Karen Read’s silence in murder trial raises stakes for defense

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

Karen Read’s legal team has chosen not to put her on the witness stand, a risky move that could either benefit or harm her case, especially after the prosecution presented incriminating interview clips from her second murder trial. These clips allow the jury to hear Read’s perspective in her own words.

Read faces a possible life sentence for allegedly murdering her boyfriend, Boston police officer John O’Keefe. The prosecution alleges that Read, during a drunken argument, hit O’Keefe with her Lexus SUV and left him to die of exposure in the front yard of a friend’s house party shortly after midnight on January 29, 2022.

Read’s defense team insists her vehicle never made contact with O’Keefe and there was no collision. 

“When I first started practicing, the advice was ‘never put your client on the stand, ever,’” said New York City defense attorney Louis Gelormino to Fox News Digital. “However, I sometimes disagree with that. I believe we’ve achieved our biggest victories when our client does testify.”

Lu said the defense has not attempted to address the video clips or provide context regarding Read’s version of events at this point in the trial. 

“So, the same trial plus the damaging video, where the jury almost convicted, is bad for the defense,” Lu said. 

As the defense continues calling witnesses, the notable absence of Read’s own testimony will likely only be fully felt once the jury reads its verdict, with the prosecution acting as the only side that opted to include her own words in the courtroom.  

“Based on the fact that they had a hung jury the last time, [the defense has] a decent case,” Gelormino told Fox News Digital. “So do you want to mess that up with having her defend her actions and character for the next two or three days on the stand? That’s a tough decision.” 

You May Also Like
President Donald Trump delays nomination hearing for own director of intelligence, or DNI, nominee Jay Clayton amid FISA lapse

Trump Delays Jay Clayton DNI Hearing as FISA Lapse Sparks Intelligence Oversight Questions

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump on Wednesday threw his own nominee’s confirmation…
Chicago crime: Suspect Merlin Lu, 21, charged with hate crime, arson for burning cross in Grant Park, police say

Chicago Police Charge 21-Year-Old Merlin Lu With Hate Crime, Arson After Cross Burning in Grant Park

CHICAGO (WLS) — A 21-year-old Chicago man is facing a series of…
Elon Musk demands prison for politicians who 'turned a blind eye' to grooming gangs as new report released

Elon Musk Calls for Jail Time for Politicians Who Ignored Grooming Gangs, Explosive New Report Reveals

Elon Musk thrust Britain’s grooming gangs scandal back into the international spotlight…
Austin Metcalf’s dad supported Karmelo Anthony judge’s hard line on cameras

Austin Metcalf’s Father Backs Judge’s Tough Stance on Cameras in Karmelo Anthony Case

FRISCO, Texas — Jeff Metcalf, the father of Austin Metcalf, said he…
Luigi Mangione battles to block key evidence a year after CEO assassination — experts say it’s a long shot

Luigi Mangione’s Emotional Disturbance Defense Could Reshape His Other Case, Lawyer Says

Attorneys for Luigi Mangione, the 28-year-old former Ivy Leaguer charged in the…
More than a million Knicks fans line the streets to celebrate team's first title in 53 years: Photos

NYC Erupts as Over 1 Million Knicks Fans Celebrate First NBA Title in 53 Years: Photos

Fans packed Manhattan’s famed “Canyon of Heroes” on Thursday, June 18, 2026,…
US and Iran sign initial deal to end war, ease sanctions and open strait as nuclear talks continue

US-Iran Initial Deal Signals Path to Ending Conflict, Easing Sanctions and Reopening Strait

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump on Wednesday signed an accord with Iran…
Wife speaks out after husband allegedly strangles disabled daughter to death in New Jersey

New Jersey Wife Breaks Silence After Husband Allegedly Strangles Disabled Daughter to Death

FRANKLIN TWP., N.J. — The family of Devin Hall is now preparing…
Austin Metcalf’s dad supported Karmelo Anthony judge’s hard line on cameras

Jeff Metcalf Breaks His Silence on Son Austin’s Death—How His Family Is Finding Strength and Moving Forward

FRISCO, Texas — Jeff Metcalf, whose son Austin Metcalf was killed in…
11 suspected illegal immigrants among 15 arrested in $1.4M benefits fraud crackdown in Massachusetts, DOJ says

Massachusetts Benefits Fraud Bust: 15 Arrested, Including 11 Suspected Illegal Immigrants, in $1.4M DOJ Crackdown

Federal authorities brought a nationwide welfare fraud crackdown to Massachusetts this week,…
Guards at 'Alligator Alcatraz' beat, pepper-sprayed detainees, lawyer says

DHS Evacuates All Detainees From ‘Alligator Alcatraz’ as Hurricane Threat Forces Emergency Move

All detainees housed at “Alligator Alcatraz,” a migrant detention center in the…
South Carolina personal trainer goes missing, last spotted walking toward wooded area

SLED Joins Investigation After Body Found Matches Description of Missing South Carolina Personal Trainer

South Carolina’s lead investigative agency, the State Law Enforcement Division (SLED), joined…