Trump DOJ says National Guard deployment in LA is 'unreviewable' in appeals court hearing
Share this @internewscast.com

SAN FRANCISCO (KGO) — During a courtroom session on Tuesday, federal judges seemed to lean towards agreeing with the Trump administration’s stance regarding the deployment of California National Guard troops by President Trump without prior notification to Governor Gavin Newsom.

In a crucial online hearing before the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, the Department of Justice contended that President Donald Trump lawfully utilized his executive authority to dispatch troops to support the protection of federal officers and infrastructures during immigration enforcement protests in Los Angeles.

Just last Thursday, U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer, based in San Francisco, ruled temporarily in favor of California to reinstate Governor Newsom’s control over the National Guard. However, only hours afterward, appellate judges issued a temporary halt on Breyer’s decision, setting the stage for their Tuesday session.

PREVIOUS: Trump can keep National Guard in LA for now after appeals court blocks order

The lawsuit was filed last Monday after President Trump issued a Saturday memo to the Department of Defense ordering “at least” 2,000 National Guard members for 60 days minimum.

Brett Shumate, a U.S. attorney representing Trump, said Breyer’s order interferes with the commander-in-chief’s executive power.

“It upends the military chain of command. It gives state governors veto power over the president’s military orders,” he said. “Courts don’t just defer to the president’s judgment – they don’t review the president’s judgment.”

The panel of three judges – including two Trump appointees – pushed back on the DOJ’s assertion, asking the Trump administration hypothetical questions about how far this lack of judicial review could go.

“If a hypothetical future president made the decision to call up in response the militia of every state and the District of Columbia, so 51 militia, would it also be your view that that decision by this hypothetical future president would be entirely unreviewable?” Judge Mark Bennett, a 2018 Trump appointee, asked.

“Yes, because the statute says the president may call into federal service members and units of the guard of any state in such numbers that he considers necessary,” Shumate responded.

Sam Harbourt with the California Department of Justice argued Trump’s deployment was “extreme” and defies precedent.

“Every day that this order remains in effect, it is causing harm to our nation’s broader democratic tradition of separation of the military from civilian affairs,” he said.

MORE: CA Sen. Alex Padilla, Democrats write letter to Pres. Trump to remove military from Los Angeles

Additionally, California argued the president violated the law by not directly contacting Newsom about his deployment. The statute in question allows federal use of state National Guard troops under certain circumstances and that orders doing so shall be issued “through the governors” of such states. Judges appeared skeptical of this point.

“Where does the statute say that issuing it ‘through the governor’ requires either the governor’s consent or requires consultation?” Bennett asked Harbourt.

“We take it from the plain meaning of through the governor,” Harbourt responded. “We think at a minimum, that means that the governor needs to be informed of it and given the chance to issue it.”

Additionally, the state said Trump’s actions are harming California, since those National Guard members would otherwise be working on wildfire prevention efforts as the state heads into peak wildfire season – a point Newsom made in an earlier statement Tuesday.

MORE: CAL FIRE is hiring: Newsom ramping up recruitment as Nat’l Guard firefighting capacity drops

“President Trump’s illegal militarization of Los Angeles is sidelining crucial firefighting and prevention resources,” the governor said. “It’s time to end the chaos and get California’s National Guard back to this important work.”

The judges did not signal how soon they may issue a decision.

Constitutional law professor Rory Little of UC Law San Francisco said the panel’s questions during Tuesday’s hearings were telling.

“Honestly, I’m not sure the court is receptive to the California position. It sounded to me like this could be a reversal of the district court. This could be affirming of the Trump administration’s position, at least at this preliminary stage,” he said.

Little noted that all action in the courts so far has been preliminary. If the appellate court decides to permanently reverse Judge Breyer’s initial temporary restraining order, the National Guard would remain in Trump’s control for at least 60 days.

“If California wins today, that case will go up to the Supreme Court,” he said. “I think if California loses today, it’ll still go to the Supreme Court.”

Copyright © 2025 KGO-TV. All Rights Reserved.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Friends who discovered Idaho murder victims reveal eerie omen before the massacre

Mother of Idaho murder victim finds surprising solace in controversial plea deal by the killer

The mother of University of Idaho victim Xana Kernodle has broken her…
Protesters and federal agents clash during raid at Southern California farm

Clash Erupts Between Protesters and Federal Agents During Southern California Farm Raid

A clash broke out on Thursday involving protesters and federal agents conducting…
Chicago's 27th Ward Alderman Walter Burnett Jr. wants son to replace him in City Council after retirement, drawing criticism

Chicago Alderman Walter Burnett Jr. faces backlash for proposing his son as successor in City Council’s 27th Ward after retirement

The longest-tenured member of the Chicago City Council is stepping down at…
Shocking New Report About What Far-Left Mamdani Allies Might Be Planning Against Jeffries, Other Dems

Surprising Insights on Potential Strategies by Far-Left Mamdani Supporters Against Jeffries and Fellow Democrats

Democrats are going off the rails, embracing extremism.  But because it’s Democrats,…
Authorities say about 200 immigrants arrested in raids on 2 Southern California farms

Officials Report Arrest of Approximately 200 Immigrants During Raids at Two Southern California Farms

CAMARILLO, Calif. (AP) — On Friday, federal immigration authorities announced the arrest…
Chicago crime: Dion Wallace speaks out after son killed in Logan Square stabbing, fire; Wendy Tolbert charged after 3 kids stabbed

Tragedy in Chicago: Father Dion Wallace Shares Loss After Son’s Death in Logan Square; Wendy Tolbert Faces Charges in Stabbing Incident Involving 3 Children

CHICAGO (WLS) — A Chicago father is speaking out after a tragedy…
Las Vegas security guard Kegia Mitchell sentenced for killing customer Thomas Martin over COVID-19 protocols

Las Vegas Security Officer Kegia Mitchell Sentenced for Fatal Incident Involving COVID-19 Protocols

A security guard from Las Vegas received a prison sentence ranging from…
Airport security subdues a disruptive passenger.

Dramatic Scene: Woman Throws Temper Tantrum at Airport, Screams at Police Before Being Arrested

THIS is the shocking moment a furious passenger had a full-blown foot-stomping…
California clinic staffers seek to shield ICE agents from detaining Honduran landscaper

California Clinic Employees Strive to Protect Honduran Landscaper from ICE Detention

At a surgical center in California, staff members were recorded on video…
World's oldest domesticated dog breed has cohabited with humans for 1,000 years, new study shows — but their population is plummeting

Ancient Dog Breed, Living Alongside Humans for a Millennium, Faces Rapid Decline, New Research Reveals

It gives new meaning to dog years. For nearly 10,000 years, people…
'I couldn't stay silent anymore'

‘I Had to Speak Up’

Actor Derek Dixon from “The Oval” has stepped forward after filing a…
Soldier walking past Patriot air defense systems at a military hub.

Russia Claims Trump is ‘Backing Terrorists’ Following US Decision to Send Weapons and Patriots to Ukraine Through NATO

RUSSIA has lashed out at Donald Trump after the US president agreed…