3.9k Share this

All UK taxpayers will from now on be complicit in legalised human trafficking, following the unveiling of the government plan to fly asylum seekers to Rwanda (UK Rwanda plan for asylum seekers decried as inhumane, expensive and deadly, 14 April). Rwanda has a dubious human rights record. The UK is handing over the safety and human rights of possible refugees, allegedly persecuted in their own countries, to Rwanda, a country that in 2010 was among the 10 lowest-ranked countries in the world for press freedom.
Tirthankar Bandyopadhyay
Hounslow, London

History seems to be in danger of repeating itself. In the first half of the 19th century, the Royal Navy was dispatched to west Africa to intercept the shipment of enslaved Africans across the Atlantic. Many of the naval initiatives were considered illegal at the time. Those “liberated” by naval action were then sent around the Atlantic world. They were given no choice as to where they would be “resettled”. Under the policy, perhaps 100,000 Africans were “rescued” from transatlantic slavery, but a further 3.5 million were still shipped to the Americas between 1807 and 1867, a million of them illegally. One suspects that the UK government’s politically motivated scheme will fare no better in inhibiting the activities of 21st-century people traffickers.
Prof David Richardson
Wilberforce Institute, University of Hull

As a historian, I was reminded of the suggestions by several 1930s British fascist organisations that Jews should be exiled to Madagascar. Tory leaders’ contempt towards parliament also recalls the interwar fascist view of parliamentary democracy as an effete anachronism that could be undermined and superseded. While the Conservative party is not a fascist party, it is undoubtedly halfway down the road to fascism.
Dr Martin Pugh
Slaley, Northumberland

Having worked in Rwanda, I believe the Home Office plan will be ineffective and poor value for money. Many of the people crossing the Channel originate from Iran, Iraq and Syria. Culturally, they are unlikely to integrate into Rwandan society, which is of a predominantly Christian tradition and has different cultural values. In view of Israel’s abortive attempt at a similar plan for the resettlement of its African migrants and the closure of the Australia’s offshore processing in Papua New Guinea, it would be folly to proceed.
Dr Joseph Mullen
Former UN adviser to Rwanda

The minister for Brexit opportunities once again excels in ambiguity (Rwanda asylum plan is ‘almost Easter story of redemption’, says Rees-Mogg, 17 April). Yes, the plan to send refugees to Rwanda is reminiscent of some aspects of the Easter story. Possibly the part where an innocent man is arrested, detained, tortured and killed, to satisfy an angry nationalist mob. And the part where due legal process is abandoned to help an incompetent, amoral administrator out of his personal political mire. Yes, so much like Easter.
Neil Ross
Newark-on-Trent, Nottinghamshire

The government claims that sending asylum seekers to Rwanda is a challenge to the people traffickers’ business model. What next? Take on the loan sharks by moving their victims into workhouses?
Margaret Fowler
Salford

Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication.

Source: This post first appeared on The Guardian

3.9k Share this
You May Also Like

Squatting over toilets may carry risk of UTIs warn experts

For these reasons, people may benefit from sitting, as opposed to hovering…

Bobby Brown on Having Recurring Dreams About His Deceased Children

Celebrity kids have it hard in the spotlight having to constantly be…

Tom Ford And BTS Deliver Initiatives Against Plastic Pollution

BEVERLY HILLS, CA – FEBRUARY 22: Fashion designer/director Tom Ford arrives at…
Ardern, 41, urged the Ivy League graduates to pursue 'genuine debate and dialogue' to keep conversations and 'solutions' going instead of ending in a dead-end and to engage in social media cautiously in her commencement speech on Thursday at Harvard University

New Zealand PM urges Harvard students not to cancel people they disagree with in commencement speech

New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern urged Harvard graduates not to cancel…

World Outrage Grows Toward Russia—This Time Over Food Crisis Sparked By Invasion

Topline Several high-level global officials criticized Russia on Tuesday morning for its…

Bridgerton’s Phoebe Dynevor and Jonathan Bailey meet Prince Charles at the Prince’s Trust Awards

Bridgerton‘s Phoebe Dynevor and Jonathan Bailey looked delighted as they met with…

Where Is Azealia Banks Now? Find Out What Happened To Her

Emma Tustin: The Whole Truth About Arthur Labinjo-Hughes Step Mother Was Cici…

What We Know About Killer Teen Who Opened Fire at Elementary School, Killing 19 Children – Crime Online

New details are emerging about the 18-year-old Texas teen who opened fire…