We need to talk about those final few moments of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season 2.

Warning: this article contains spoilers for Season 2 of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives. Read at your own risk.

Before Jen Affleck took a step back from the show to focus on her mental health, she hinted at the possibility of something more occurring between Demi Engemann and Vanderpump Villa star Marciano Brunette, after their encounter at Lisa Vanderpump’s castle in Italy last summer.

In Vanderpump Villa Season 2, Brunette charmed Engemann, but their interaction appears limited to flirtatious exchanges and a heartfelt poolside conversation, culminating in a warm embrace and Brunette kissing Engemann on the side of her head. Despite this, a social media feud has erupted between them, with Engemann accusing him of sexual assault and Brunette alleging that an unidentified Mormon wife got him uninvited from a Hulu event to keep her husband from uncovering the truth.

Speculation points to Engemann as the unidentified individual, based on their past interactions in Italy. Adding intrigue, Affleck’s husband discloses in The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season 2 that Engemann issued a cease and desist letter after Affleck alluded to the issue. However, Layla Taylor seeks clarity by meeting with Brunette in person, leading to an unforeseen plot twist.

First, we have to rewind.

Earlier in the season, Jessi Ngatikaura addressed an online rumor that she was seen making out with Brunette at Vanderpump’s TomTom restaurant in Los Angeles. While Ngatikaura — whose husband Jordan had a bigger role this season — shut down the accusations, Brunette confirmed to Taylor that not only were they making out, but they’ve also allegedly had sex.

“It’s not like this was just some freaking one-night stand,” Brunette says, to which a stunned Taylor replies, “No, it’s full-blown fucking affair.”

According to Brunette, Ngatikaura’s husband “doesn’t know the truth about how extensive it was.” He also claims they’ve “tried meeting up” on other occasions to continue their alleged affair.

Whether this is true remains to be seen, but if it is then messy Jessi just got a whole lot messier. In a brief teaser for The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season 3, Ngatikaura appears to deny Brunette’s claim, while Jordan suggests it was all Engemann’s doing (perhaps as retaliation for voting her out of MomTok after many episodes of mean-girl behavior).

We’ll just have to wait and see how it all unfolds when Season 3 comes out!

The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season 2 is currently streaming on Hulu.