Trump strikes a righteous blow at feds' rabid criminal code
Share this @internewscast.com

Last autumn, mountain runner Michelino Sunseri set a new record for climbing and descending Grand Teton, a feat that his sponsor, The North Face, celebrated as the realization of “an impossible dream.”

Not long after, Sunseri faced a legal challenge: He was charged by federal prosecutors with a misdemeanor that could lead to a jail sentence of up to six months. The charge was for using a trail that the National Park Service claimed was closed, despite their failure to adequately communicate this status to the public.

Unknowingly, Sunseri ran afoul of one of the countless federal regulations that carry criminal charges—a legal maze so extensive and unclear that no one is certain how many offenses are actually included in it.

An executive order that President Donald Trump issued last week aims to ameliorate the injustices caused by the proliferation of such agency-defined crimes, which turn the rule of law into a cruel joke.

The Code of Federal Regulations “contains over 48,000 sections, stretching over 175,000 pages — far more than any citizen can possibly read, let alone fully understand,” Trump’s order notes.

“Worse, many [regulations] carry potential criminal penalties for violations.”

How many? As Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch and co-author Janie Nitze note in their 2024 book on “the human toll of too much law,” even experts cannot say for sure, although “estimates suggest that at least 300,000 federal agency regulations carry criminal sanctions today.”

At the federal level, in other words, regulatory crimes outnumber statutory crimes — another uncertain tally — by a factor of roughly 60 to 1.

Since the latter category has exploded during the last century, that is no small feat, but it is what you might expect when unaccountable bureaucrats are free to invent crimes.

“Many of these regulatory crimes are ‘strict liability’ offenses, meaning that citizens need not have a guilty mental state to be convicted of a crime,” Trump notes.

“This status quo is absurd and unjust. It allows the executive branch to write the law, in addition to executing it.”

Trump said prosecutors generally should eschew criminal charges for regulatory violations based on strict liability and focus on cases where the evidence suggests the defendant knowingly broke the rules.

Trump also instructed federal agencies to “explicitly describe” conduct subject to criminal punishment under new regulations, and prepare lists of regulatory violations that already can be treated as crimes.

Given the enormous volume and range of federal regulations, that last requirement is a tall order.

But if the agencies that issue those regulations cannot specify all of the violations that can trigger criminal penalties, what hope does the average American have?

Those penalties may not be readily apparent, because “you need to consult at least two provisions of law to identify regulatory crimes,” GianCarlo Canaparo, a senior legal fellow at the Heritage Foundation, explained in Senate testimony this month.

A regulation that says “Swiss cheese must have holes throughout the cheese,” for example, says nothing about criminal prosecution, which is authorized by a separate provision of the US Code.

Canaparo noted other examples gathered by Mike Chase, author of the comical yet accurate book “How to Become a Federal Criminal.”

It is a federal crime, for instance, “to sell a tufted mattress unless you have burned 9 cigarettes on the tufted part of it,” “to submit a design to the Federal Duck Stamp contest if your design does not primarily feature ‘eligible waterfowl,’” and “to sell a small ball across state lines unless it is marked with a warning that says, ‘this toy is a small ball.’”

Getting a handle on this bewildering situation will require more than prosecutorial restraint, a matter of discretion that is subject to change at any time.

Canaparo argues that Congress should eliminate “excess federal crimes,” add mens rea (“guilty mind”) requirements to provisions that lack them, and recognize a defense for people who did not realize their conduct was unlawful.

As he notes, rampant overcriminalization makes a mockery of the old adage that “ignorance of the law is no excuse.”

Jacob Sullum is a senior editor at Reason magazine.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Fernandina Beach celebrates fifth annual Pride Festival during Pride month.

Fernandina Beach Hosts 5th Annual Pride Festival in Celebration of Pride Month

Fernandina Beach’s fifth Pride Parade fosters unity and inclusion with vibrant festivities,…
Elon Musk hints at new ‘America Party’ as Trump fumes billionaire has ‘lost his mind’ after bitter bromance break-up

Elon Musk Suggests Launching New ‘America Party’ Amid Tensions with Trump After Friendship Fallout

ELON Musk has hinted at launching a new political party amid a…
Pride Fest Chicago: Jesse McCartney and more to perform at 24th year of celebration in Northalsted

Celebrate Pride Fest Chicago: Jesse McCartney Among Performers at 24th Annual Northalsted Event

CHICAGO (WLS) — The 24th annual Chicago Pride Fest 2025 kicks off…
Person holding a carton of eggs in a supermarket.

Recalled ‘Contaminated’ Eggs from Walmart & Safeway Following ‘Multistate Infection Outbreak’ – Full List of Affected States Available

SHOPPERS have been issued a major health warning as millions of eggs…
Rachel Reeves and Angela Rayner smiling and holding hands.

Angela Rayner and Rachel Reeves in Heated Disagreement Over Important Budget Review

ANGELA Rayner and Rachel Reeves are locked in a row over this…
Jackie Robinson and Minnie Minoso mural defaced, vandalized in Miami

Mural of Jackie Robinson and Minnie Minoso Vandalized in Miami

Authorities are conducting an investigation after a mural depicting renowned baseball icons…
Man charged with hate crime in Boulder attack on 'Zionist people' appears in federal court

Boulder Attack Suspect in Hate Crime Against ‘Zionist People’ Appears in Federal Court

A man who admitted to investigators that he aimed “to kill all…
WNBA news: Chicago Sky host Indiana Fever for first-ever women's basketball game at United Center

WNBA Update: Chicago Sky to Welcome Indiana Fever for Historic First Women’s Basketball Game at United Center

CHICAGO — The Chicago Sky are hosting the Indiana Fever Saturday for…
Reckoning: Lisa Murkowski Censured Again by Alaska Republicans

Alaska Republicans Censure Lisa Murkowski Once More

As RedState’s leading (and only) correspondent from Alaska, I feel a bit…
Federal officials slam Democrats for 'dangerous' rhetoric as ICE agents face violent mobs in LA, NYC

Federal Officials Criticize Democrats Over ‘Dangerous’ Language as ICE Agents Confront Violent Crowds in LA and NYC

Protesters tried to obstruct an ICE van’s passage at a Los Angeles…
President Donald Trump and Elon Musk in the Oval Office.

Why Did Trump and Elon Musk’s Relationship Fall Apart? From NASA Dispute to Involvement of Trump’s Young Family Member, Here’s the Truth

THE richest man in the world going toe-to-toe with the most powerful…

Unusual Trend: Celebrities Selling Personal Items Like Underwear and Bathwater

SYDNEY Sweeney has been getting pervy fans hot under the collar after…