After Niagara Falls Trip

Among the five individuals who lost their lives on Friday in an…
Black and white photo of Willeke Dost.

The Enigma of Missing 15-Year-Old ‘Pregnant’ Girl from Foster Care… Investigator Unveils Shocking ‘Predator’ Theory

WHEN a 15-year-old girl failed to show up for breakfast, her foster…
America's last surviving WWII ace Navy fighter pilot Donald McPherson dies at 103 years old

Donald McPherson, America’s Last WWII Ace Navy Fighter Pilot, Dies at 103

Donald McPherson, a World War II veteran recognized as the country’s last…
Anti‑corruption protests hit European nation as calls for new elections grow

Protests Against Corruption Erupt in European Country Amid Rising Demands for Fresh Elections

Serbia’s capital, Belgrade, has become a focal point of unrest as protests…
Keir Starmer at a remembrance service.

Keir Starmer Plans Major Reform of Asylum Appeals to Accelerate Migrant Deportations and Reduce Hotel Stays

KEIR Starmer is planning on overhauling the asylum appeals system in a…
1 dead, 4 wounded after shooting in New York City, police say

Shooting in New York City Leaves 1 Dead and 4 Injured, According to Police

A shooting in New York City on Saturday resulted in one fatality…
Grandmother accused of masterminding family murder-for-hire plot in dentist's killing of professor

Elderly Woman Allegedly Plots Family Murder Scheme Involving Dentist in Professor’s Death

Nearly 11 years following the murder of Florida State University law professor…
Netanyahu slams Australia PM, says he 'betrayed Israel and abandoned Australia's Jews'

Netanyahu Criticizes Australian Prime Minister, Accuses Him of ‘Betraying Israel and Abandoning Australia’s Jewish Community’

Australia and Israel are trading diplomatic blows with each side taking actions…
NATO scrambles warplanes as Russia hits near Romanian border in Ukraine

NATO Deploys Warplanes in Response to Russian Strikes Close to Romanian Border in Ukraine

Two German warplanes were scrambled overnight from Romania after Russia launched a…
Little Village, Chicago community, senators from Mexico rally to support those facing deportation, address immigration raid fears

Mexican Senators Rally in Little Village, Chicago to Support Residents Facing Deportation and Ease Fears of Immigration Raids

CHICAGO (WLS) — A community gathering took place Saturday in response to…
US seeks to deport Abrego Garcia to Uganda

U.S. Plans to Deport Abrego Garcia to Uganda

(The Hill) — The federal government said it would deport Kilmar Abrego…
Illinois leaders speak out on Washington Post report President Donald Trump preparing to deploy National Guard troops to Chicago

Illinois Officials Respond to Report of Trump Planning to Deploy National Guard in Chicago

CHICAGO (WLS) — Illinois officials voiced their concerns on Saturday following a…