University students feel 'anxious, confused and distrustful' about AI in the classroom and among their peers

University Students Wary and Uncertain About AI in Education and Among Friends

The rise of generative AI has sparked concern and frustration in the academic world for predictable reasons: Initial research indicates that these AI tools can weaken critical thinking and hinder problem-solving abilities. Additionally, numerous reports suggest that students might be using chatbots to commit academic dishonesty.

But how do students feel about AI? And how is it affecting their relationships with peers, instructors and their coursework?

As a member of a research group at the University of Pittsburgh focusing on AI and undergraduate education, I am aware that there is an increasing amount of research examining generative AI’s impact on higher education. However, we are concerned that one crucial demographic—our students—is not sufficiently represented in this research, despite being especially qualified to provide insights on the topic.

In the spring of 2025, our research team conducted multiple focus groups with 95 students from our campuses. Our findings revealed that whether or not students and faculty are actively engaged with AI, it is having a noteworthy interpersonal and emotional impact on learning dynamics and classroom trust. Beyond affecting learning methods, AI technologies like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude are altering the relationships between students and their professors, as well as among students themselves.

‘It’s not going to judge you’

Most of our focus group participants had used AI in the academic setting – when faced with a time crunch, when they perceive something to be “busy work,” or when they are “stuck” and worry that they can’t complete a task on their own. We found that most students don’t start a project using AI, but many are willing to turn to it at some point.

Many students described positive experiences using AI to help them study or answer questions, or give them feedback on papers. Some even described using AI instead of a professor, tutor or teaching assistant. Others found a chatbot less intimidating than attending office hours where professors might be “demeaning.” In the words of one interviewee: “With ChatGPT you can ask as many questions as you want and it’s not going to judge you.”

But by using it, you may be judged. While some were excited about using AI, many students voiced mild feelings of guilt or shame about their AI use due to environmental or ethical concerns, or just coming across as lazy. Some even expressed a feeling of helplessness, or a sense of inevitability regarding AI in their futures.

Anxiety, distrust and avoidance

While many students expressed a sense that faculty members are, as one participant put it, “very anti-ChatGPT,” they also lamented the fact that the rules around acceptable AI use were not sufficiently clear. As one urban planning major put it: “I feel uncertain of what the expectations are,” with her peer chiming in, “We’re not on the same page with students and teachers or even individually. No one really is.”

Students also described feelings of distrust and frustration toward peers they saw as overly reliant on AI. Some talked about asking classmates for help, only to find that they “just used ChatGPT” and hadn’t learned the material. Others pointed to group projects, where AI use was described as “a giant red flag” that made them “think less” of their peers.

These experiences feel unfair and uncomfortable for students. They can report their classmates for academic integrity violations – and enter yet another zone in which distrust mounts – or they can try to work with them, sometimes with resentment. “It ends up being more work for me,” a political science major said, “because it’s not only me doing my work by myself, it’s me double checking yours.”

Distrust was a marker that we observed of both student-to-teacher relationships and student-to-student relationships. Learners shared fears of being left behind if other students in their classes used chatbots to get better grades. This resulted in emotional distance and wariness among students. Indeed, our findings reflect other reports that indicate the mere possibility that a student might have used a generative AI tool is now undercutting trust across the classroom. Students are as anxious about baseless accusations of AI use as they are about being caught using it.

Students described feeling anxious, confused and distrustful, and sometimes even avoiding peers or learning interactions. As educators, this worries us. We know that academic engagement – a key marker of student success – comes not only from studying the course material, but also from positive engagement with classmates and instructors alike.

AI is affecting relationships

Indeed, research has shown that faculty-student relationships are an important indicator of student success. Peer-to-peer relationships are essential too. If students are sidestepping important mentoring relationships with professors or meaningful learning experiences with peers due to discomfort over ambiguous or shifting norms around the use of AI technology, institutions of higher education could imagine alternative pathways for connection. Residential campuses could double down on in-person courses and connections; faculty could be incentivized to encourage students to visit during office hours. Faculty-led research, mentoring and campus events where faculty and students mix in an informal fashion could also make a difference.

We hope our research can also flip the script and disrupt tropes about students who use AI as “cheaters.” Instead, it tells a more complex story of students being thrust into a reality they didn’t ask for, with few clear guidelines and little control.

As generative AI continues to pervade everyday life, and institutions of higher education continue to search for solutions, our focus groups reflect the importance of listening to students and considering novel ways to help students feel more comfortable connecting with peers and faculty. Understanding these evolving interpersonal dynamics matters because how we relate to technology is increasingly affecting how we relate to one another. Given our experiences in dialogue with them, it is clear that students are more than ready to talk about this issue and its impact on their futures.

You May Also Like

Penn State Jewish Studies slammed for hosting ‘disgusting and abhorrent’ lecture on 'need to decolonize' Holocaust museums

Penn State Jewish Studies Slammed Over ‘Decolonize’ Holocaust Lecture

Pennsylvania State University was skewered online for hosting a Jewish studies lecture…
Scientists warn of possible ‘ARkStorm,’ historic California flooding

Scientists Warn ARkStorm Could Trigger Historic California Flooding

California could be staring down a weather catastrophe of historic proportions, with…
‘World’s most wanted’ OnlyFans model desperately wants to leave US — after allegedly entering illegally, overstaying visa

‘World’s Most Wanted’ OnlyFans Model Seeks to Leave US

The Dutch OnlyFans creator who allegedly attempted to enter the US illegally…
California utility PG&E lays off more than 200 workers across state

California Utility PG&E Lays Off More Than 200 Workers Statewide

California’s largest electric utility has eliminated more than 200 positions statewide, including…
Europe assassination scheme emerges as Iran denies DC 'dirty bomb' plot amid Trump warning

Iran Denies DC Dirty Bomb Plot as Europe Assassination Scheme Emerges

Iran on Tuesday rejected allegations that it was preparing a chemical weapons…
Sadist accused of killing Sonia Exelby after meeting on fetish site had ultra-violent videos on phone, court hears

Sonia Exelby murder accused had ultra-violent videos, court hears

Disturbing images depicting women being raped, tortured and murdered were allegedly found…
White House withdraws Heidi Overton's FDA bid after nominee received bipartisan pushback

White House Pulls FDA Nominee Heidi Overton Amid Bipartisan Pushback

The White House has withdrawn Heidi Overton’s nomination to lead the Food…
Illinois ethanol plant bomb threat suspect ID's as worker Andrew Kozak

Worker Andrew Kozak Named Suspect in Illinois Ethanol Plant Bomb Threat

An Illinois ethanol plant employee with a decades-long criminal record has been…
American Airlines passenger Arthur Layne Lundeen has Maryland assault charges dropped

American Airlines Passenger Arthur Lundeen Cleared in Maryland Assault Case

An Arizona Realtor whose belligerent, racist outburst forced a Newark-bound flight to…
Supreme Court rejects case on Trump's bid to cut research grants related to DEI

Supreme Court Rejects Case Over Trump DEI Research Grant Cuts

Washington — The Supreme Court on Monday declined to take up a…
Mullin defends use of government plane to go to college football game after ground stop

Sen. Markwayne Mullin Defends Government Plane Use for College Football Game During Ground Stop

WASHINGTON — Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin on Tuesday defended taking a…
REPORT: NBC Broadcast Legend Dan Hicks' Cause of Death Revealed

Report Reveals NBC Broadcast Legend Dan Hicks’ Cause of Death

Dan Hicks, the longtime NBC Sports broadcaster, died last week at 64…