Father admits gunning down man on suburban street but says it's not murder
Share this @internewscast.com

A father has admitted he gunned down another man in a suburban street but says it was a clumsy accident.

Lawyers for Luke James Picking told a Victorian Supreme Court jury the 42-year-old did kill Abdurhman Jemal, 33, in March 2024.

But they denied he committed murder, arguing Picking did not mean to pull the trigger and he should instead be found guilty of manslaughter.

Luke James Picking arrives at the Melbourne Supreme Court in Melbourne today.
Luke James Picking arrives at the Melbourne Supreme Court in Melbourne today. (AAP)

“What happened here was a warning that went wrong,” Picking’s barrister Peter Morrissey SC told the jury today.

Prosecutors allege Picking and his son Brodi, 19, ambushed Jemal outside a Glenroy shopping strip in Melbourne’s north about 4.30am on March 29.

Brodi, who is also on trial for murder, knew Jemal but the pair had a falling out in early March after Brodi accused the 33-year-old of stealing his wallet.

Abdurhman Jemal murder Melbourne
Abdurhman Jemal stumbled back to his car and managed to press down on the horn before he collapsed. (James Ross/AAP PHOTOS)

Prosecutors allege in the hour before the shooting, Brodi and Luke Picking drove past locations connected to Jemal, including his mother’s home.

It’s alleged they located Jemal driving a red Hyundai in Glenroy and followed the 33-year-old until he pulled over and confronted them.

CCTV footage played to the jury showed yelling between the two groups before Jemal was shot in the face.

Prosecutors allege Luke Picking said “you want a f—ing air raid” to Jemal before firing the bullet and speeding off.

Jemal stumbled back to his car and managed to press down on the horn before he collapsed.

He died after suffering multiple shotgun pellets to the face and neck.

Morrissey told the jury Luke Picking was responsible for Jemal’s death and had already offered a plea to manslaughter, which prosecutors rejected.

The barrister argued Picking had only intended to threaten Jemal and it went wrong.

“He did mean to present the gun … but he didn’t mean to pull the trigger,” Morrissey told the jury.

Morrissey said there would be evidence from a neurologist, who had identified issues with Picking’s hands that caused him to be clumsy.

Brodi Picking’s barrister Rishi Nathwani KC conceded his client was in the car when Luke fired the fatal shot. 

But he told the jury Brodi did not know there was a loaded gun in the vehicle and he never made an agreement with his father to murder Jemal.

“He did not positively assist or encourage his dad to do so,” Nathwani said.

It was also disputed that Brodi was still upset about the stolen wallet at the time of the shooting, the barrister said.

Prosecutors allege after the killing, Luke Picking contacted his friend Ian Harris, 49, to dispose of the gun.

Harris’ barrister Rahmin de Kretser accepted his client did take possession of the firearm but argued Harris did not know it had been used to kill someone.

de Kretser told the jury they should have great doubts his client was guilty of assisting an alleged murderer.

The trial before Justice Jane Dixon continues.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Unveiling Secrets: Exclusive Interview with Maureen ‘Cookie’ Rowan’s Daughter on the Little Miss Panasoffkee Cold Case

Press release from TheColdCases.com GAINESVILLE, Fla. – In a poignant revelation, TheColdCases.com…

Family in Distress as Investigation Unfolds into Anna Kepner’s Cruise Ship Ordeal

The family of Anna Kepner is grappling with heartache and confusion as…

Shocking Ohio Case: Man Posing as Teen Targets Vulnerable Kids in Online Exploitation

A Middletown man, aged 53, is facing a lengthy prison sentence after…

Police Report: Woman Stabbed Following Cigarette Request

Inset: Pamela Puskar (McCabe Funeral Home). Background: Glenn Whittier being escorted to…

Mother and Partner Face Charges in Infant’s Tragic Death

Inset left top to bottom: Elizabeth LynnLanor Hogan and Devin Austin Brown-Fowler…

Court Delivers Verdict for Man Convicted of Stabbing 11-Year-Old at Sleepover

Inset: Ricardo Perez Castillo appears in a booking photo (Kent County Sheriff”s…

Urgent Search for Missing Alabama Brothers, Ages 6 and 7: Police Request Public Assistance

The Autauga County Sheriff’s Office is reaching out to the community for…

Authorities Report 15-Year-Old Suspect in Shooting of Bicyclist with Taurus 9mm

Inset: Tommy Lagree (Orange County Sheriff”s Office). Background: The 4900 block of…

Probation Violation: Man Arrested with 125 Grams of Marijuana Sparks Legal Controversy

Staff Report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – In the early hours today, authorities apprehended…

Adelaide Stabbing Leaves Man in Critical Condition: Police Investigate

A 32-year-old man is in critical condition following an alleged stabbing incident…

Thanksgiving Tragedy: Man Sets Neighbor’s Home Ablaze, Police Report

Inset: Ora Wallace (Vernon County Sheriff”s Office). Background: The home on County…

Family Ties Under Scrutiny: Fiancé and Sister Charged in Case of Missing Pregnant Woman

Inset left to right: Richard Falor, Kimberly Park and Rebecca Park (Wexford…