Share this @internewscast.com

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Wednesday will consider whether to block a Biden administration policy aimed at reducing air pollution that crosses from one state to another and creates harmful smog.

The court is hearing four related cases involving challenges to the policy brought by three Republican-led states — Indiana, Ohio and West Virginia — and various affected industries, including natural gas pipeline operators.

The Supreme Court, which has a 6-3 conservative majority, has been skeptical of broad exertions of federal power on regulatory issues, including the environment.

In 2022, the court limited the ability of the Environmental Protection Agency to use the Clean Air Act to combat emissions that contribute to climate change. Last year, the court weakened the landmark Clean Water Act by limiting the EPA’s regulatory oversight over wetlands.

Recently, the court has been treating environmental policies like they are “guilty until proven innocent,” said Sam Sankar, a lawyer at environmental group Earthjustice.

The “good neighbor plan,” introduced by the EPA last year, seeks to curb nitrogen oxide pollution from industrial facilities. If implemented in full, it would apply to 23 “upwind” states whose emissions can contribute to pollution in “downwind” states.

The EPA says the plan would help prevent premature deaths, reduce emergency room visits and cut asthma symptoms by limiting the amount of smog.

Under the Clean Air Act, states get a chance to draw up their own pollution control plans. Each state has a responsibility under the law to be a “good neighbor,” meaning that its plans address pollution that can contribute to other states that are not meeting their own obligations.

The EPA can step in to adopt its own plan, which is what happened last year. The three states object to the federal government’s approach, saying in part that they didn’t have enough time to come up with their own plans.

The agency’s approach “ignored obvious problems with its attempt to twist the Clean Air Act into a system of top-down regulation instead of the system of cooperative federalism that Congress intended,” Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost wrote in court papers.

Yost called the policy “a disaster” because court rulings in separate litigation mean it has already been blocked in 12 of the 23 states it applies to, meaning it only reaches 25 percent of the emissions it seeks to regulate.

Republican-led states frequently complain about robust EPA interventions over environmental policy, citing it as an example of federal overreach that infringes on the right of states to govern themselves.

Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar, who is defending the rule, said in court papers that it is in “full force” and able to “function properly” in the 11 states where it is in effect. The fact that it is currently blocked in some states does not undermine the validity of the rule as a whole, she added.

If the regulation were to be put on hold while litigation continues, it would “delay efforts to control pollution that contributes to unhealthy air in downwind states, which is contrary to Congress’s express directive that sources in upwind States must assume responsibility for their contributions to emissions levels in downwind states,” Prelogar wrote. 

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Michigan lawyer says a Halloween terror plot that FBI Director Kash Patel described never existed

Michigan Attorney Refutes FBI’s Halloween Terror Plot Claims as Nonexistent, Challenges Director Kash Patel’s Statements

A defense attorney in Michigan is challenging claims made by FBI Director…
Joyful Day of the Dead commemorations rally US Latino communities despite immigration raid fears

Vibrant Day of the Dead Celebrations Unite US Latino Communities Amidst Immigration Raid Concerns

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — Over a hundred attendees joined Aztec dancers as they…
Tinley Park boy Alex Anning hosts Chicago food giveaway at Carrie Jacobs Bond Elementary School for 8th birthday

Young Philanthropist Alex Anning Celebrates 8th Birthday with Heartwarming Food Giveaway at Chicago School

Inside Carrie Bond Elementary School in Englewood, a heartwarming act of generosity…
Jacksonville animal shelter sees surge in cat and dog adoptions

Adopt a Furry Friend for Free All November at ACPS Jacksonville!

Jacksonville, Fla. — The spirit of Halloween may have faded, but a…
New video purportedly shows Louvre thieves in action during brazen daytime heist

Louvre Museum Heist Unravels: Two New Suspects Charged in Expanding Investigation

Parisian prosecutors have revealed that two additional individuals have been implicated in…
Salvador Lozano charged with attempted murder for Addison shooting, police standoff in 200-block of East La Porte Drive: officials

Breaking: Salvador Lozano Faces Attempted Murder Charges After Addison Shooting and Intense Police Standoff

A 45-year-old man from Addison, Illinois, is facing attempted murder charges after…
D.C. Mayor Enacts 'Juvenile Curfew' After 'Weeks of Disorderly' Behavior

Washington D.C. Implements Youth Curfew to Combat Rising Disorderly Conduct

In response to what she described as “weeks of disorderly juvenile behavior,”…
Former Kentucky Gov. Martha Layne Collins has died at 88

Remembering Martha Layne Collins: Trailblazing Former Kentucky Governor Passes Away at 88

Martha Layne Collins, a trailblazer in Kentucky’s political landscape as the first…
National Guard, police confront hundreds of juveniles amid Halloween chaos in DC’s Navy Yard

National Guard and Police Address Large Youth Gatherings During Halloween Disruptions in DC’s Navy Yard

A video has surfaced depicting scenes of turmoil in Washington, D.C., during…
Gif of a boat being blown up, as announced by Secretary of War Pete Hegseth

Mothers of Victims Applaud Trump’s Effective Crackdown on Narco-Terror Boats

Anne Fundner never anticipated that the tragic loss of her 15-year-old son,…
Cops release photo of hulking suspect in fatal stabbing of Harlem man, 51

Police Unveil Image of Suspect in Harlem Man’s Fatal Stabbing: Public Assistance Sought

Authorities have released a mugshot of a suspect linked to a fatal…
JSO: College Park shooting stems from argument during video games

Jacksonville Authorities Probe Domestic Incident Resulting in Man’s Injury

In Jacksonville, Florida, a man is on the mend after sustaining a…