Share this @internewscast.com

A New York man who killed a teen girl decades ago will spend the next 25 years behind bars.

Joseph Belstadt, 46, was found guilty of the death of 17-year-old Mandy Steingasser last week. The incident happened in Niagra Falls in September 1993 after Beldstadt broke into the victim’s car before strangling and beating her.

“It was a horrendous and violent crime,” Niagara County District Attorney Brian D. Seaman said last week. “He fractured this girl’s skull and strangled her with her own bra. That kind of calls for the maximum sentence.”

After Judge Michael Mohun handed down a 25-year sentence, Belstadt “shook his head and looked down,” according to the Union-Sun & Journal.

“I am innocent. I’ve said that from day one. I did not kill Mandy Steingasser,” Belstadt said before his sentencing.

Joseph Belstadt/Police Handout

Evidence, however, suggests otherwise. Two mushroom hunters found the victim’s lifeless body in a ravine at the Meyers Lake area of Lewiston Park. She had been beaten and strangled, with a skull fracture found by her ear, The Buffalo News reports.

Investigators found the teen’s bra wrapped around her neck. They also found Beldstadt’s pubic hair in the floorboard of Steingasser’s car.

In 2018, investigators utilized new forensic testing which led them to Beldstadt after a DNA match. Police said Bledstadt’s story changed numerous times when they interviewed him. He first said he dropped the victim off at church and left for Canada, but later said he dropped her off and went to a doughnut shop.

The defense argued that none of the suspect’s DNA was actually found on the victim, but the jury ultimately agreed with the prosecution. His lawyers reportedly said they are gearing up to start an appeal.

Check back for updates.

For the latest true crime and justice news, subscribe to the ‘Crime Stories with Nancy Grace’ podcast. 

Join Nancy Grace for her new online video series designed to help you protect what you love most – your children.

[Feature Photo: Family Handout] Source: This post first appeared on

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Tragic Incident at Spirit Halloween: Security Guard Fatally Confronts Alleged Shoplifter

Inset: Josiah Armijo (Metropolitan Detention Center). Background: The Spirit Halloween store located…

Unbelievable Jailhouse Romance: Man’s Bold Scheme to Reunite with Girlfriend Behind Bars

Inset left: Aaron Oldham (Oklahoma County Sheriff’s Office). Inset right: Christine Hillier…

Shocking Revelations: Kada Scott’s Alleged Abductor Linked to Another Chilling Assault

A man facing charges related to the kidnapping of a Pennsylvania woman…

Shocking CCTV Footage: Beauty Queen Suspect Caught Stalking First Victim with Chilling Threats

In the days leading up to her disappearance, Kada Scott confided in…

Suspect Claims Police Responsible for Deadly High-Speed Pursuit

Inset left: Donald Wayne Rownan (Washington Department of Corrections). Inset right: Paola…

Family Shares Emotional Struggles of Melbourne Stabbing Survivor Afraid to Go Out in Public

The family of a woman who was reportedly stabbed in an unprovoked…

Long Island Teacher Arrested for Soliciting Explicit Photos from Undercover Decoy Posing as Teen

A teacher from an elementary school on Long Island has been taken…

Emergency Hearing Scheduled to Address Alleged Violations by Trump Administration

President Donald Trump speaks before Steve Witkoff is sworn as special envoy…

Self-Proclaimed ‘Savage’ Sentenced for Gruesome Dismemberment of Teacher

Left: Harold Francis Landon III (Prince George”s County police). Right: Mariame Toure…

Jared Fogle’s Surprising Prison Life: How the Former Subway Spokesman is Spending His Time Behind Bars

Jared Fogle, once the face of Subway, asserts that he was misled…

Unveiling the Chilling Pursuit: How a Suspect Trailed Kada Scott Before Her Mysterious Disappearance

A Pennsylvania man implicated in the disappearance of a local woman will…

Tragic Unveiling: Georgia Baby’s Cause of Death Disclosed After Heartbreaking Yard Discovery

Tragedy has struck in Clayton County, Georgia, as authorities have determined the…