As Trump admin pushes Gaza peace plan, history shows UN peacekeeping’s mixed record

The United States’ ambassador to the United Nations, Mike Waltz, unveiled a proposed resolution to the U.N. Security Council on Wednesday, aiming to advance President Donald Trump’s peace initiative for Gaza. This proposal includes setting up an international security force, per a high-ranking U.S. official.

Waltz engaged recently with delegates from Egypt, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, and the United Arab Emirates. These nations are anticipated to collaborate on humanitarian efforts and reconstruction in line with the plan. The draft resolution proposes establishing a two-year international stabilization force in Gaza under U.N. supervision, which is a component of what is being referred to as “phase two” of the comprehensive post-conflict strategy.

Reports from Reuters and the Associated Press indicate that the draft empowers the mission to “employ all necessary measures” to ensure Gaza’s security, safeguard civilians, and initiate the demilitarization of armed factions once major hostilities subside. The strategy also entails creating a transitional “Board of Peace” to work alongside Egypt, Israel, and a selected Palestinian police force.

While Washington has decided against deploying U.S. combat troops, it has requested participation from Muslim-majority nations such as Indonesia, Egypt, the U.A.E., and Turkey. However, Israeli officials have made it clear that Turkish forces will not be permitted along their borders.

The discussions, which included the Palestinian Authority, were a significant diplomatic interaction, highlighting the U.S. plan to eventually return authority to the PA after necessary reforms—a condition that Israel currently opposes, according to Axios.

Israeli tanks are stationed near Gaza

In southern Israel, near the Israel-Gaza border, military vehicles were stationed amid a ceasefire on October 12, 2025. (Ammar Awad/Reuters)

In an interview with Fox News Digital, John Spencer, executive director of the Urban Warfare Institute, said the concept can work — but only if it follows successful precedents. “For Gaza, I personally would like people to think Kosovo, not Lebanon,” he said. “History shows exactly what determines success: a clear mandate, enough troops and the authority to act.”

Kosovo: A model of success

Kosovo Serbs Tensions

Polish soldiers, part of the peacekeeping mission in Kosovo, guard a municipal building in the town of Zvecan, northern Kosovo, May 29, 2023. (AP Photo/Bojan Slavkovic)

After the 1999 NATO campaign, the Kosovo Force (KFOR) deployed under U.N. Security Council Resolution 1244 with about 50,000 troops to stabilize the region, separate combatants and rebuild governance.

“Kosovo gives you the best example,” Spencer said. “It had a clear disarmament mandate, a capable coalition and enough troops to enforce peace.”

He warned that Gaza will require similar patience. “If somebody believes this will just disappear from the news in six months, that’s not reality,” he said, noting that KFOR remains in place decades later, albeit with fewer troops.

Bosnia: Mandate and mass

July 11, 2015: A woman mourns among graves in Memorial Center Potocari, near Srebrenica, Bosnia and Herzegovina.

A woman mourns among graves in Memorial Center Potocari, near Srebrenica, Bosnia and Herzegovina, on July 11, 2015. (AP)

The 1995 Dayton Accords ended the Bosnian war and authorized the NATO-led Implementation Force (IFOR), followed by the Stabilization Force (SFOR). About 60,000 troops were deployed to enforce the peace, separate armies and support reconstruction.

“These were significant forces with clear mandates for disarming,” Spencer said. “That’s what success looks like — a mission with both muscle and legitimacy.”

He added that Gaza’s mission must mirror Bosnia’s strong command structure and clear legal authority, not rely on unarmed observers.

East Timor: Fast-track legitimacy

In this Oct. 24, 1999, photo, then East Timorese rebel leader Xanana Gusmao is embraced as he returns to the Armed Forces of National Liberation of East Timor (FALINTIL) rebel army camp for the first time since his release from an Indonesian prison, in Remexio, in the hills outside of Dili, East Timor. East Timor independence hero Prime Minister Xanana Gusmao resigned as prime minister Friday, Feb. 6, 2015, stepping down ahead of an expected restructuring of the government next week. (AP Photo/Charles Dharapak)

East Timorese rebel leader Xanana Gusmao is embraced as he returns to the Armed Forces of National Liberation army camp after his release from an Indonesian prison in the hills outside of Dili, East Timor on Oct. 24, 1999. (AP Photo/Charles Dharapak)

In East Timor, an Australian-led mission entered under U.N. authority in 1999 after post-independence violence. It restored order and laid the groundwork for local governance.

“East Timor shows how quickly you can start rebuilding governance when the force has legitimacy and local trust,” Spencer said. “That legitimacy must exist from day one in Gaza.”

Lebanon: A cautionary tale

UNIFIL soldier

A member of the UNIFIL force patrols in the southern Lebanese village of Borj El Mlouk, near the border with Israel, on Jan. 7, 2025. (Anwar Amro/AFP via Getty Images)

By contrast, the U.N. Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL), established in 1978 and expanded after the 2006 war, is what Spencer calls a failure.

“Southern Lebanon was not a success story,” he said. “They were glorified observers without a mandate to demilitarize anything.”

Israel has long criticized UNIFIL for allowing Hezbollah to entrench under its watch. Spencer said the same mistake cannot be repeated in Gaza. “It has to be seen as liberating areas from militant rule, not occupying them,” he said.

Lessons for Gaza

Gaza destroyed after bombardment

Destroyed buildings in Gaza, as seen from the Israeli side of the border, July 28, 2025. (Reuters)

Spencer described an “inkblot strategy” — stabilizing cleared districts while combat continues elsewhere. “You can create safe areas where a stabilization force, under the right mandate and equipped correctly, is stabilizing areas while you are also conducting operations against Hamas,” he said.

He predicts that the Israel Defense Forces will continue high-intensity operations while the international force focuses on humanitarian aid, demining and restoring order in secured zones. “Part of the lesson is giving people a vision of life after Hamas,” Spencer said.

During a recent visit to Gaza, Spencer said he saw “a glimmer of hope” in newly established humanitarian zones inside cleared areas. “If you start quickly, even on a small scale, success builds success,” he said.

About 200 U.S. personnel are already on the ground in a civil-military coordination center managing logistics and planning for the proposed transition in Israel. Spencer said this small presence will be vital to coordinating aid, reconstruction and stabilization without engaging in combat.

He warned that the mission will face disinformation and attacks from groups opposed to peace. “There are people who do not want this to succeed,” he said. “Thinking through how they’ll try to undermine it — especially online — is vital.”

He added that stabilization must move alongside local capacity-building. “You have to start training a vetted Palestinian police force and governance team,” he said. “That’s how you build legitimacy.”

You May Also Like

Sheriff investigating Nancy Guthrie disappearance hunting suspect in separate Tucson home invasion

Sheriff Probing Nancy Guthrie Disappearance Searches for Suspect in Separate Tucson Home Invasion

Massive search party deployed in Mexico for Nancy Guthrie Fox News says…
Jacksonville Beach Police Department launches push to educate the public on e-bike laws

Jacksonville Beach Police Explain E-Bike Laws for Riders

The Jacksonville Beach Police Department is rolling out a new public education…
House GOP advances $95 billion plan to fund Iran war and SAVE America Act

House GOP Advances $95B Iran War and SAVE America Act Plan

Washington — The House on Wednesday approved a Republican budget framework that…
Travelers unite in powerful moment of silence as fallen US service member returns home

Travelers Fall Silent as Fallen US Service Member Returns Home

A solemn scene of unity and respect played out inside a crowded…
Beloved artist stabbed, killed in 'random' beach town daytime attack as police arrest 19-year-old suspect

Beloved Artist Fatally Stabbed in Random Daytime Beach Town Attack; 19-Year-Old Suspect Arrested

Pursuit suspect attempts to swim away from authorities A man sought on…
Former CIA Director James Woolsey suffered from Havana Syndrome before his death, wife claims 

James Woolsey Had Havana Syndrome Before Death, Former CIA Director’s Wife Claims

Former CIA Director James Woolsey was battling Havana Syndrome in the years…
Joe Rogan reveals former podcast guest Sheldon Johnson allegedly decapitated a man after appearing on 'The Joe Rogan Experience'

Former Joe Rogan Guest Sheldon Johnson Accused of Beheading

Joe Rogan says a man who had recently appeared on his podcast…
Teachers who once dated and share child arrested after classroom argument spiraled into violence: police

Two Teachers Who Share a Child Arrested After Classroom Argument Turns Violent, Police Say

A private conflict between two Miami teachers who once dated spilled into…
Long Island man Joseph Norton charged with murder after chasing down beloved homeless man Timothy Stark and stabbing him to death off LIE

Long Island Man Charged With Murder in Timothy Stark Stabbing

A 20-year-old Long Island man is accused of fatally stabbing a beloved…
River Forest woman recovers nearly $4K after fake Icelandair support scam

River Forest Woman Recovers Nearly $4K After Fake Icelandair Scam

RIVER FOREST, Ill. — A River Forest woman says she was tricked…
1 in 5 Americans say communism a 'major threat' to US

Poll: 1 in 5 Americans See Communism as a Major US Threat

Red scare, reconsidered. Only about one in five Americans say communism represents…
Sgt. Angel S. Rampersad killed in Iranian attack remembered in touching tributes

Sgt. Angel S. Rampersad Honored With Heartfelt Tributes After Being Killed in Iranian Attack

One of the U.S. soldiers killed in an Iranian attack on an…