Share this @internewscast.com
US Supreme Court judges raised doubts on Wednesday over the legality of President Donald Trump’s sweeping tariffs in a case with implications for the global economy that marks a major test of Trump’s powers.
Both conservative and liberal judges sharply questioned the lawyer representing Trump’s administration about whether the president had intruded on the power of Congress in imposing tariffs under a 1977 law meant for use during national emergencies.
But some of the conservative judges also signalled that they were wrestling with their recognition of the inherent power that presidents have in dealing with foreign countries, suggesting the court could be sharply divided in the outcome of the case.

The Supreme Court currently comprises a 6-3 conservative majority.

In a session that extended over two and a half hours, justices probed the legality of Trump’s use of a 1977 statute to enforce tariffs indefinitely, questioning if such significant executive actions necessitate explicit authorization from Congress.

The challenge involves three lawsuits brought by businesses affected by the tariffs and 12 US states, most of them Democratic-led.

Trump has mounted pressure on the Supreme Court, urging it to uphold tariffs which he considers pivotal to his economic and foreign policy strategies.

The tariffs — taxes on imported goods — could add up to trillions of dollars for the United States over the next decade.

Utilizing the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA), Trump applied tariffs affecting almost all of the United States’ trading partners.

Typically, the Supreme Court deliberates for several months before delivering decisions, but the Trump administration has requested an expedited ruling in this matter, leaving the decision’s timeline uncertain. Source: AAP / Kent Nishimura / POOL / EPA

Trump solicitor general John Sauer kicked off the arguments by defending the legal rationale employed by the president, but immediately faced questions raising scepticism over the administration’s arguments about the language and purpose of the statute at issue.

Under IEEPA, the president is empowered to address “an unusual and extraordinary threat” during a national emergency.

Donald Trump wearing a suit standing at a podium, holding up an executive order in front of a crowd

While the US Supreme Court typically takes months to issue rulings after hearing arguments, the Trump administration has asked it to act swiftly in this case, though the timing of the decision remains clear. Source: AAP / Kent Nishimura / POOL / EPA

IEEPA gives the president power to deal with “an unusual and extraordinary threat” amid a national emergency.

It had historically been used for imposing sanctions on enemies or freezing their assets, not to impose tariffs.

Sauer said Trump determined that US trade deficits have brought the nation to the brink of an economic and national security catastrophe.

But what does the law say?

The US constitution grants Congress, not the president, the authority to issue taxes and tariffs.
The imposition of taxes on Americans “has always been the core power of Congress,” conservative chief justice John Roberts told Sauer, adding that these tariffs seem to be raising revenue, which the constitution contemplates as a role for Congress.
Conservative justice Amy Coney Barrett questioned Sauer about his argument that IEEPA’s language granting presidents emergency power to “regulate importation” encompasses tariffs.

“Can you point to any other place in the code or any other time in history where that phrase together ‘regulate importation’ has been used to confer tariff imposing authority?” Barrett asked.

Trump is the first president to use IEEPA to impose tariffs, one of the many ways he has aggressively pushed the boundaries of executive authority since he returned to office in areas as varied as his crackdown on immigration, the firing of federal agency officials and domestic military deployments.

Does the court have power over Trump?

US treasury secretary Scott Bessent said in the lead-up to the arguments that if the Supreme Court rules against Trump’s use of IEEPA, his tariffs are expected to remain in place because the administration would switch to other legal authorities to underpin them.
In fact, conservative justice Samuel Alito asked about a different statute that has gotten less attention, known as Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930, could provide an alternate basis for Trump’s tariffs.

Liberal justice Elena Kagan pressed Sauer about his claim that Trump’s tariffs are supported by the president’s inherent powers under the constitution.

Kagan said the power to impose taxes and regulate foreign commerce are usually thought of as “quintessential” powers belonging to Congress, not the president.
Conservative justice Brett Kavanaugh signalled potential sympathy for Trump, noting that former president Richard Nixon imposed a worldwide tariff under IEEPA’s predecessor statute in the 1970s that contained language similar to “regulate importation”.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Parilla Fresh has recalled multiple products over Salmonella fears.

Urgent Recall: Popular Salad Brand Linked to Salmonella Outbreak Sickening 44 – Is Your Health at Risk?

Alfalfa sprouts have been pulled from supermarket shelves across the country amid…
Famed film director Lee Tamahori has died at home in New Zealand at the age of 75. The Hollywood stalwart had been battling Parkinson's disease, his family revealed to New Zealand's public broadcasting company on Friday. 'His legacy endures with his whānau, his mokopuna, every filmmaker he inspired, every boundary he broke, and every story he told with his genius eye and honest heart,' his family told RNZ.

Legendary James Bond Director Lee Tamahori Passes Away at 75 After Battling Illness

Renowned filmmaker Lee Tamahori has passed away at the age of 75…
Sophia Begg is one of Australia's most recognisable young influencers and co-founder of fashion brand All For Mimi.

Young Entrepreneur Shares Common Jobseeker Mistake to Avoid

Exclusive Series Launch: Today, nine.com.au is debuting a new series where we…
Inmate mistakenly released from London prison arrested

Escaped Inmate Recaptured: London Prison’s Mistaken Release Sparks Security Review

A convicted sex offender who was mistakenly released early from a London…

Palestinian Militants Release Israeli Hostage’s Body in Tense Exchange

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office said a coffin carrying the remains…
Former chief of staff at NAB Rosemary Rogers has been jailed for a maximum of eight years.

Ex-NAB Staffer Receives Eight-Year Sentence for $5.5 Million Fraud Scheme

A former bank executive has been sentenced to prison after embezzling funds…

Princess Anne Set to Visit Australia Amidst Prince Andrew’s Title Removal Controversy

Princess Anne is set to land in Australia in one of the…

Sudan’s Rapid Support Forces Embrace US-Arab Proposal for Humanitarian Truce: A Step Toward Peace

Sudan’s paramilitary Rapid Support Forces agreed to a proposal from the United…
Thousands of flights to be cut across US airports amid government shutdown

US Airports Brace for Turbulence: Thousands of Flights Slashed as Government Shutdown Looms

Some of the busiest airports in the United States, including those serving…
Newsreader Martine Croxall.

BBC Newsreader’s Facial Expression Sparks Controversy Over Broadcasting Standards Violation

A BBC news presenter has been found in violation of the network’s…
Scotland skipper Sione Tuipulotu shows off his country's commemorative jersey for the Murrayfield Test against the All Blacks

Scotland Skipper Tuipulotu Rallies Team Spirit Ahead of Epic Showdown Against All Blacks: 67,000 Fans Expected!

Scotland’s captain, Sione Tuipulotu, is rallying his squad to seize the moment…
One Australian city enjoying the sun today will feel temperatures dramatically plummet by up to 20 degrees tomorrow.

City Experiences 25-Degree Temperatures Today, Expected to Drop to 5 Degrees Tomorrow

An Australian city is experiencing a brief spell of warm weather, but…