In the realm of online MAGA communities, modesty often takes a backseat, especially among ‘traditional’ Christian women who share their lives with fervent followers.

Such dynamics are evident in the heated rivalry between two self-proclaimed Christian influencers, who collectively boast millions of followers across various social media platforms.

Isabella DeLuca, a former Turning Point USA figure, and Isabella Moody, a provocative voice in right-wing circles, are entangled in an intensifying dispute that is not only testing allegiances but also riveting their extensive young female fanbase. The conflict ignited over a seemingly innocuous bikini photograph.

The exchange of harsh words has reached new heights, with accusations of hidden romantic interests and marital difficulties emerging in exclusive discussions with the Daily Mail.

The rivalry between these MAGA commentators dates back to 2022 when their friendship shattered following Moody’s allegations that DeLuca was copying others’ content.

Moody, who is married with a new baby, often critiques DeLuca, a devout Christian and participant in the January 6 events, for her bold social media presence.

‘She’s a lying sl*t,’ Moody told the Daily Mail while accusing DeLuca of being dishonest about not wanting to post risqué photos. 

‘She still is [posting revealing photos] while claiming to be some conservative Christian woman that will never post sl*tty photos because she’s waiting for her future husband.’

DeLuca’s bikini started a massive argument between her and Moody over modesty within online MAGA circles

Isabella Moody once dressed as a bride with a female friend in college for a Halloween party

Moody is married to her husband Josiah. The couple have a child and live in Arizona

DeLuca, meanwhile, accused Moody of sleeping with married men while also having a lesbian past in college. 

‘She was a lesbian. She had a fake lesbian wedding in college,’ DeLuca told the Daily Mail.

‘And there’s a picture of her kissing another woman and they’re both wearing bride lingerie costumes.’

DeLuca then suggested that Moody’s frequent criticism may be rooted in her alleged lesbian desires. 

‘There’s a lesbian on this app that’s constantly talking about me and now has a hot screenshot of me from three months ago in her phone. Like maybe there, maybe there’s something there.’

During Moody’s college days, she and a close female friend dressed up as scantily clad brides for a Halloween party. A picture emerged online recently showing Moody kissing her at the soirée. 

Moody admits that she was an atheist during her college days, but she’s embraced a new Christian life. 

‘I’m embarrassed about it, but it’s a part of my past… I’m not a lesbian!’

DeLuca then suggested that Moody’s frequent criticism may be rooted in her alleged lesbian desires

When asked about DeLuca’s insinuation that Moody has a secret sexual desire for her, the right-wing provocateur gave a blunt response.

‘She’s stupid,’ Moody said. ‘No.’

During Isabella’s phone call interview with the Daily Mail, her husband, Josiah Moody, could then be heard saying, ‘She’s such a narcissist! She thinks you want to f*** her! That’s hilarious!’

Meanwhile, DeLuca claims that Moody’s husband initially wanted to marry her instead of his current wife.

DeLuca describes the 22-year-old Josiah as ‘literally looking like a child’ and claims Moody is jealous.

‘Josiah, was constantly messaging me, asking him to take me out, telling me he was gonna marry me, even messaging my mom, telling me that he was gonna marry me,’ DeLuca mused.

‘I never went for Josiah, I never entertained it because Josiah was practically a child. Yeah. Okay. Well, now Isabella Riley Moody starts going out with him, they get married, they have a baby.

‘Really weird situation, in my opinion. So it’s like, I feel like there’s some maybe jealousy because your husband wanted me first. I feel like there’s discontent in her current relationship.’

DeLuca describes the 22-year-old Josiah as ‘literally looking like a child’ and claims Moody is jealous

Josiah, however, claims that DeLuca first contacted him by ‘sliding’ into the comment section on his Instagram page years before he met her rival Moody.

‘Isabella DeLuca slid into my comment section on my Instagram,’ Josiah said. ‘She commented, she was thirsty, she wanted me.

‘Most Isabellas do. And so, yeah, I mean, we talked and I know her mom, her mom was down for us to like hang out or date or whatever.

‘My mom was cool with it too. It was like all in my comment section on an Instagram post. I was 17 at the time. I think she was older. But this is all like in the past.’

Moody then provided the Daily Mail a recorded video of an Instagram post from Josiah dated August 24, 2021, showing her husband smiling at the camera with the caption, ‘You a blonde female? Hit my DM.’

Under the comment section of the post, DeLuca wrote the following comment: ‘Hi [attached with an emoji of a blonde woman raising her hand].’

DeLuca and Moody’s friendship ended in December 2021 after the former was fired from a PR firm following accusations of plagiarism.

DeLuca and Moody’s friendship ended in December 2021 after the former was fired from a PR firm following accusations of plagiarism

DeLuca claims that Moody’s husband initially wanted to marry her instead of his current wife

According to Moody, who served in the company as director of content management at Arsenal Media group, DeLuca was hired on September 17, 2021 and fired just after Christmas a few months later. 

‘This is what she’s known for. Even people that don’t work at Arsenal, they know DeLuca plagiarizes tweets and she’s so shameless about it.

‘Word for word, verbatim! It’s like you almost have to give her some points for how shameless she is.’

DeLuca’s early career online started in 2021 after she became an ambassador for Turning Point USA in college at Stony Brook University in New York.

Her relationship at TPUSA went as high as the organization’s now-deceased founder Charlie Kirk.

In October 2020,  Kirk claimed DeLuca had been assaulted at a Women’s March rally, claiming she was ‘assaulted by BLM activists while at a rally for our great president.’

The future of this conflict is uncertain as the two influencers continue throwing accusations of unholiness at each other.

Moody resides in Arizona with her husband and child, while DeLuca lives not too far away in East Texas. 

Every few months the conflict dies down before one-party throws out new bombshell accusations, leading to more attention and online engagement from the young MAGA followers.