Karen Read murder case verdict reached after deadlocked first trial

Juror explains how Karen Read was acquitted in boyfriend's death case

One of the 12 jurors who acquitted Karen Read of murder charges in the death of her Boston police officer boyfriend John O’Keefe shared the jury’s decision-making process on Thursday, following the conclusion of her second trial.

The juror also explained brief confusion Wednesday afternoon that arose out of a verdict that jurors later retracted before it was read in court.

Judge Beverly Cannone sealed that one. Within minutes, jurors handed down a verdict for real.

“Everything on that initial slip was the same as the slip that was presented,” Juror No. 4, known only as “Jason,” stated on TMZ Live. He mentioned that they revisited the first slip concerning the OUI charge—operating under the influence of liquor—which was the charge they found her guilty of.

Noble and the department faced lawsuits from true crime reporters and some of Read’s advocates regarding the enforcement of a “buffer zone” around the Dedham courthouse, which their attorneys argued was unconstitutional.

Separately, local police in Canton, Massachusetts, were subjected to an external audit that recommended increased training and oversight while dispelling claims of a conspiracy to frame Read for O’Keefe’s death.

A federal investigation into the case ended without charges against members of either law enforcement agency.

You May Also Like

Second Student Arrested After Two Alleged Attacks Rock College Campus in Weeks

Second Student Arrested After Two Alleged Attacks Rock College Campus in Weeks

A Wichita State University student was arrested Saturday on suspicion of rape,…
ICE nabs illegal migrant in NYC wanted for murder in Guyana

ICE Arrests NYC Migrant Wanted for Murder in Guyana

Federal immigration authorities have arrested a Guyanese man in Queens who is…
Shot 12 times in ambush that killed his partner, Philadelphia officer leaves hospital to cheers

Philadelphia Officer Shot 12 Times Leaves Hospital After Deadly Ambush

Philadelphia police Officer Hector Rodriguez III received a hero’s welcome over the…
Florida woman goes viral for reporting crash while in banana costume

Florida Woman Goes Viral Reporting Crash in Banana Costume

She came to the rescue in a peel-worthy disguise. A Florida woman…
Ghoulish thief caught on camera stealing Halloween decor from family's lawn: report

Halloween Decoration Thief Caught on Camera Stealing From Family Lawn

A Halloween thief was captured on camera stealing several spooky decorations from…
Florida woman set man on fire, burning over 80% of his body following argument: cops

Florida woman accused of setting man on fire after argument

A Florida woman allegedly asked to borrow a lighter before setting a…
15-year-old busted for shooting at Florida A&M University party that injured 11, including kids: cops

15-Year-Old Held in FAMU Party Shooting That Hurt 11, Including Kids

A 15-year-old boy has been arrested in connection with a shooting at…
DOJ Charges 28 Alleged Noncitizen Voters in California Fraud Case

DOJ Charges 28 Alleged Noncitizen Voters in California Fraud Case

More than two dozen people arrested last week in what authorities describe…
Microsoft Offers Buyouts to 60,000 Workers Amid AI Spending Push

Microsoft Offers Buyouts to 60,000 Workers Amid AI Spending Push

Microsoft is offering voluntary buyouts to approximately 60,000 employees—about a quarter of…
NJ con man admits to stuffing Marine vet cousin's body in closet to collect benefits

New Jersey Man Admits Hiding Marine Veteran Cousin’s Body to Collect Benefits

A New Jersey man concealed his military veteran cousin’s body in a…
Violent crime victimization fell 25% in 2025 over prior year, survey released by DOJ shows

DOJ Survey Finds Violent Crime Victimization Fell 25% in 2025

A preliminary survey released Monday found that the violent crime victimization rate…
Reckless visitors are destroying Yellowstone's iconic thermal pools with trash

Reckless Visitors Litter Yellowstone’s Iconic Thermal Pools

By early October, Yellowstone National Park crews had removed more than 23,000…