The Supreme Court has postponed its ruling regarding a planned pro-Palestinian demonstration on the Sydney Harbour Bridge, originally scheduled for Sunday afternoon.
The Palestine Action Group submitted a request for 10,000 participants to march across the bridge to show support for Palestinians and draw attention to the humanitarian issues in Gaza.
Earlier in the week, NSW Premier Chris Minns declined the group’s permission due to advice that there wasn’t sufficient time for authorities to prepare resources for the event. NSW Police initiated legal proceedings to have the march declared illegal and unauthorized.
In NSW, there is a permit process allowing protesters to block public thoroughfares, but the police have the ability to challenge this through the courts.
The organizing entity, Palestine Action Group Sydney, has committed to holding a rally irrespective of the judicial decision and has not disclosed the location, concluding a Facebook announcement with “whatever happens, see you on Sunday”.
Parallel events are lined up in Melbourne and Adelaide, and an online petition in favor of the Sydney march has garnered over 15,000 endorsements.
Organisers and NSW Police present their cases
Spectators overflowed in the Supreme Court in Sydney on Friday, with journalists and members of the public finding spaces to sit on the floor.
NSW Police requested the rally to be deemed unauthorised, pushing for the court to revoke protesters’ immunities to block public roads.
Representing the state police, Lachlan Gyles SC argued they would not be able to maintain a safe environment if the protest was authorised and that closing the bridge was not reasonable in under a week’s notice.
“This is really unprecedented in terms of scale, the level of risk, the lack of time to prepare,” he told the court.
He accused the organisers’ spokesman, Josh Lees, of ignoring his duty of care to public safety.
Under cross-examination, acting assistant police commissioner Adam Johnson raised the possibility of a crowd crush.
“I’m personally concerned about that,” he said.
But Lees disputed the claims.
“We (Palestine Action Group) want to work with them to facilitate a march over the bridge that is safe and peaceful,” Lees said.
The group’s barrister Felicity Graham told the court it would be safer for police to authorise the protest, as people would march regardless of Justice Belinda Rigg’s decision.
“A prohibition order may well increase the number of people who attend the protest, and exacerbate the potential for unrest and violence,” she said.
Ahead of the ruling, Lees said the organisation was open to delay the rally if the police are willing to work with them.
“We proposed everything needed by August 24 for a march following the same route over the Sydney Harbour Bridge as the World Pride March in 2023,” Lees commented outside the Supreme Court on Friday.
Police would retain certain powers to address antisocial behaviours, even if the protest is authorised, Graham said.
She said the groundswell of support for the march, including from members of parliament, organisations and high-profile figures, must also be taken into account.
Rigg has reserved her decision until 10am on Saturday.
Politicians set to join the march
Several trade unions had endorsed the march, while 15 state politicians — including five NSW Labor MPs — said they were planning to march on Sunday.
One of the Labor politicans, Stephen Lawrence, said in a social media post on Friday morning that “the event is now absolutely inevitable, largely because of the way it has been mishandled”.
Minns, who has blamed demonstrators for draining police resources for nearly two years in their facilitation of weekly protests in the city’s centre, said earlier in the week that he “cannot allow Sydney to descend into chaos”.
The laws were called into question in a recent open letter written by Australian Lawyers for Human Rights, which said they run contrary to Australia’s civil rights obligations under an international treaty.
The bridge has previously been shut, including for a reconciliation rally in 2000 which attracted more than 250,000 people, a World Pride event with Prime Minister Anthony Albanese’s participation and a Hollywood film production.
Among other objectives, protesters aim to shine a spotlight on the humanitarian crisis that has engulfed the Gaza Strip.
Since 7 October 2023, the Gaza health ministry has recorded 156 deaths from starvation and malnutrition, most of them in recent weeks, including at least 90 children.
Nearly 60,000 Palestinians have been killed in Israel’s subsequent campaign against Hamas in Gaza, according to Palestinian health officials.
Confronted by rising international outrage over images of starving children, Israel said it would halt military operations for 10 hours a day in parts of Gaza and designate secure routes for convoys delivering food and medicine.
SBS News reported this week that Israel’s ambassador to Australia, Amir Maimon, and deputy chief of mission, Amir Meron, were called in for a meeting with the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade.
