In the wake of a tragic incident involving Alphanso Talley, new insights into his extensive criminal record have emerged, prompting a wave of concern among some elected officials in Chicago. The focus of this uproar is the judicial use of electronic monitoring, which critics argue is being inappropriately applied to defendants who pose significant risks to public safety.
Talley, 26, has accumulated over six felony charges since 2017. Before the recent, grave events, Talley was already wanted for evading electronic monitoring. The system’s perceived flaws have been thrust into the spotlight following the fatal shooting of a Chicago police officer and the critical wounding of another at Swedish Covenant Hospital this past Saturday. Officer John Bartholomew was tragically killed in the line of duty.
ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch
On Monday, Talley faced a court hearing charged with multiple felonies, including murder and attempted murder. This case has ignited calls for reform from various quarters, highlighting what some see as failures in the current system. Illinois Comptroller Susana Mendoza expressed her dismay, stating, “We should not be here today. This is a consequence of a failed system.”
The courtroom was filled with elected officials, police union representatives, and concerned citizens, all advocating for stricter accountability for judges who allow potentially dangerous individuals to be monitored electronically rather than incarcerated. The collective sentiment is that the current practice needs urgent reevaluation.
“It should end right now, absolutely, and now hold them accountable in there. You guys need to be held accountable. I’m held accountable every single day. They’re held accountable by just getting out of the car answering a call. Something needs to be done, and something needs to change today,” declared 41st Ward Alderman Anthony Napolitano, echoing a widespread call for immediate action and reform.
“It should end right now, absolutely, and now hold them accountable in there. You guys need to be held accountable. I’m held accountable every single day. They’re held accountable by just getting out of the car answering a call. Something needs to be done, and something needs to change today,” said 41st Ward Ald. Anthony Napolitano.
Talley’s arrest record includes two robberies in 2017, including one where he was charged with using a handgun.
In 2022, he pleaded guilty to being a felon in possession of a firearm.
In 2024, he was charged with another felony after attacking a Cook County correctional officer.
In 2025, he was arrested for carjacking a woman at gunpoint.
Judge John Lyke, who handled the case, agreed to let Talley out on electronic monitoring, so he could go to college. When his monitoring device died because Talley did not charge it, Lyke issued an arrest warrant on March 11, but there is no record of anything being done to follow up.
The warrant was still active on Saturday, when Talley allegedly robbed a Family Dollar store in Albany Park, which, later that morning, led to hospital shooting that killed Officer John Bartholemew and left his partner critically wounded.
“Officer Bartholomew would be alive today if his massively repeat offender of violent crime after violent crime were behind bars where he belonged, instead of free to roam our streets and caused the mayhem that he did in a hospital,” Mendoza said.
“Our attention is going nowhere until we get the change that we need, and if that means we have to clear out this building of every judge who will not listen, then I say, vote no on retention. Push them all out. Eventually, they will get the message that they are held accountable,” said 15th Ward Ald. Ray Lopez.
INTERACTIVE SAFETY TRACKER Track crime and safety in your neighborhood
Copyright © 2026 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.
